pdf2.txt

Warning: Cannot polyfill `DOMMatrix`, rendering may be broken.
Warning: Cannot polyfill `Path2D`, rendering may be broken.
# Document Loaded
Number of Pages: 18

# Metadata Is Loaded
## Info
{
  "PDFFormatVersion": "1.4",
  "Language": null,
  "EncryptFilterName": null,
  "IsLinearized": false,
  "IsAcroFormPresent": false,
  "IsXFAPresent": false,
  "IsCollectionPresent": false,
  "IsSignaturesPresent": false,
  "ModDate": "D:20140520123848-07'00'",
  "Subject": "gnuplot plot",
  "CreationDate": "Mon Mar 25 14:30:13 2013",
  "Author": "ongardie",
  "Title": "In Search of an Understandable Consensus Algorithm",
  "Creator": "gnuplot 4.6 patchlevel 0",
  "Producer": "GPL Ghostscript 9.05"
}

## Metadata
{
  "xmp:modifydate": "Mon -Ma-r T25: 1:4:30::3",
  "xmp:createdate": "Mon -Ma-r T25: 1:4:30::3",
  "xmp:creatortool": "gnuplot 4.6 patchlevel 0",
  "dc:title": "timeoutcdf.eps",
  "dc:creator": [
    "ongardie"
  ],
  "dc:description": "gnuplot plot"
}

# Page 1
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 0,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 4, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 3,
      streamId: 1,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 458752,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 458752, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'In Search of an Understandable Consensus Algorithm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 396.89902677280986,
  height: 17.2154,
  transform: [ 17.2154, 0, 0, 17.2154, 111.24, 704.16 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(Extended Version)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 141.57240832924595,
  height: 17.2154,
  transform: [ 17.2154, 0, 0, 17.2154, 238.92000000000002, 682.3198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 224.76020000000003, 662.5198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Diego Ongaro and John Ousterhout',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 169.88438416204824,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 224.76020000000003, 662.5198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Stanford University',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 94.41797738956814,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 261, 648.5999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 626.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Abstract',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 44.421181453926394,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 626.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 614.7601000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft is a consensus algorithm for managing a replicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82174527878132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 614.7601000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log. It produces a result equivalent to (multi-)Paxos, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6607288516243,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 602.7601000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it is as efficient as Paxos, but its structure is different',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84949580365955,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 590.8800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from Paxos; this makes Raft more understandable than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6615599051654,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 578.8800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos and also provides a better foundation for build-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777241590511,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 566.9999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing practical systems. In order to enhance understandabil-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.03762726877707,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 554.9999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ity, Raft separates the key elements of consensus, such as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63539353929988,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 542.9999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader election, log replication, and safety, and it enforces',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87545625557522,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 531.1198000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a stronger degree of coherency to reduce the number of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67747155631375,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 519.1198000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'states that must be considered. Results from a user study',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133584539168,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 507.11980000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'demonstrate that Raft is easier for students to learn than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66131088897848,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 495.24010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos. Raft also includes a new mechanism for changing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90086789779087,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 483.24010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the cluster membership, which uses overlapping majori-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79740066096753,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 471.3600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ties to guarantee safety.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.57073243415566,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 459.3600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 440.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 440.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.9025253888,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 77.9776, 440.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Introduction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 64.72733060326402,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 89.8801253888, 440.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 428.51980000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Consensus algorithms allow a collection of machines',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.79562451191933,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 428.51980000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to work as a coherent group that can survive the fail-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6768111129829,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 416.51980000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ures of some of its members. Because of this, they play a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58326141528832,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 404.51980000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'key role in building reliable large-scale software systems.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.57065999999998,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 392.6397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos [15, 16] has dominated the discussion of consen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79779158499855,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 380.6397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sus algorithms over the last decade: most implementations',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.99539078601128,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 368.6397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of consensus are based on Paxos or influenced by it, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132968848018,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 356.7600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos has become the primary vehicle used to teach stu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55679306187926,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 344.7600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dents about consensus.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 91.17057023648853,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 332.8799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Unfortunately, Paxos is quite difficult to understand, in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.58118124631784,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016000000003, 320.63970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'spite of numerous attempts to make it more approachable.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.05131381409464,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 308.63970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Furthermore, its architecture requires complex changes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87562134262615,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 296.75960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to support practical systems. As a result, both system',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55145865595495,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 284.75960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'builders and students struggle with Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 167.49085423542775,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 272.75960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'After struggling with Paxos ourselves, we set out to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.58080930111606,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016000000003, 260.63970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'find a new consensus algorithm that could provide a bet-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67747370824412,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 248.63970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ter foundation for system building and education. Our ap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776305102349,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 236.63970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'proach was unusual in that our primary goal was',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 199.11545352067614,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 224.75960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0845464793237625,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 271.1154535206763, 224.75960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'under-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.47770763061523,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 274.20000000000005, 224.75960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'standability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.263400025498015,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 212.75960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ': could we define a consensus algorithm for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 181.3976283827859,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 119.28010000000006, 212.75960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'practical systems and describe it in a way that is signifi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.677345080599,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 200.87950000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cantly easier to learn than Paxos? Furthermore, we wanted',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.661347182876,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 188.87950000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the algorithm to facilitate the development of intuitions',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75541682078986,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 176.87950000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that are essential for system builders. It was important not',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7297483677461,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 164.99940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'just for the algorithm to work, but for it to be obvious why',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66232331238072,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 152.99940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it works.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.890570699662156,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 140.99940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The result of this work is a consensus algorithm called',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70142193253756,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016000000006, 128.87950000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft. In designing Raft we applied specific techniques to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54130990387722,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 116.87950000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'improve understandability, including decomposition (Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60961392,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000006, 104.99940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'separates leader election, log replication, and safety) and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000007,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 92.99940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.97011, 0, 0, 7.97011, 72.4801, 74.2801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This tech report is an extended version of [32]; additional material is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.10022321352557,
  height: 7.97011,
  transform: [ 7.97011, 0, 0, 7.97011, 72.4801, 74.2801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'noted with a gray bar in the margin. Published May 20, 2014.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 195.9129163788355,
  height: 7.97011,
  transform: [ 7.97011, 0, 0, 7.97011, 72.00009999999995, 64.80002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 627.0000200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state space reduction (relative to Paxos, Raft reduces the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70367723475627,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 627.0000200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'degree of nondeterminism and the ways servers can be in-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67874007933946,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 615.0000200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consistent with each other). A user study with 43 students',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75539210347944,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 603.0000200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'at two universities shows that Raft is significantly easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55737324618198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 591.1199200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to understand than Paxos: after learning both algorithms,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8108300904719,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 579.1199200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '33 of these students were able to answer questions about',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84982300664504,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 567.2402200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft better than questions about Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 155.49108292827714,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 555.2402200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft is similar in many ways to existing consensus al-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5979331564865,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5602599999999, 542.2800200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'gorithms (most notably, Oki and Liskov’s Viewstamped',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7815914755714,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 530.3999200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Replication [29, 22]), but it has several novel features:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 216.1294591986057,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60009999999994, 518.3999200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5602599999999, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5602599999999, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.5415799999999, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Strong leader:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 61.51768634870849,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5204199999999, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.922513651291524,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 400.03810634870837, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Raft uses a stronger form of leader-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 144.31725711722567,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 402.9606199999999, 505.4401200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ship than other consensus algorithms. For example,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.89079912653386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5200199999999, 493.5600200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entries only flow from the leader to other servers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.77141392224846,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5200199999999, 481.5600200000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This simplifies the management of the replicated log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7414063310167,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5200199999999, 469.