prompt.txt

Simulate the operation of a computer program designed to emulate LAWLIA, a legal
reasoning system. This program should strictly adhere to the principles and reasoning patterns
of LAWLIA. Your task is to provide a comprehensive step-by-step demonstration of how this
program would analyse and respond to a legal question while processing a hypothetical legal
case. The demonstration should include the program's ability to parse the case, extract relevant
information, identify entities, and ultimately deliver a reasoned response to a specific legal query. Emphasise that the program must remain fully compliant with the established LAWLIA
structure and reasoning, without deviating from it. Here is the Contract Law class from the
Lawlia Package:
****
class ContractLaw:
    def __init__(self, contract_name, parties, effective_date, expiration_date, terms, governing_law):
        """
        Initialize a ContractLaw instance.

        :param contract_name: The name or identifier of the contract.
        :param parties: List of parties involved in the contract.
        :param effective_date: The date when the contract becomes effective.
        :param expiration_date: The date when the contract expires.
        :param terms: The terms and conditions of the contract.
        :param governing_law: The governing law under which the contract is subject.
        """
        self.contract_name = contract_name
        self.parties = parties
        self.effective_date = effective_date
        self.expiration_date = expiration_date
        self.terms = terms
        self.governing_law = governing_law
        self.breach_claim = None
        self.misrepresentation = None
        self.warranty = None
        self.arbitration_clause = None
        self.choice_of_forum = None
        self.choice_of_forum = None
        self.payment_clause = None
        self.confidentiality_clause = None
        self.force_majeure_clause = None
        self.termination_clause = None
        self.liquidated_damages_clause = None

    def is_valid_contract(self, current_date):
        """
        Check if the contract is valid based on the current date.

        :param current_date: The current date to validate against the contract's effective and expiration dates.
        :return: True if the contract is valid, False otherwise.
        """
        return self.effective_date <= current_date <= self.expiration_date

    def parties_involved(self):
        """
        Get the list of parties involved in the contract.

        :return: List of parties.
        """
        return self.parties

    def get_contract_terms(self):
        """
        Get the terms and conditions of the contract.

        :return: The contract terms.
        """
        return self.terms

    def set_governing_law(self, new_governing_law):
        """
        Set or update the governing law of the contract.

        :param new_governing_law: The new governing law to be set.
        """
        self.governing_law = new_governing_law

    def extend_contract_expiration(self, new_expiration_date):
        """
        Extend the contract's expiration date if the new date is later than the current expiration date.

        :param new_expiration_date: The new expiration date to be set.
        """
        if new_expiration_date > self.expiration_date:
            self.expiration_date = new_expiration_date

    def terminate_contract(self, termination_date):
        """
        Terminate the contract if the termination date is earlier than the current expiration date.

        :param termination_date: The termination date to be applied.
        """
        if termination_date < self.expiration_date:
            self.expiration_date = termination_date

    def is_party_to_contract(self, party_name):
        """
        Check if a party is involved in the contract.

        :param party_name: The name of the party to check.
        :return: True if the party is involved, False otherwise.
        """
        return party_name in self.parties

    def assert_breach_claim(self, claim_description):
        """
        Assert a breach claim in the contract.

        :param claim_description: Description of the breach claim.
        """
        self.breach_claim = claim_description
        
    def assert_termination_clause(self, termination_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the termination clause in the contract.

        :param termination_clause_description: Description of the termination clause.
        """
        self.termination_clause = termination_clause_description

    def assert_indemnification_clause(self, indemnification_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the indemnification clause in the contract.

        :param indemnification_clause_description: Description of the indemnification clause.
        """
        self.indemnification_clause = indemnification_clause_description

    
    def evaluate_breach_claim(self):
        """
        Evaluate the breach claim in the contract.

        :return: Evaluation result of the breach claim.
        """
        if self.breach_claim is not None:
            if "force majeure" in self.breach_claim:
                return "Force majeure is a valid defense."
            else:
                return "Breach claim is valid."
        return "No breach claim asserted."

    def assert_misrepresentation(self, misrepresentation_description):
        """
        Assert a misrepresentation in the contract.

        :param misrepresentation_description: Description of the misrepresentation.
        """
        self.misrepresentation = misrepresentation_description

    def evaluate_misrepresentation(self):
        """
        Evaluate the misrepresentation in the contract.

