Recalculate Route Without Profiles Changing does not update GPX

[david-gpu]

Description

When you select a track and click on "Recalculate Route Without Profiles Change", the route is updated on the screen. However, if you then click on the "Save" button on the upper right corner, the GPX is left unchanged.

Steps to reproduce

Open a track. Click on the bottom right icon that indicates which type of routing is used. This opens a menu that reads "Route between points". Scroll down and click on "Recalculate Route Without Profiles Changing".

A new route will appear on the screen after a few seconds -- e.g. because the map has changed or because routing.xml is different from the last time the route was computed. Now click on the "Save" button on the upper right corner.

Actual result

The track remains unchanged after saving.

Note that the new route will be saved if you click on a transportation method, such as Cycling. But if you select "Recalculate Route Without Profiles Changing" then the changes are not saved.

Expected result

The track should be updated with the new route as it appeared on the screen after "Recalculate Route Without Profiles Changing" was clicked.

Your Environment (required)

WARNING Crash-Logs MAY contain information you deem sensitive.
Review this CAREFULLY before posting your issue!

OsmAnd Version: 4.8.6
Android/iOS version: Android 13
Device model: Samsung A71
Crash-Logs: ?

[yuriiurshuliak]

The bug is reproducible. To reproduce it, follow these steps:

• Import the track Furkot_Test_Route_-_2.zip.
• Navigate to Menu → Plan a route → Open existing track → Options → Route between points.
• Select Recalculate route without profile changing.
• Then choose a profile, such as car, and wait for the route to be recalculated.
• Save the track.

As a result, after recalculating, the track is updated, but once you save it and review the changes, they won’t appear. Instead, the original track will be displayed without the modifications.

OsmAnd~ 4.9.0#3258m, released: 2024-09-23

video_2024-09-23_13-32-56.mp4

[nazar-kutz]

It looks like the problem has already been fixed. I can't reproduce it anymore.

[david-gpu]

Were you ever able to reproduce it yourself, or only somebody else?

Because I can still reproduce this issue on Android 4.9.4 (2024-11-05) beta.

[yuriiurshuliak]

@david-gpu On our end, GPX track changes are successfully saved and displayed. I attempted to reproduce the issue on multiple tracks using the nightly version, but without success. Please check if this issue persists for you on the nightly version: Nightly builds.

If the issue persists, please attach a video of the error and export the GPX track where it occurs.

[Zirochkabila]

OsmAnd~ 5.0.0#3793m, Released: 2024-11-25
Done