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and makes Raft easier to understand.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 146.85105164232363,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5200199999999, 457.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5602499999999, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5602499999999, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54156999999987, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Leader election:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 71.23769411203146,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52040999999986, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.602505887968505,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 409.75810411203133, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Raft uses randomized timers to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.78085281914028,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 414.36060999999984, 445.67992000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'elect leaders. This adds only a small amount of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7577196060714,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52000999999984, 433.7998200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mechanism to the heartbeats already required for any',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.74173871457506,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52000999999984, 421.7998200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus algorithm, while resolving conflicts sim-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6377885088898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52000999999984, 409.7998200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ply and rapidly.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.49027511108732,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52000999999984, 397.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56023999999985, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56023999999985, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54155999999983, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Membership',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 54.139224454871744,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5203999999998, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.220921452000027,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 392.65962445487156, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'changes:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.157630612234364,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 401.8805459068716, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.042223480893881,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 439.03817651910595, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.79537210575735,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 448.0803999999998, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.204592685039984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 471.87577210575716, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'mechanism',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 45.5510165208286,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 481.08036479079715, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.929145614319964,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 526.6313813116258, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.717561327407132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 535.5605269259457, 385.9197200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'changing the set of servers in the cluster uses a new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.79351805154184,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 374.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 362.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'joint consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.63531620548987,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 362.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.644383794510304,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 402.1547162054895, 362.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'approach where the majorities of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 140.4776906998307,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 406.7990999999998, 362.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two different configurations overlap during transi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7575932399456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 350.03962000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tions. This allows the cluster to continue operating',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86112614052917,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 338.15992000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'normally during configuration changes.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.4107647920195,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5193999999998, 326.15992000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We believe that Raft is superior to Paxos and other con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71789202950848,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5596299999998, 313.19972000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus algorithms, both for educational purposes and as a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58347451615782,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 301.31962000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'foundation for implementation. It is simpler and more un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67815601956957,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 289.31962000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'derstandable than other algorithms; it is described com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67769862480466,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 277.43992000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pletely enough to meet the needs of a practical system;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6093784461605,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 265.43992000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it has several open-source implementations and is used',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66170215173915,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 253.43992000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'by several companies; its safety properties have been for-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6775079896878,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 241.55982000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mally specified and proven; and its efficiency is compara-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91808879923738,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 229.55982000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ble to other algorithms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.21038585743547,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 217.55982000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The remainder of the paper introduces the replicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82157969970424,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5596299999998, 204.71962000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine problem (Section 2), discusses the strengths',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75596103996205,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 192.71962000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and weaknesses of Paxos (Section 3), describes our gen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67759667710945,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 180.83992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'eral approach to understandability (Section 4), presents',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75572941854458,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 168.83992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the Raft consensus algorithm (Sections 5–8), evaluates',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75564544345198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 156.83992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft (Section 9), and discusses related work (Section 10).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 224.8507116942077,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 144.95982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.5994699999998, 125.51962 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.5994699999998, 125.51962 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.5770699999998, 125.51962 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Replicated state machines',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.09090080435206,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.4795953887998, 125.51962 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5596299999998, 112.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Consensus algorithms typically arise in the context of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71786768081625,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5596299999998, 112.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 100.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'replicated state machines',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 100.95593258944443,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 100.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.005067410555853,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 419.555402589444, 100.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '[37]. In this approach, state ma-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 125.71742565191651,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 421.56046999999984, 100.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'chines on a collection of servers compute identical copies',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.755884526887,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 88.67982 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the same state and can continue operating even if some',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70330491097457,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 76.79972000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the servers are down. Replicated state machines are',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70371460461914,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5994699999998, 64.79972000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.0795699999998, 34.91962000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 2
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 1,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 5, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 4,
      streamId: 2,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Figure 1:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.346133210846006,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 585.6 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.8542667891539963,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 113.385933210846, 585.6 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Replicated state machine architecture. The con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.30637108339798,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 117.2402, 585.6 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus algorithm manages a replicated log containing state',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.66164664342193,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 574.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'machine commands from clients. The state machines process',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.40791641670253,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 563.6403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'identical sequences of commands from the logs, so they pro-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50550255141542,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 552.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'duce the same outputs.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 81.44155676885987,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 541.7997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 524.9997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'used to solve a variety of fault tolerance problems in dis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55680090247694,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 524.9997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tributed systems. For example, large-scale systems that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60924863296123,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 512.9997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have a single cluster leader, such as GFS [8], HDFS [38],',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69053627349308,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 500.9997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and RAMCloud [33], typically use a separate replicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78146531866108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 489.11960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine to manage leader election and store config-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.797540456732,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 477.11960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'uration information that must survive leader crashes. Ex-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67796697847558,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 465.23990000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'amples of replicated state machines include Chubby [2]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.557759418034,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 453.23990000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and ZooKeeper [11].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.01082905781195,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 441.23990000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Replicated state machines are typically implemented',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82152759509742,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012, 427.79970000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'using a replicated log, as shown in Figure 1. Each server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67785383277317,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 415.9196 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'stores a log containing a series of commands, which its',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63571479458943,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 403.9196 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine executes in order. Each log contains the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70230678396086,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 392.0395 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'same commands in the same order, so each state ma-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67788071197583,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 380.0395 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'chine processes the same sequence of commands. Since',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7037534987658,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 368.0395 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the state machines are deterministic, each computes the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70317172044037,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 356.15979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'same state and the same sequence of outputs.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 179.9704183746421,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 344.15979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Keeping the replicated log consistent is the job of the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7438978673557,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012, 330.71959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus algorithm. The consensus module on a server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67794058744235,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 318.83949999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'receives commands from clients and adds them to its log.