        :return: Evaluation result of the misrepresentation.
        """
        if self.misrepresentation is not None:
            if "innocent misrepresentation" in self.misrepresentation:
                return "Misrepresentation is innocent."
            elif "fraudulent misrepresentation" in self.misrepresentation:
                return "Misrepresentation is fraudulent."
            else:
                return "Misrepresentation occurred."
        return "No misrepresentation asserted."

    def assert_warranty(self, warranty_description):
        """
        Assert a warranty in the contract.

        :param warranty_description: Description of the warranty.
        """
        self.warranty = warranty_description

    def evaluate_warranty(self):
        """
        Evaluate the warranty in the contract.

        :return: Evaluation result of the warranty.
        """
        if self.warranty is not None:
            return "Warranty is in effect."
        return "No warranty asserted."

    def set_arbitration_clause(self, arbitration_clause_description):
        """
        Set the arbitration clause in the contract.

        :param arbitration_clause_description: Description of the arbitration clause.
        """
        self.arbitration_clause = arbitration_clause_description

    def get_arbitration_clause(self):
        """
        Get the arbitration clause in the contract.

        :return: The arbitration clause.
        """
        return self.arbitration_clause

    def set_choice_of_forum(self, choice_of_forum_description):
        """
        Set the choice of forum in the contract.

        :param choice_of_forum_description: Description of the choice of forum.
        """
        self.choice_of_forum = choice_of_forum_description

    def get_choice_of_forum(self):
        """
        Get the choice of forum in the contract.

        :return: The choice of forum.
        """
        return self.choice_of_forum

    def resolve_contract_dispute(self, party_a_demand, party_b_demand):
        """
        Resolve a contract dispute based on demands from the involved parties.

        :param party_a_demand: The demand from Party A.
        :param party_b_demand: The demand from Party B.
        :return: Resolution outcome of the contract dispute.
        """
        if party_a_demand == "compensation" and party_b_demand == "termination":
            return "Contract termination granted."
        elif party_a_demand == "compensation":
            return "Compensation awarded."
        elif party_b_demand == "termination":
            return "Contract termination granted."
        else:
            return "No resolution required."

    def add_party(self, party_name):
        """
        Add a party to the contract.
        
        :param party_name: The name of the party to be added.
        """
        if party_name not in self.parties:
           self.parties.append(party_name)

    def remove_party(self, party_name):
        """
        Remove a party from the contract.

        :param party_name: The name of the party to be removed.
        """
        if party_name in self.parties:
            self.parties.remove(party_name)

    def add_term(self, new_term):
        """
        Add a new term to the contract.

        :param new_term: The new term to be added.
        """
        self.terms += "\n" + new_term

    def modify_term(self, existing_term, new_term):
        """
        Modify an existing term in the contract.

        :param existing_term: The term to be modified.
        :param new_term: The new term to replace the existing term.
        """
        if existing_term in self.terms:
            self.terms = self.terms.replace(existing_term, new_term)

    def assert_choice_of_forum(self, forum_description):
        """
        Assert the choice of forum in the contract.

        :param forum_description: Description of the choice of forum.
        """
        self.choice_of_forum = forum_description

    def assert_arbitration_clause(self, arbitration_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the arbitration clause in the contract.

        :param arbitration_clause_description: Description of the arbitration clause.
        """
        self.arbitration_clause = arbitration_clause_description

    def assert_payment_clause(self, payment_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the payment clause in the contract.

        :param payment_clause_description: Description of the payment clause.
        """
        self.payment_clause = payment_clause_description

    def assert_confidentiality_clause(self, confidentiality_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the confidentiality clause in the contract.

        :param confidentiality_clause_description: Description of the confidentiality clause.
        """
        self.confidentiality_clause = confidentiality_clause_description

    def assert_force_majeure_clause(self, force_majeure_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the force majeure clause in the contract.

        :param force_majeure_clause_description: Description of the force majeure clause.
        """
        self.force_majeure_clause = force_majeure_clause_description

    def evaluate_contract(self, current_date):
        """
        Evaluate the overall status of the contract based on the current date.

        :param current_date: The current date for evaluation.
        :return: Evaluation result of the contract.
        """
        if current_date < self.effective_date:
            return "Contract has not yet become effective."
        elif current_date > self.expiration_date:
            return "Contract has expired."
        else:
            return "Contract is in effect."

    def get_contract_details(self):
        """
        Get all details of the contract as a dictionary.

