cip-19: Review status

[Wondertan]

Change status to review

[Wondertan]

Or is it In Review? Also, where is the list of all the possible statuses?

[jcstein]

Review is correct, in CIP-1, https://github.com/celestiaorg/CIPs/blob/main/cips/cip-1.md#cip-process

[Wondertan]

Found it, CIP-1

[jcstein]

While CIP-1 doesn't mention anything about how long a CIP remains in Draft before going to Review, should this remain in Draft longer than just a few hours? cc @YazzyYaz @rootulp @ebuchman

[Wondertan]

Actually, @jcstein, let's keep it as a draft; I will add one more container and ID type for the eds.

[rootulp]

While CIP-1 doesn't mention anything about how long a CIP remains in Draft before going to Review, should this remain in Draft longer than just a few hours? cc @YazzyYaz @rootulp @ebuchman

IMO there doesn't need to be a minimum time enforced on how long a CIP is in Draft before moving to Review.

Actually, @jcstein, let's keep it as a draft; I will add one more container and ID type for the eds.

Sounds good. Should this PR be closed?

[Wondertan]

We may, but the transition to review will happen anyway, and it's also the case that the change will be strictly additive and won't change the existing doc, so it still makes sense to keep what exist in the review stage

[rootulp]

I'm confused on the back and forth behind moving this to review but approving to unblock. Seems like not a big deal to make modifications to this doc even after it has been moved to review.

[Wondertan]

@rootulp, we are new to the process and there are many little edge-cases like this one. I am thinking both directions to see the best one. I didn't mean to confuse you.