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69045252754145,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 306.83949999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'It communicates with the consensus modules on other',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67761522754537,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 294.83949999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers to ensure that every log eventually contains the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70388783500357,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 282.9593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'same requests in the same order, even if some servers fail.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5706272933721,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 270.9593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Once commands are properly replicated, each server’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75599371742126,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 258.9593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine processes them in log order, and the out-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774928464755,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 247.0792999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'puts are returned to clients. As a result, the servers appear',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7972687058006,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 235.0792999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to form a single, highly reliable state machine.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.37095235799663,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 223.1991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Consensus algorithms for practical systems typically',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7013328067602,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012, 209.7593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have the following properties:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 119.40896053940978,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996, 197.7593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94144, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'They ensure',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.543411409920765,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92028, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0167885900792157,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 141.46369140992078, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'safety',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.26340801643194,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 144.48048, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0166919835680233,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 167.74388801643198, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(never returning an incorrect re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 129.91754108687672,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 170.76058, 184.3191999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sult) under all non-Byzantine conditions, including',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86174813803274,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91998000000001, 172.4394999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'network delays, partitions, and packet loss, duplica-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.87739513164954,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91998000000001, 160.4394999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion, and reordering.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 81.69055668247172,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91998000000001, 148.4394999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96021, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96021, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94153, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'They are fully functional (',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 107.35738902356182,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92037, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'available',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.30344368176009,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 199.32037000000003, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') as long as any',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 64.02155312317171,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 236.64027000000002, 136.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'majority of the servers are operational and can com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75774639561058,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 124.5593999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'municate with each other and with clients. Thus, a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6628922695355,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 112.6792999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'typical cluster of five servers can tolerate the failure',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7834695435477,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 100.6792999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of any two servers. Servers are assumed to fail by',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.74088545430976,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 88.6792999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'stopping; they may later recover from state on stable',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.66342646629232,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 76.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'storage and rejoin the cluster.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 117.09022955387972,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92027000000002, 64.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96050000000001, 52.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96050000000001, 52.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94182, 52.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'They do not depend on timing to ensure the consis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75761389249863,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92066000000001, 52.7991999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tency of the logs: faulty clocks and extreme message',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7834288760512,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52066, 698.0391999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'delays can, at worst, cause availability problems.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 194.73070081732564,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52066, 686.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56089000000003, 674.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56089000000003, 674.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54221, 674.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In the common case, a command can complete as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71583477461016,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52105, 674.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'soon as a majority of the cluster has responded to a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.66327057090135,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52105, 662.1595 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'single round of remote procedure calls; a minority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7577334242531,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52105, 650.2794 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'slow servers need not impact overall system perfor-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.87746824746426,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52105, 638.2794 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mance.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.650645491824726,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52105, 626.3993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.60115, 606.8391 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.60115, 606.8391 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.57875, 606.8391 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'What’s wrong with Paxos?',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 136.53784104140811,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.4812753888, 606.8391 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56131, 593.8793000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Over the last ten years, Leslie Lamport’s Paxos proto-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83718350527687,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56131, 593.8793000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'col [15] has become almost synonymous with consensus:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.73018718218773,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 581.9992000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it is the protocol most commonly taught in courses, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66137467976262,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 569.9992000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'most implementations of consensus use it as a starting',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66137695124434,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 557.9992000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'point. Paxos first defines a protocol capable of reaching',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78175446436188,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 546.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'agreement on a single decision, such as a single replicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7812821854123,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 534.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entry. We refer to this subset as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 143.31535692301065,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60115, 522.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9646430769897165,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 461.91650692301033, 522.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'single-decree Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 79.95542503357144,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 464.88115000000005, 522.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.49066,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 544.80105, 522.1191000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos then combines multiple instances of this protocol to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54139654895695,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60105000000004, 510.2394000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'facilitate a series of decisions such as a log (',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 175.3973791576079,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60105000000004, 498.2394000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'multi-Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.55569763652265,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 494.04105000000004, 498.2394000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ').',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.850650800771188,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 541.5613500000001, 498.2394000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos ensures both safety and liveness, and it supports',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87573315333472,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 486.3593000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'changes in cluster membership. Its correctness has been',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66152104090636,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 474.3593000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'proven, and it is efficient in the normal case.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.61097531981792,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 462.3593000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Unfortunately, Paxos has two significant drawbacks.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.85102691236125,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56151, 449.3991000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The first drawback is that Paxos is exceptionally diffi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67762124497972,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 437.51900000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cult to understand. The full explanation [15] is notori-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79777234714044,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 425.51900000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ously opaque; few people succeed in understanding it, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66155789271184,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 413.51900000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'only with great effort. As a result, there have been several',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72945788705147,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 401.63890000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'attempts to explain Paxos in simpler terms [16, 20, 21].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6909790331397,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 389.63890000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'These explanations focus on the single-decree subset, yet',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72990469153027,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 377.63890000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'they are still challenging. In an informal survey of atten-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67799631845017,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 365.7592 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dees at NSDI 2012, we found few people who were com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6783697580481,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 353.7592 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'fortable with Paxos, even among seasoned researchers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81094014775599,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 341.8791 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We struggled with Paxos ourselves; we were not able to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5418869798363,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 329.8791 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'understand the complete protocol until after reading sev-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776429436096,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 317.8791 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'eral simplified explanations and designing our own alter-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55803904941328,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 305.99899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'native protocol, a process that took almost a year.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.65054103723074,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 293.99899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We hypothesize that Paxos’ opaqueness derives from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83105561492744,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56151, 281.0392 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its choice of the single-decree subset as its foundation.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.050484274875,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 269.0392 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Single-decree Paxos is dense and subtle: it is divided into',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66139087901482,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 257.15909999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two stages that do not have simple intuitive explanations',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.99498667144474,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 245.15909999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and cannot be understood independently. Because of this,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.57100597331856,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 233.15909999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it is difficult to develop intuitions about why the single-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67745989006227,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 221.27899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'decree protocol works. The composition rules for multi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67771219392017,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 209.27899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos add significant additional complexity and subtlety.