Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
348 lines (325 loc) · 10.1 KB

137.md

File metadata and controls

348 lines (325 loc) · 10.1 KB

Results of GPT-4 on HumanEval/137

Date: 18 July, 2023
Model: gpt-4
Temperature: 0.2
Passing runs: 9
Total runs: 10
Success rate: 90%

Prompt

Tokens: 167

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """

The above is an incomplete Python code fragment. Return the complete and correct code with no additional text.

Correct solution

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """temp_a, temp_b = a, b
    if isinstance(temp_a, str): temp_a = temp_a.replace(',','.')
    if isinstance(temp_b, str): temp_b = temp_b.replace(',','.')
    if float(temp_a) == float(temp_b): return None
    return a if float(temp_a) > float(temp_b) else b

Unit tests

def check(candidate):

    # Check some simple cases
    assert candidate(1, 2) == 2
    assert candidate(1, 2.5) == 2.5
    assert candidate(2, 3) == 3
    assert candidate(5, 6) == 6
    assert candidate(1, "2,3") == "2,3"
    assert candidate("5,1", "6") == "6"
    assert candidate("1", "2") == "2"
    assert candidate("1", 1) == None

    # Check some edge cases that are easy to work out by hand.
    assert True

Runs

✅ Run 1

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:56:37
Duration: 17.41s
Completion tokens: 194
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    a_val = float(str(a).replace(',', '.'))
    b_val = float(str(b).replace(',', '.'))

    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 2

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:56:21
Duration: 15.62s
Completion tokens: 194
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    a_val = float(str(a).replace(",", "."))
    b_val = float(str(b).replace(",", "."))

    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif b_val > a_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 3

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:56:04
Duration: 16.74s
Completion tokens: 223
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    # Convert strings to floats for comparison
    a_val = float(a.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(a, str) else a
    b_val = float(b.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(b, str) else b

    # Compare the values
    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 4

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:55:49
Duration: 15.54s
Completion tokens: 166
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,
    """
    # Convert strings to floats for comparison
    a_val = float(a.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(a, str) else a
    b_val = float(b.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(b, str) else b

    # Compare values and return the larger one in its original type
    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif b_val > a_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 5

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:55:26
Duration: 22.32s
Completion tokens: 223
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    # Convert strings to floats if necessary
    a_val = float(a.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(a, str) else a
    b_val = float(b.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(b, str) else b

    # Compare the values
    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 6

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:55:08
Duration: 18.73s
Completion tokens: 223
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    # Convert strings to floats if necessary
    a_val = float(a.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(a, str) else a
    b_val = float(b.replace(',', '.')) if isinstance(b, str) else b

    # Compare the values
    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

❌ Run 7

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:54:48
Duration: 19.92s
Completion tokens: 212
Result: Fail

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    # Convert string numbers to float
    if isinstance(a, str):
        a = float(a.replace(',', '.'))
    if isinstance(b, str):
        b = float(b.replace(',', '.'))

    # Compare the numbers
    if a > b:
        return a
    elif a < b:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 8

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:54:32
Duration: 15.14s
Completion tokens: 194
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    a_val = float(str(a).replace(',', '.'))
    b_val = float(str(b).replace(',', '.'))

    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 9

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:54:18
Duration: 14.41s
Completion tokens: 194
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    a_val = float(str(a).replace(",", "."))
    b_val = float(str(b).replace(",", "."))

    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif b_val > a_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None

✅ Run 10

Start time: 2023-07-18 17:53:57
Duration: 20.49s
Completion tokens: 195
Result: Pass

def compare_one(a, b):
    """
    Create a function that takes integers, floats, or strings representing
    real numbers, and returns the larger variable in its given variable type.
    Return None if the values are equal.
    Note: If a real number is represented as a string, the floating point might be . or ,

    compare_one(1, 2.5) ➞ 2.5
    compare_one(1, "2,3") ➞ "2,3"
    compare_one("5,1", "6") ➞ "6"
    compare_one("1", 1) ➞ None
    """
    a_val = float(str(a).replace(',', '.'))
    b_val = float(str(b).replace(',', '.'))
    
    if a_val > b_val:
        return a
    elif a_val < b_val:
        return b
    else:
        return None