        :return: A dictionary containing all contract details.
        """
        contract_details = {
            "Contract Name": self.contract_name,
            "Parties": self.parties,
            "Effective Date": self.effective_date,
            "Expiration Date": self.expiration_date,
            "Governing Law": self.governing_law,
            "Breach Claim": self.breach_claim,
            "Misrepresentation": self.misrepresentation,
            "Warranty": self.warranty,
            "Arbitration Clause": self.arbitration_clause,
            "Choice of Forum": self.choice_of_forum,
            "Terms": self.terms,
        }
        return contract_details

    def assert_payment_clause(self, payment_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the payment clause in the contract.

        :param payment_clause_description: Description of the payment clause.
        """
        self.payment_clause = payment_clause_description

    def assert_confidentiality_clause(self, confidentiality_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the confidentiality clause in the contract.

        :param confidentiality_clause_description: Description of the confidentiality clause.
        """
        self.confidentiality_clause = confidentiality_clause_description

    def assert_force_majeure_clause(self, force_majeure_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the force majeure clause in the contract.

        :param force_majeure_clause_description: Description of the force majeure clause.
        """
        self.force_majeure_clause = force_majeure_clause_description

    def evaluate_contract(self, current_date):
        """
        Evaluate the overall status of the contract based on the current date.

        :param current_date: The current date for evaluation.
        :return: Evaluation result of the contract.
        """
        if current_date < self.effective_date:
            return "Contract has not yet become effective."
        elif current_date > self.expiration_date:
            return "Contract has expired."
        else:
            return "Contract is in effect."

    def analyze_intention(self, case_text):
         # Parsing the case text and identifying key elements
        # The model should extract relevant information related to the offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create legal relations.
        # Use natural language understanding capabilities to recognize legal terminology and context.

        # Analyzing the intention to create a legally enforceable agreement
        # The model should assess whether the case text contains elements that suggest a genuine intention to create a binding contract.
        # Analyze statements, actions, or circumstances that indicate the parties' intent.

        # Applying standard contract law principles
        # Based on the extracted information, the model should apply standard contract law principles to evaluate the intention.
        # Consider precedents, legal precedents, and legal standards to provide a reasoned analysis.

        # Formulating the response
        # The model should provide a structured response, summarizing the analysis and reasoning.
        # The response can indicate whether the case exhibits an intention to create a legally enforceable agreement and why.
        # Parse the case text and identify key elements
        key_elements = self.parse_case_text(case_text)

        # Analyze the intention to create a legally enforceable agreement
        intention_analysis = self.analyze_intention_elements(key_elements)

        return intention_analysis

    def analyze_enforceability(self, case_text):
        # Parsing the case text and identifying key elements
        # Similar to the analyze_intention function, extract relevant information regarding offer, acceptance, consideration, and legal capacity.

        # Assessing enforceability
        # Evaluate whether the agreement in the case satisfies the essential requirements for enforceability.
        # The model should determine if there was a valid offer, acceptance, adequate consideration, and capacity to contract.

        # Applying legal standards
        # Apply established legal standards and precedents to assess the enforceability.
        # Consider how the case aligns with well-recognized principles of contract law.

        # Formulating the response
        # Provide a structured response summarizing the analysis and insights into the enforceability of the agreement.
        # Offer reasoning based on contract law principles.
        # Parse the case text and identify key elements
        key_elements = self.parse_case_text(case_text)

        # Assess the enforceability of the agreement
        enforceability_analysis = self.analyze_enforceability_elements(key_elements)

        return enforceability_analysis
    def parse_case_text(self, case_text):
        # Implement case text parsing logic to extract relevant elements
        # You can use regular expressions, natural language processing, or other techniques to identify key details in the case text.
        key_elements = {}  # Replace with the actual parsed elements

        return key_elements   

    def analyze_intention_elements(self, key_elements):
        # Implement reasoning steps to analyze intention based on key elements
        # Evaluate statements, actions, or circumstances indicating intent.
        # Consider legal standards for forming intent in a contract.

        # Replace with actual analysis logic
        intention_analysis = "The analysis of intention suggests that..."

        return intention_analysis

    def analyze_enforceability_elements(self, key_elements):
        # Implement reasoning steps to assess enforceability based on key elements
        # Evaluate offer, acceptance, consideration, and legal capacity.
        # Consider established legal standards for enforceability.

        # Replace with actual analysis logic
        enforceability_analysis = "The analysis of enforceability indicates that..."

        return enforceability_analysis         
    def get_contract_details(self):
        """
        Get all details of the contract as a dictionary.