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8112214827471,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 197.27899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We believe that the overall problem of reaching consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75550926412635,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 185.39889999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on multiple decisions (i.e., a log instead of a single entry)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79757805573527,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 173.39889999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can be decomposed in other ways that are more direct and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66226975322772,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 161.51879999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'obvious.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.17080761844138,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 149.51879999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The second problem with Paxos is that it does not pro-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83770296728892,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56151, 136.55899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'vide a good foundation for building practical implemen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79736109932395,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 124.55899999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tations. One reason is that there is no widely agreed-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79769936083966,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 112.67889999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'upon algorithm for multi-Paxos. Lamport’s descriptions',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87565358172918,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 100.67889999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'are mostly about single-decree Paxos; he sketched possi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67813982031703,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 88.67889999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ble approaches to multi-Paxos, but many details are miss-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55767324119807,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 76.79879999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing. There have been several attempts to flesh out and op-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67667123751704,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 64.79879999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'timize Paxos, such as [26], [39], and [13], but these differ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79814779919136,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60135, 52.79879999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08145, 22.918699999999973 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 3
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 2,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 6, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 5,
      streamId: 3,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'from each other and from Lamport’s sketches. Systems',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63608175847105,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'such as Chubby [4] have implemented Paxos-like algo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776573296618,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rithms, but in most cases their details have not been pub-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79770973194823,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lished.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.370661155969614,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Furthermore, the Paxos architecture is a poor one for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71715825118466,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 649.9201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'building practical systems; this is another consequence of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67746077673735,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 637.9201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the single-decree decomposition. For example, there is lit-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5575591200001,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 626.0400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tle benefit to choosing a collection of log entries indepen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91754187022704,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 614.0400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dently and then melding them into a sequential log; this',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63543320057002,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 602.0400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'just adds complexity. It is simpler and more efficient to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54134726377714,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 590.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'design a system around a log, where new entries are ap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67739796229193,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 578.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pended sequentially in a constrained order. Another prob-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79756297229844,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 566.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lem is that Paxos uses a symmetric peer-to-peer approach',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90124467487297,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 554.2802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'at its core (though it eventually suggests a weak form of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774011503368,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 542.2802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leadership as a performance optimization). This makes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75573501754852,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 530.4001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sense in a simplified world where only one decision will',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60953520830085,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 518.4001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be made, but few practical systems use this approach. If a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58359721603205,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 506.4001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'series of decisions must be made, it is simpler and faster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5581870444305,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 494.52000000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to first elect a leader, then have the leader coordinate the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70301600437722,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 482.52000000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'decisions.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.6906614212752,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 470.52000000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'As a result, practical systems bear little resemblance',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.86370916379136,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 458.28020000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to Paxos. Each implementation begins with Paxos, dis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55757446162235,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 446.28020000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'covers the difficulties in implementing it, and then de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772625401266,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 434.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'velops a significantly different architecture. This is time-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6775591200001,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 422.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consuming and error-prone, and the difficulties of under-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79806838698823,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 410.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'standing Paxos exacerbate the problem. Paxos’ formula-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91763732228063,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 398.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion may be a good one for proving theorems about its cor-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777597655263,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 386.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rectness, but real implementations are so different from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79104797360873,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 374.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos that the proofs have little value. The following com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67725763850768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 362.63990000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ment from the Chubby implementers is typical:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.88931578981177,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 350.63990000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.6801, 335.8801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There are significant gaps between the description of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 189.10604081840756,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.6801, 335.8801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the Paxos algorithm and the needs of a real-world',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 189.16327134797416,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.6801, 324.9602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'system. . . . the final system will be based on an un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 189.10560836990015,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.6801, 313.9200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'proven protocol [4].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 71.7218601304922,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.6801, 303.0001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96018, 287.16030000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Because of these problems, we concluded that Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.79506931391734,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96018, 287.16030000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'does not provide a good foundation either for system',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55063944799303,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 275.28020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'building or for education. Given the importance of con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67701407188503,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 263.28020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus in large-scale software systems, we decided to see',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58355501428898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 251.28020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'if we could design an alternative consensus algorithm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79075127622713,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 239.40010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with better properties than Paxos. Raft is the result of that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60962659559746,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 227.40010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'experiment.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.49056857117153,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 215.52000000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72.00001999999999, 196.68020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '4',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72.00001999999999, 196.68020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.9025253888,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 77.97761999999999, 196.68020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Designing for understandability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 162.33792839587846,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 89.88014538879999, 196.68020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96018, 184.32000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We had several goals in designing Raft: it must provide',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.9829461837696,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96018, 184.32000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a complete and practical foundation for system building,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81057888250461,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 172.44030000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'so that it significantly reduces the amount of design work',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66137486905268,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 160.44030000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'required of developers; it must be safe under all conditions',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87517751697683,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 148.44030000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and available under typical operating conditions; and it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60932691938632,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 136.56020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'must be efficient for common operations. But our most',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7301267986265,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 124.56020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'important goal—and most difficult challenge—was',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 211.355298180345,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999999, 112.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.924701819654956,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 283.355318180345, 112.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.397557524804009,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 287.28002, 112.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'derstandability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.463398598354814,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999998, 100.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. It must be possible for a large audience to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 168.06126910394528,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 132.48011999999997, 100.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'understand the algorithm comfortably. In addition, it must',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72937045492324,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999998, 88.68010000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be possible to develop intuitions about the algorithm, so',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54130986402666,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999998, 76.80000000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that system builders can make the extensions that are in-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67772375058271,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999998, 64.80000000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'evitable in real-world implementations.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.17041916054987,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00001999999998, 52.80000000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There were numerous points in the design of Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.64981146231858,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56002, 698.0400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'where we had to choose among alternative approaches.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.93052401704603,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 686.