Conversation
| "pip", | ||
| "scikit-build>=0.14.0", | ||
| "setuptools==59.2.0", | ||
| "setuptools>=59.2.0", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I normally wouldn't recommend pinning setuptools on an upperbound unless you have an explicit reason, but v71 changed how it vendors its dependencies in a major way. https://setuptools.pypa.io/en/latest/history.html#v71-0-0
Where it'll prefer already installed deps over its vendors. This can cause issues if the environment has an older version of a dep installed (which wasn't problematic before for setuptools, as it'd use it's own vendor anyway).
Note that running pip install setuptools[core] would install the necessary dependencies along with setuptools.
Given the various distributions and dockerization of opencv-python, it might be warranted to progressively relax this pin by first going to:
| "setuptools>=59.2.0", | |
| "setuptools>=59.2.0,<71.0.0", |
Leaving this to the maintainers whether that's a concern 😄
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I'm reticent to introduce an upper-bound with neither any observed problems nor a plan to fix any anticipated problems. But I'm happy to commit the suggestion if maintainers agree it's prudent.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Yeah same, figured I'd at least let it be known.
|
I tried installing OpenCV on macOS in a virtual environment, with the suggestion by @Avasam of I'm on macOS 11.7.10, Python 3.12.5. I upgraded to Python 3.12.6 and have the same issue. I tried in a new virtual environment, and I tried it twice. |
The option |
|
@mm3509 I'm glad you were able to install opencv-python. N.B. Installation under python 3.11 always has worked. This patch aims to support 3.12. It will be helpful to determine whether this fix works under macOS, and if not what does. |
|
Thank you Bryan. You can count on me to test any patches on macOS :) At the moment, I am out of ideas for how to make it work. |
|
FYI this PR does appear to work for getting opencv-python to install (in Home Assistant's "wheels" container which is based on Alpine Linux and Python 3.13); took me 35 minutes on a Intel CPU from 2021. |
|
@bryankaplan or @asmorkalov , could you retrigger this PR's CI? (closing & reopening should work), I don't recall the reason for test failure and I'm guessing it doesn't have to do with this PR. Even if this doesn't fix everyone's issues. It should be an objective improvement. |
Currently, opencv-python fails to build under python 3.12. This patch fixes that problem by permitting the use of any setuptools>=59.2.0, rather than mandating that specific version. This patch fixes opencv#988. See discussion there for details. I have tested by successfully installing opencv-python.
11cb9fc to
218a392
Compare
Same failure as before:
|
|
Ah so just opencv's self-hosted runenrs being unavailable ( |
|
Replaced by #1061. |
Currently, opencv-python fails to build under python 3.12. This patch fixes that problem by permitting the use of any setuptools>=59.2.0, rather than mandating that specific version.
This patch fixes #988. See discussion there for details.
I have tested by successfully installing opencv-python.