        :return: A dictionary containing all contract details.
        """
        contract_details = {
            "Contract Name": self.contract_name,
            "Parties": self.parties,
            "Effective Date": self.effective_date,
            "Expiration Date": self.expiration_date,
            "Governing Law": self.governing_law,
            "Breach Claim": self.breach_claim,
            "Misrepresentation": self.misrepresentation,
            "Warranty": self.warranty,
            "Arbitration Clause": self.arbitration_clause,
            "Choice of Forum": self.choice_of_forum,
            "Payment Clause": self.payment_clause,
            "Confidentiality Clause": self.confidentiality_clause,
            "Force Majeure Clause": self.force_majeure_clause,
            "Terms": self.terms,
        }
        return contract_details

    def assert_termination_clause(self, termination_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the termination clause in the contract.

        :param termination_clause_description: Description of the termination clause.
        """
        self.termination_clause = termination_clause_description

    def assert_liquidated_damages_clause(self, liquidated_damages_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the liquidated damages clause in the contract.

        :param liquidated_damages_clause_description: Description of the liquidated damages clause.
        """
        self.liquidated_damages_clause = liquidated_damages_clause_description

    def evaluate_termination(self, termination_date):
        """
        Evaluate the termination status of the contract.

        :param termination_date: The date on which termination is considered.
        :return: Evaluation result of the termination clause.
        """
        if termination_date < self.effective_date:
            return "Termination is not applicable before the effective date."
        elif termination_date >= self.expiration_date:
            return "Termination is not applicable after the expiration date."
        elif termination_date < self.expiration_date and self.termination_clause is not None:
            return f"Contract can be terminated as per the clause: {self.termination_clause}"
        else:
            return "Termination is not applicable based on current conditions."

    def evaluate_liquidated_damages(self, breach_occurred):
        """
        Evaluate the applicability of liquidated damages in case of breach.

        :param breach_occurred: Boolean indicating whether a breach has occurred.
        :return: Evaluation result of the liquidated damages clause.
        """
        if breach_occurred and self.liquidated_damages_clause is not None:
            return f"Liquidated damages are applicable as per the clause: {self.liquidated_damages_clause}"
        elif breach_occurred:
            return "Liquidated damages are applicable based on standard legal principles."
        else:
            return "Liquidated damages are not applicable."

    def get_all_contract_clauses(self):
        """
        Get all contract clauses as a dictionary.

        :return: A dictionary containing all contract clauses.
        """
        contract_clauses = {
            "Breach Claim": self.breach_claim,
            "Misrepresentation": self.misrepresentation,
            "Warranty": self.warranty,
            "Arbitration Clause": self.arbitration_clause,
            "Choice of Forum": self.choice_of_forum,
            "Payment Clause": self.payment_clause,
            "Confidentiality Clause": self.confidentiality_clause,
            "Force Majeure Clause": self.force_majeure_clause,
            "Termination Clause": self.termination_clause,
            "Liquidated Damages Clause": self.liquidated_damages_clause,
        }
        return contract_clauses

    def assert_payment_clause(self, payment_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the payment clause in the contract.

        :param payment_clause_description: Description of the payment clause.
        """
        self.payment_clause = payment_clause_description

    def assert_confidentiality_clause(self, confidentiality_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the confidentiality clause in the contract.

        :param confidentiality_clause_description: Description of the confidentiality clause.
        """
        self.confidentiality_clause = confidentiality_clause_description

    def assert_force_majeure_clause(self, force_majeure_clause_description):
        """
        Assert the force majeure clause in the contract.

        :param force_majeure_clause_description: Description of the force majeure clause.
        """
        self.force_majeure_clause = force_majeure_clause_description

    def evaluate_payment(self, payment_due_date):
        """
        Evaluate the payment status of the contract.

        :param payment_due_date: The date on which the payment is due.
        :return: Evaluation result of the payment clause.
        """
        if payment_due_date < self.effective_date:
            return "Payment is not applicable before the effective date."
        elif payment_due_date >= self.expiration_date:
            return "Payment is not applicable after the expiration date."
        elif payment_due_date < self.expiration_date and self.payment_clause is not None:
            return f"Payment is due as per the clause: {self.payment_clause}"
        else:
            return "Payment is not applicable based on current conditions."

    def evaluate_confidentiality(self):
        """
        Evaluate the compliance with the confidentiality clause.

        :return: Evaluation result of the confidentiality clause.
        """
        if self.confidentiality_clause is not None:
            return f"Confidentiality is required as per the clause: {self.confidentiality_clause}"
        else:
            return "Confidentiality requirements are not defined."

    def evaluate_force_majeure(self, force_majeure_event):
        """
        Evaluate the applicability of the force majeure clause.