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In these situations we evaluated the alternatives based on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.661080652368,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 674.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'understandability: how hard is it to explain each alterna-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67732123003867,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 662.1603000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tive (for example, how complex is its state space, and does',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75471074856736,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 650.2802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it have subtle implications?), and how easy will it be for a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58336588353112,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 638.2802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'reader to completely understand the approach and its im-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67745216901622,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 626.4001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'plications?',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 43.30344620208385,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 614.4001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We recognize that there is a high degree of subjectiv-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.8377623147356,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56002, 601.6802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ity in such analysis; nonetheless, we used two techniques',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87577683951108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 589.8001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that are generally applicable. The first technique is the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7040893592853,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 577.8001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'well-known approach of problem decomposition: wher-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67792545419192,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 565.8001000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ever possible, we divided problems into separate pieces',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7563355754501,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 553.9200000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that could be solved, explained, and understood relatively',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78199533110896,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 541.9200000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'independently. For example, in Raft we separated leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67806230101493,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 529.9200000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election, log replication, safety, and membership changes.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81066000000044,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59986000000004, 518.0403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Our second approach was to simplify the state space',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74364557346004,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55985999999996, 505.3200000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'by reducing the number of states to consider, making the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70357900312592,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 493.3200000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'system more coherent and eliminating nondeterminism',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9107314493735,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 481.4403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'where possible. Specifically, logs are not allowed to have',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70376790474316,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 469.4403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'holes, and Raft limits the ways in which logs can become',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82364525348189,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 457.5602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'inconsistent with each other. Although in most cases we',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58352363197295,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 445.5602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tried to eliminate nondeterminism, there are some situ-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5578827953676,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 433.5602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ations where nondeterminism actually improves under-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7981929698013,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 421.68010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'standability. In particular, randomized approaches intro-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79755912000053,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 409.68010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'duce nondeterminism, but they tend to reduce the state',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58382088726268,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 397.68010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'space by handling all possible choices in a similar fashion',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66156660005944,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 385.8000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(“choose any; it doesn’t matter”). We used randomization',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90102956155008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 373.8000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to simplify the Raft leader election algorithm.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 182.61118350888194,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 361.9199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.5997, 342.7199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.5997, 342.7199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.5773, 342.7199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The Raft consensus algorithm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.5189369477121,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.47982538879995, 342.7199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55985999999996, 330.0000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft is an algorithm for managing a replicated log of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71720718767222,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55985999999996, 330.0000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the form described in Section 2. Figure 2 summarizes the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7041058175664,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 318.1199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'algorithm in condensed form for reference, and Figure 3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54126320898345,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 306.1199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lists key properties of the algorithm; the elements of these',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58366681503483,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 294.1199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'figures are discussed piecewise over the rest of this sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55762008055063,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 282.2402000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.090672377001134,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 270.2402000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft implements consensus by first electing a distin-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7172625799505,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55985999999996, 257.51990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'guished',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.141307175510907,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.5997, 245.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3387928244891896,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 349.7410071755108, 245.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.59546314628695,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 352.0798, 245.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', then giving the leader complete responsi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 169.75787856144987,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 377.64, 245.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'bility for managing the replicated log. The leader accepts',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75616297271227,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 233.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entries from clients, replicates them on other servers,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69096198706305,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 221.64020000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and tells servers when it is safe to apply log entries to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54179466601394,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 209.76010000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'their state machines. Having a leader simplifies the man-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67750127486875,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 197.76010000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'agement of the replicated log. For example, the leader can',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66124494626393,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 185.76010000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'decide where to place new entries in the log without con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67764565344768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 173.88000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sulting other servers, and data flows in a simple fashion',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6617376984388,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 161.88000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from the leader to other servers. A leader can fail or be-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67772368084425,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 149.99990000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'come disconnected from the other servers, in which case',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58381514878195,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 137.99990000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a new leader is elected.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 92.4907729331246,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 125.99990000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Given the leader approach, Raft decomposes the con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71781169077946,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55995999999993, 113.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus problem into three relatively independent subprob-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91827269960942,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 101.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lems, which are discussed in the subsections that follow:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 225.37019622201407,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59979999999996, 89.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55995999999993, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.55995999999993, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.5412799999999, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Leader election:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 68.95761443371144,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5201199999999, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.202585566288576,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 407.47773443371136, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'a new leader must be chosen when',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.5815434311583,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 409.68031999999994, 76.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'an existing leader fails (Section 5.2).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 146.37064781151128,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5198199999999, 64.79990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56004999999993, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56004999999993, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.5413699999999, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Log replication:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 69.0774698646424,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5202099999999, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0424301353576766,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 407.59767986464226, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'the leader must accept log entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 136.7162138756769,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 410.64010999999994, 52.799900000000065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08010999999993, 22.919800000000066 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 4
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 3,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 7, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 6,
      streamId: 4,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Invoked by candidates to gather votes (§5.2).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 151.6342567110001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 662.836 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 647.086 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Arguments:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.13298593780001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 647.086 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 636.586 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.25301406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 636.586 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.76568593779996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 343.5410140622, 636.586 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'candidate’s term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 55.285567986600036,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 636.586 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 627.136 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidateId',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.9413859378,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 627.136 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.077314062200003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 369.2293859378, 627.136 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'candidate requesting vote',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 85.84546304880007,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 627.136 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 616.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lastLogIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.1413859378,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 616.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.877314062200014,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 373.42938593779996, 616.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'index of candidate’s last log entry (§5.4)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 136.00838984880008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 616.