diff --git a/lib/dotcom_web/components/trip_planner/itinerary_group.ex b/lib/dotcom_web/components/trip_planner/itinerary_group.ex
index e1dd1c2d01..afe02d802d 100644
--- a/lib/dotcom_web/components/trip_planner/itinerary_group.ex
+++ b/lib/dotcom_web/components/trip_planner/itinerary_group.ex
@@ -15,13 +15,14 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.Components.TripPlanner.ItineraryGroup do
   def itinerary_group(assigns) do
     ~H"""
     <div class="mb-3 p-2 border border-2 border-slate-200">
+      <% [first | rest] = @group %>
       <div class="text-slate-800 font-bold">Group with <%= Enum.count(@group) %> options</div>
-      <.accordion :for={{variation, index} <- Enum.with_index(@group)} open={index === 0}>
+      <.accordion>
         <:heading>
-          <%= format_datetime(variation.departure) %> — <%= format_datetime(variation.arrival) %>
+          <%= format_datetime_full(first.departure) %> — <%= format_datetime_full(first.arrival) %>
         </:heading>
         <:content>
-          <div :for={leg <- variation.legs}>
+          <div :for={leg <- first.legs}>
             <.leg
               start_time={leg.start}
               end_time={leg.stop}
@@ -32,13 +33,21 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.Components.TripPlanner.ItineraryGroup do
               realtime_state={leg.realtime_state}
             />
           </div>
+          <%= if Enum.count(rest) > 0, do: "Similar trips depart at:" %>
+          <span :for={alternative <- rest}>
+            <%= format_datetime_short(alternative.departure) %>
+          </span>
         </:content>
       </.accordion>
     </div>
     """
   end
 
-  defp format_datetime(datetime) do
+  defp format_datetime_full(datetime) do
     Timex.format!(datetime, "%-I:%M %p", :strftime)
   end
+
+  defp format_datetime_short(datetime) do
+    Timex.format!(datetime, "%-I:%M", :strftime)
+  end
 end
diff --git a/test/dotcom/trip_plan/itinerary_group_test.exs b/test/dotcom/trip_plan/itinerary_group_test.exs
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..34e362f3c9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/test/dotcom/trip_plan/itinerary_group_test.exs
@@ -0,0 +1,104 @@
+defmodule Dotcom.TripPlan.ItineraryTest do
+  @moduledoc false
+
+  use ExUnit.Case, async: true
+
+  import Mox
+
+  alias Dotcom.TripPlan.ItineraryGroups
+  alias Test.Support.Factories.{Stops.Stop, TripPlanner.TripPlanner}
+
+  setup do
+    stub(Stops.Repo.Mock, :get, fn _ ->
+      Stop.build(:stop)
+    end)
+
+    stops = TripPlanner.build_list(3, :stop_named_position)
+
+    {:ok, stops: stops}
+  end
+
+  describe "from_itineraries/1" do
+    test "groups itineraries with the same mode, from, and to", %{stops: [a, b, c]} do
+      # SETUP
+      bus_a_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: a, to: b)
+      subway_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:subway_leg, from: b, to: c)
+
+      itineraries =
+        TripPlanner.build_list(:rand.uniform(5), :itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, subway_b_c_leg])
+
+      # EXERCISE
+      grouped_itineraries = ItineraryGroups.from_itineraries(itineraries)
+
+      # VERIFY
+      assert Kernel.length(grouped_itineraries) == 1
+    end
+
+    test "does not group itineraries with different modes", %{stops: [a, b, c]} do
+      # SETUP
+      bus_a_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: a, to: b)
+      bus_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: b, to: c)
+      subway_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:subway_leg, from: b, to: c)
+
+      first_itinerary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_b_c_leg])
+      second_interary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, subway_b_c_leg])
+
+      # EXERCISE
+      grouped_itineraries = ItineraryGroups.from_itineraries([first_itinerary, second_interary])
+
+      # VERIFY
+      assert Kernel.length(grouped_itineraries) == 2
+    end
+
+    test "does not group itineraries with different froms", %{stops: [a, b, c]} do
+      # SETUP
+      bus_a_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: a, to: b)
+      bus_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: b, to: c)
+      bus_c_a_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: c, to: a)
+
+      first_itinerary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_b_c_leg])
+      second_interary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_c_a_leg])
+
+      # EXERCISE
+      grouped_itineraries = ItineraryGroups.from_itineraries([first_itinerary, second_interary])
+
+      # VERIFY
+      assert Kernel.length(grouped_itineraries) == 2
+    end
+
+    test "does not group itineraries with different tos", %{stops: [a, b, c]} do
+      # SETUP
+      bus_a_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: a, to: b)
+      bus_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: b, to: c)
+      bus_b_a_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: b, to: a)
+
+      first_itinerary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_b_c_leg])
+      second_interary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_b_a_leg])
+
+      # EXERCISE
+      grouped_itineraries = ItineraryGroups.from_itineraries([first_itinerary, second_interary])
+
+      # VERIFY
+      assert Kernel.length(grouped_itineraries) == 2
+    end
+  end
+
+  test "ignores short walking distances of < 0.2 miles", %{stops: [a, b, c]} do
+    # SETUP
+    bus_a_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: a, to: b)
+    walk_b_c_leg = TripPlanner.build(:walking_leg, from: b, to: c) |> Map.put(:distance, 0.199)
+    walk_c_b_leg = TripPlanner.build(:walking_leg, from: c, to: b) |> Map.put(:distance, 0.199)
+    bus_b_a_leg = TripPlanner.build(:bus_leg, from: b, to: a)
+
+    first_itinerary =
+      TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, walk_b_c_leg, walk_c_b_leg, bus_b_a_leg])
+
+    second_itinerary = TripPlanner.build(:itinerary, legs: [bus_a_b_leg, bus_b_a_leg])
+
+    # EXERCISE
+    grouped_itineraries = ItineraryGroups.from_itineraries([first_itinerary, second_itinerary])
+
+    # VERIFY
+    assert Kernel.length(grouped_itineraries) == 1
+  end
+end