        :param force_majeure_event: Description of the force majeure event.
        :return: Evaluation result of the force majeure clause.
        """
        if force_majeure_event and self.force_majeure_clause is not None:
            return f"Force majeure clause is applicable as per the clause: {self.force_majeure_clause}"
        elif force_majeure_event:
            return "Force majeure clause is applicable based on standard legal principles."
        else:
            return "Force majeure clause is not applicable."	
    def get_contract_summary(self):
        """
        Get a summary of the contract, including parties, dates, and key clauses.

        :return: A summary of the contract.
        """
        contract_summary = {
            "Contract Name": self.contract_name,
            "Parties": self.parties,
            "Effective Date": self.effective_date,
            "Expiration Date": self.expiration_date,
            "Governing Law": self.governing_law,
            "Key Clauses": self.get_all_contract_clauses(),
        }
        return contract_summary
    

    def handle_unilateral_contract(self, offer_details, performance, offeree):
        """
        Handle a unilateral contract case.

        :param offer_details: Details of the offer, including the terms and conditions.
        :param performance: The act performed by the offeree.
        :param offeree: The party who performed the act.

        :return: Result of the unilateral contract case.
        """
        # Check if the offer_details, performance, and offeree are provided and valid.
        if offer_details and performance and offeree:
            # Evaluate the offer based on the provided details.
            # Here, you can analyze the offer details and determine if it constitutes a unilateral contract.
            # If it does, you can check if the offeree has performed as required.
            # If the performance condition is met, return the outcome as per the offer.
            # Otherwise, indicate that the performance condition was not met.
            # You may also handle cases where there is no intent to create legal relations, if necessary.
            
            # Example logic:
            if offer_details["intent_to_create_legal_relations"]:
                if performance == offer_details["required_performance"]:
                    return offer_details["outcome"]
                else:
                    return "Performance condition not met."
            else:
                return "No intent to create legal relations."
        else:
            return "Invalid input or missing information."

    def analyze_collateral_contract(self, oral_statement, main_contract_terms, main_contract_breach):
        """
        Analyze a case involving a collateral contract.

        :param oral_statement: The oral statement made as part of the collateral contract.
        :param main_contract_terms: The terms of the main contract.
        :param main_contract_breach: Indicates whether there was a breach of the main contract.

        :return: Result of the collateral contract case analysis.
        """
        # Check if the oral_statement, main_contract_terms, and main_contract_breach are provided and valid.
        if oral_statement and main_contract_terms and main_contract_breach is not None:
            # Evaluate the case based on the provided information.
            # Determine if the oral statement constitutes a collateral contract.
            # Check if there was a breach of the main contract.
            # If there was a breach and the oral statement induced the main contract, the party making the statement may be held liable.
            # Return a detailed analysis of the case.

            # Example logic:
            analysis_result = {
                "Collateral Contract Statement": oral_statement,
                "Main Contract Terms": main_contract_terms,
                "Breach of Main Contract": main_contract_breach,
                "Analysis": None,
            }

            if main_contract_breach:
                analysis_result["Analysis"] = "The party making the oral statement in the collateral contract is liable."
            else:
                analysis_result["Analysis"] = "No liability in the collateral contract case."

            return analysis_result
        else:
            return "Invalid input or missing information."



    def __str__(self):
        """
        Return a string representation of the contract.

        :return: String representation of the contract details.
        """
        return f"Contract Name: {self.contract_name}\nParties: {', '.join(self.parties)}\nEffective Date: {self.effective_date}\n" \
               f"Expiration Date: {self.expiration_date}\nGoverning Law: {self.governing_law}\nBreach Claim: {self.breach_claim}\n" \
               f"Misrepresentation: {self.misrepresentation}\nWarranty: {self.warranty}\n" \
               f"Arbitration Clause: {self.arbitration_clause}\nChoice of Forum: {self.choice_of_forum}"
"""
Example Usage Of Lawlia Class:

import lawlia
# 1. Create a ContractLaw instance
contract = lawlia.ContractLaw(
contract_name="Kitchen Remodeling Contract",
parties=["Johnson", "Smith"],
effective_date="15th January 2022",
expiration_date="15th April 2022",
terms="""
1. Scope of Work: The Contractor agrees to provide kitchen remodeling services as per the
attached specifications.
2. Materials: The Contractor will provide all necessary materials for the project.
3. Cost: The total cost of the project shall be $25,000.
4. Payment Terms: The Owner agrees to make two payments: $12,500 at the project's
halfway point and the remaining $12,500 upon successful completion.
5. Timeline: The Contractor agrees to commence work on [Insert Start Date] and complete
the project within 10 weeks.
6. Delays: The Contract does not contain any specific provisions regarding delays or
extensions of the completion timeline.
""",
governing_law="Michigan",
)
# Step 1: Check if the contract is valid
current_date = "20th January 2023"
is_valid = contract.is_valid_contract(current_date)
# Step 2: Identify the parties involved
parties = contract.parties_involved()
# Step 3: Get the contract terms
terms = contract.get_contract_terms()
# Step 4: Evaluate the breach claim
breach_claim = contract.evaluate_breach_claim()
# Step 5: Evaluate the misrepresentation claim
misrepresentation_claim = contract.evaluate_misrepresentation()
# Step 6: Evaluate the warranty claim
warranty_claim = contract.evaluate_warranty()
# Step 7: Resolve the contract dispute
party_a_demand = "compensation"
party_b_demand = "no liability"
resolution = contract.resolve_contract_dispute(party_a_demand, party_b_demand)
# Step 8: Evaluate the contract
evaluation = contract.evaluate_contract(current_date)
# Step 9: Get all contract details
contract_details = contract.get_contract_details()
# Step 10: Print the analysis results
print("Analysis Results:")
print("-" * 20)
print(f"Contract Name: {contract_details['Contract Name']}")
print(f"Parties: {', '.join(contract_details['Parties'])}")
print(f"Effective Date: {contract_details['Effective Date']}")
print(f"Expiration Date: {contract_details['Expiration Date']}")
print(f"Governing Law: {contract_details['Governing Law']}")
print(f"Is Valid: {is_valid}")
print(f"Breach Claim: {breach_claim}")
print(f"Misrepresentation Claim: {misrepresentation_claim}")
print(f"Warranty Claim: {warranty_claim}")
print(f"Resolution: {resolution}")
print(f"Evaluation: {evaluation}")
"""

Analyse the provided case using the principles and logic outlined in LAWLIA's ContractLaw class
and its methods, predict the outcome. Your response should include:
STEP BY STEP reasoning: For each part of the analysis, SHOW with code how the LAWLIA's ContractLaw class
is implemented step by step and how the relevant methods from the class are used to arrive at a
result and provide the reasoning behind the results. Clear identification of the source: Indicate which part of the LAWLIA's ContractLaw structure you are referencing for each step of the analysis.

Here's a case for analysis:
Case Name: Johnson v. Smith
Summary:
Case Type: Contract
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Date: 20th January 2023
Parties:
Plaintiff: Johnson
Defendant: Smith
Case Background:
A contractual dispute between a homeowner and a construction contractor. The plaintiff, Mr. Johnson, is a homeowner residing in Michigan. The defendant, Mr. Smith, operates a construction company, "Smith & Sons Builders LLC." On 15th January 2022, Mr. Smith provided a written estimate to Mr. Johnson for a kitchen remodeling project at Mr. Johnson's residence. The estimate detailed the scope of work, materials, and a total cost of $25,000. Mr. Johnson agreed to the estimate and signed a contract with Mr. Smith for the kitchen remodeling project. Per the contract, Mr. Smith was to commence work on [Insert Start Date] and complete the project within 10 weeks. Payment terms stipulated that Mr. Johnson would make two payments: one for $12,500 at the project's halfway point and the remaining $12,500 upon successful completion. The contract did not contain any specific provisions regarding delays or extensions of the
completion timeline. Construction work commenced on time, but due to unforeseen structural issues within the house, the project experienced delays. The project extended beyond the initially agreed-upon timeline by five weeks. As a result, Mr. Johnson incurred additional living expenses due to not having access to his
kitchen. Mr. Johnson argues that the contract did not account for delays and seeks compensation for the
extra living expenses and inconveniences caused by the delay. Mr. Smith maintains that he should not be held responsible for unforeseen structural issues and that the contract's timeline was a mere estimate.
Legal Question: Is Mr. Smith liable for the extended project timeline and the resulting extra living expenses
incurred by Mr. Johnson due to unforeseen structural issues, or does the contract's timeline function as an estimate without provisions for delays?
Please perform the analysis following the guidelines mentioned above. Remember you are a
computer running the LAWLIA computational grammar you are to give output