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 607.1859999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lastLogTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 45.89032010220003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 607.1859999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.12837989779996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 372.1783201022, 607.1859999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'term of candidate’s last log entry (§5.4)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.74021437320016,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 607.1859999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 590.386 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Results:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.1385859378,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 590.386 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 579.886 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.25301406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 579.886 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.76568593779996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 343.5410140622, 579.886 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'currentTerm, for candidate to update itself',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 141.70791851580017,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 579.886 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 570.4359999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'voteGranted',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 45.258028124400006,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 570.4359999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.76067187560011,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 371.54602812439987, 570.4359999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'true means candidate received vote',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 118.02429637320006,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 392.3067, 570.4359999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 553.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Receiver implementation:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 102.2289325512,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 553.636 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 544.186 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 544.186 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743749999999977,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 332.588, 544.186 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reply false if term < currentTerm (§5.1)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 135.48293250660012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 340.33175, 544.186 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 533.686 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743749999999977,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 332.588, 533.686 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If votedFor is null or candidateId, and candidate’s log is at',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.2047512488001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 340.33175, 533.686 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'least as up-to-date as receiver’s log, grant vote (§5.2, §5.4)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 197.42815779539993,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 339.938, 523.186 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 388.095, 677.062 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RequestVote RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 88.47851194665004,
  height: 10.5,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 388.095, 677.062 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 385.287 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Invoked by leader to replicate log entries (§5.3); also used as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 204.58551517320004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 385.287 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'heartbeat (§5.2).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 55.27864012440003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 375.837 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 359.037 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Arguments:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.13298593780001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 359.037 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 349.587 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.25301406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 349.587 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.76568593779997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 97.84051406220003, 349.587 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader’s term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 43.92968274660004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 349.587 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 339.087 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leaderId',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.33181406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 339.087 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.68688593779997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 110.91931406220003, 339.087 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'so follower can redirect clients',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 103.56907664880005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 339.087 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 329.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prevLogIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.71864224000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 329.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.300057759999959,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 131.30614224000004, 329.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'index of log entry immediately preceding',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.2768843732,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 329.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'new ones',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.491016124399998,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 319.137 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 308.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prevLogTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.4681623422,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 308.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.550537657799964,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 130.05561234220005, 308.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'term of prevLogIndex entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.54397286220008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.60615, 308.637 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 299.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries[]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.85301406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 299.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.165685937799964,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 110.44046406220005, 299.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'log entries to store (empty for heartbeat;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 135.30407917320002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.60615, 299.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'may send more than one for efficiency)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.33772676880005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68740000000003, 288.687 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58740000000003, 279.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leaderCommit',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.784828124400015,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58740000000003, 279.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.233871875599931,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 132.3722281244001, 279.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader’s commitIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.33065920880004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.60610000000003, 279.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 262.437 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Results:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.1385859378,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 262.437 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 251.937 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.25301406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 251.937 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.76568593779997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 97.84051406220003, 251.937 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'currentTerm, for leader to update itself',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 130.04129714100006,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 251.937 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 242.48700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'success',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.671374992199986,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 242.48700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.347325007799995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 106.2588749922, 242.48700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'true if follower contained entry matching',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.33549637320004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 242.48700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prevLogIndex and prevLogTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 109.98170423100008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 231.98700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 215.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Receiver implementation:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 102.22834661340002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 215.187 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 205.737 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 205.737 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743750000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 86.8875, 205.737 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reply false if term < currentTerm (§5.1)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 135.4825419066001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.63125000000001, 205.737 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 195.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743750000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 86.8875, 195.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reply false if log doesn’t contain an entry at prevLogIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 198.84717330659993,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.63125000000001, 195.237 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'whose term matches prevLogTerm (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.14825776880005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.23750000000001, 185.787 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '3.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 175.287 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743750000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 86.8875, 175.287 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If an existing entry conflicts with a new one (same index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 190.82690523540003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.63125000000001, 175.287 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'but different terms), delete the existing entry and all that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 189.2789935554,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.23750000000001, 164.787 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'follow it (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.096422924400024,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.23750000000001, 155.33700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '4.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 144.83700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743750000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 86.8875, 144.83700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Append any new entries not already in the log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 154.9012791732,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.63125000000001, 144.83700000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.300000000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 135.38700000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.743750000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 86.8875, 135.38700000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If leaderCommit > commitIndex, set commitIndex =',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.76374509920004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.63125000000001, 135.38700000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'min(leaderCommit, index of last new entry)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 147.91540468320005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 94.23750000000001, 124.88700000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 136.757, 399.62 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'AppendEntries RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.75781032735,
  height: 10.5,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 136.757, 399.62 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 662.735 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Persistent state on all servers:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 121.84652775120004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 662.735 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 653.285 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(Updated on stable storage before responding to RPCs)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.46926778660003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 653.285 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 642.785 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'currentTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.1919670044,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 642.785 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.695532995599976,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 126.77946700440005, 642.785 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'latest term server has seen (initialized to 0',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 141.6034911732001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.47500000000002, 642.785 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on first boot, increases monotonically)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 129.48405104880004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68750000000003, 633.3349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58750000000003, 622.8349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'votedFor',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.6586140622,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58750000000003, 622.8349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.22888593779996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 113.24611406220006, 622.8349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'candidateId that received vote in current',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 135.52286969760013,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.47500000000002, 622.8349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term (or null if none)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 70.91905578660004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68750000000003, 612.3349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58750000000003, 602.8849999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log[]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.329600000000003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58750000000003, 602.8849999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.557899999999975,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 96.91710000000005, 602.8849999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'log entries; each entry contains command',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.7384895732,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.47500000000002, 602.8849999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for state machine, and term when entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 131.33009797320008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68750000000003, 592.3849999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'was received by leader (first index is 1)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.72605831100012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68750000000003, 582.9349999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 566.135 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Volatile state on all servers:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 110.48827080900003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 566.135 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 556.685 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'commitIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.59440000000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 556.685 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.42429999999996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 128.18190000000004, 556.685 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'index of highest log entry known to be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 129.95503492440008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 556.685 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committed (initialized to 0, increases',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 124.34949843540005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 546.185 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'monotonically)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.33122812440001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 535.685 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 526.2349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lastApplied',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.076,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 526.2349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.811499999999995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 121.66345000000004, 526.2349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'index of highest log entry applied to state',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.2856771110001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.47495000000004, 526.2349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'machine (initialized to 0, increases',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.87349637320004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745000000004, 515.7349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'monotonically)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.33122812440001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745000000004, 505.2349999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 489.485 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Volatile state on leaders:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.34230539560004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 489.485 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 478.985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(Reinitialized after election)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 94.70589843540004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 478.985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 469.535 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nextIndex[]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.52940468740002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.5875, 469.535 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.489295312599964,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 122.11690468740004, 469.535 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'for each server, index of the next log entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 142.65355127100005,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.6062, 469.535 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to send to that server (initialized to leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.7386911732001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 459.035 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'last log index + 1)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 61.20200520000001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745, 448.535 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 439.08500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'matchIndex[]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.52660468740002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 80.58745000000002, 439.08500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.36089531259998,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 129.11405468740006, 439.08500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'for each server, index of highest log entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 140.0923304088,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 146.47495000000004, 439.08500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'known to be replicated on server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 109.87024012440003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745000000004, 428.58500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(initialized to 0, increases monotonically)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.74689163540003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 145.68745000000004, 419.13500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 173.8, 677.062 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'State',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.67313476595,
  height: 10.5,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 173.8, 677.062 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 485.155 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'All Servers:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.68716021340002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 485.155 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 475.705 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 475.705 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 475.705 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If commitIndex > lastApplied: increment lastApplied, apply',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 201.88794561179998,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 475.705 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log[lastApplied] to state machine (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 134.1462422874,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 465.205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 455.755 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 455.755 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 455.755 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If RPC request or response contains term T > currentTerm:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 197.712144378,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 455.755 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'set currentTerm = T, convert to follower (§5.1)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.10330625360012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 445.255 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 428.455 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Followers (§5.2):',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.28396953780003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 428.455 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 419.005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 419.005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 419.005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Respond to RPCs from candidates and leaders',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 155.38104944880007,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 419.005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 408.505 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 408.505 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 408.505 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If election timeout elapses without receiving AppendEntries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 201.5756691732,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 408.505 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RPC from current leader or granting vote to candidate:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 183.82911517320008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 399.055 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'convert to candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 68.11306304880006,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 388.555 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 372.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Candidates (§5.2):',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 72.34876953780004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 372.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 362.305 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 362.305 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 362.305 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'On conversion to candidate, start election:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 141.83869117320012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 362.305 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 351.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 351.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 351.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Increment currentTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 77.54968856880004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 351.805 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 342.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 342.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 342.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Vote for self',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.370203662200026,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 342.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 331.855 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 331.855 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 331.855 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reset election timer',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 67.18925418660002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 331.855 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 321.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 321.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 321.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Send RequestVote RPCs to all other servers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 146.8400134488001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 321.355 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 311.90500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 311.90500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.22794999999996, 311.90500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If votes received from majority of servers: become leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 193.1365083732001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.00044999999994, 311.90500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 301.40500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 301.40500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.22794999999996, 301.40500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If AppendEntries RPC received from new leader: convert to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 201.55378717320008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.00044999999994, 301.40500000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.45861406220001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.73794999999996, 291.95500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 281.45500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28794999999997, 281.45500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.22794999999996, 281.45500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If election timeout elapses: start new election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.1025083732,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.00044999999994, 281.45500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 264.655 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leaders:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.0123718756,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 264.655 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 255.205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 255.205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 255.205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Upon election: send initial empty AppendEntries RPCs',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.27069163540008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 255.205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(heartbeat) to each server; repeat during idle periods to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 184.27295422200012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 244.705 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prevent election timeouts (§5.2)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 107.3158651110001,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 235.25500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 224.75500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 224.75500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 224.75500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If command received from client: append entry to local log,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 200.61935215980012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 224.75500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'respond after entry applied to state machine (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 169.35631203540018,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 214.25500000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 204.80500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.288, 204.80500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.228, 204.80500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If last log index ≥ nextIndex for a follower: send',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 163.48002911100016,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.0005, 204.80500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'AppendEntries RPC with log entries starting at nextIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 193.88685311100002,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 194.30500000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 184.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 184.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 184.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If successful: update nextIndex and matchIndex for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 172.62098883540008,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 184.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'follower (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.853014062200046,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.138, 174.35500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 163.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.738, 163.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.1162499999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 338.678, 163.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If AppendEntries fails because of log inconsistency:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 174.96856837320007,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.79425, 163.85500000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'decrement nextIndex and retry (§5.3)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 125.26080191100012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 344.138, 154.40500000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28799999999995, 143.90500000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9400000000000004,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 326.28799999999995, 143.90500000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7724999999999795,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 329.22799999999995, 143.90500000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f8',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If there exists an N such that N > commitIndex, a majority',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.510370637,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 336.00049999999993, 143.90500000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of matchIndex[i] ≥ N, and log[N].term == currentTerm:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 187.28944756620012,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.73799999999994, 134.45500000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'set commitIndex = N (§5.3, §5.4).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 114.62756980920003,
  height: 8.4,
  transform: [ 8.4, 0, 0, 8.4, 335.73799999999994, 123.95500000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 388.859, 499.382 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Rules for Servers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.94897498524999,
  height: 10.5,
  transform: [ 10.5, 0, 0, 10.5, 388.859, 499.382 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 107.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 2:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.425830505386,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 107.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9343694946140033,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 111.465630505386, 107.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A condensed summary of the Raft consensus algorithm (excluding membership changes and log compaction). The server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 428.7459717183451,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 113.4, 107.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'behavior in the upper-left box is described as a set of rules that trigger independently and repeatedly. Section numbers such as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 447.7280069119701,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.04000000000002, 96.5998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.1520930880299147,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 524.7680069119701, 96.5998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 526.9201, 96.5998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.203189822321598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 531.00018, 96.5998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'indicate where particular features are discussed. A formal specification [31] describes the algorithm more precisely.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 414.08154155640625,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.04018000000002, 85.6799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08038000000005, 22.919700000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '4',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08038000000005, 22.919700000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 5
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 4,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 8, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 7,
      streamId: 5,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Election Safety:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.46581887789858,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.8801, 696.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.054081122101422,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 138.34591887789858, 696.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'at most one leader can be elected in a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 150.50144215736483,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 143.4, 696.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'given term.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.521465153796186,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80000000000001, 686.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.1984348462038383,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 138.32146515379617, 686.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 140.5199, 686.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.203189822321598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 144.59998000000002, 686.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88008000000002, 673.0799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leader Append-Only:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 84.94553518764315,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88008000000002, 673.0799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.694264812356835,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 162.82561518764317, 673.0799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'a leader never overwrites or deletes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 126.24764000542169,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 167.51988, 673.0799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries in its log; it only appends new entries.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 162.4420196467236,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.79998, 662.1600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.197980353276364,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 260.2419996467236, 662.1600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 262.43998, 662.1600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.203189822321598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 266.52006, 662.1600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88006000000001, 649.1998000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Log Matching:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 57.105995425096204,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88006000000001, 649.1998000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.934204574903816,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 134.9860554250962, 649.1998000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'if two logs contain an entry with the same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 153.86127524005923,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 139.92026, 649.1998000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'index and term, then the logs are identical in all entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.08763864173878,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.79996000000001, 638.1600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'up through the given index.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.24138538959554,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.79996000000001, 627.2397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4386146104044997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 196.0413453895955, 627.2397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 198.47996, 627.2397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.203189822321598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 202.56004000000001, 627.2397000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88004000000001, 614.2799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leader Completeness:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 85.42569691435702,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88004000000001, 614.2799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.934103085643045,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.30573691435697, 614.2799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'if a log entry is committed in a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 125.66088611466256,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 168.23984000000002, 614.2799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'given term, then that entry will be present in the logs',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 195.96770901434286,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80004000000001, 603.3600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the leaders for all higher-numbered terms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 160.40195945939732,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80004000000001, 592.3198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.318040540602624,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 258.20199945939737, 592.3198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 260.52004, 592.3198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.4',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.203189822321598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 264.60012, 592.3198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88012, 579.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'State Machine Safety:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 84.10569803931381,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.88012, 579.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.054101960686211,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 161.98581803931378, 579.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'if a server has applied a log entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 126.76345969837112,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 167.03992, 579.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'at a given index to its state machine, no other server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.06588796126937,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80011999999999, 568.4402000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'will ever apply a different log entry for the same index.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 195.92160621964172,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80011999999999, 557.5199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80011999999999, 546.5996000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '§',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0886692799999995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 97.80011999999999, 546.5996000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f9',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '5.4.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.92320183891999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 101.88019999999999, 546.5996000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 530.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 3:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.666057758346,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 530.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.054242241653995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 111.705857758346, 530.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Raft guarantees that each of these properties is true',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 181.82097900220916,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 113.7601, 530.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'at all times. The section numbers indicate where each prop-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50608764357597,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03979999999999, 519.5998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'erty is discussed.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.80180466626876,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03979999999999, 508.6799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91989999999998, 485.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from clients and replicate them across the cluster,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.77036902064006,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91989999999998, 485.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'forcing the other logs to agree with its own (Sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75767066958397,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91989999999998, 473.27989999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion 5.3).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.4506497973864,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91989999999998, 461.27989999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012999999998, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012999999998, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94144999999997, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Safety:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.077566822511997,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92028999999998, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.802533177488016,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 121.99785682251196, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'the key safety property for Raft is the State',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 175.78284315375325,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 124.80038999999998, 449.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Machine Safety Property in Figure 3: if any server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75794465214645,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 437.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'has applied a particular log entry to its state machine,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.890921368127,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 425.3997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'then no other server may apply a different command',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.98155811939986,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 413.5196999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for the same log index. Section 5.4 describes how',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.79303705528264,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 401.5196999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft ensures this property; the solution involves an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.74085695119683,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 389.5196999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'additional restriction on the election mechanism de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75733263720878,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 377.63959999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'scribed in Section 5.2.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 89.01054552085346,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91988999999998, 365.63959999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'After presenting the consensus algorithm, this section dis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5575591200001,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999998, 351.35989999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cusses the issue of availability and the role of timing in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70352872168226,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 339.35989999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'system.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.210660609474957,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 327.47979999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 309.71959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.1',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541318828509604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 309.71959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898530411600007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.54130882850957, 309.71959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Raft basics',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.71531277817687,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.43983924010958, 309.71959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96014999999997, 294.35979999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'A Raft cluster contains several servers; five is a typical',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.76995495302285,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96014999999997, 294.35979999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number, which allows the system to tolerate two failures.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.690878191298,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 282.35979999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'At any given time each server is in one of three states:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.4902719965419,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 270.35979999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.59546324591337,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99998999999997, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.49066,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 97.56018999999996, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9093400000000003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 100.05084999999997, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.275451692152096,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 102.96018999999997, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.757558318215189,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 136.19998999999996, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9225416817848213,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 149.95754831821515, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.583387280380336,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 152.88008999999997, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. In normal operation there',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 108.22385074341517,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 192.48008999999996, 258.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'is exactly one leader and all of the other servers are fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776238850792,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999996, 246.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lowers. Followers are passive: they issue no requests on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66193850541055,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999996, 234.4796999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'their own but simply respond to requests from leaders',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75549469874645,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999996, 222.5995999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and candidates. The leader handles all client requests (if',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67768111048346,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999996, 210.5995999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a client contacts a follower, the follower redirects it to the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70241216000008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999996, 198.7194999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader). The third state, candidate, is used to elect a new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7127120341682,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999994, 186.7194999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader as described in Section 5.2. Figure 4 shows the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70350689353776,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999994, 174.7194999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'states and their transitions; the transitions are discussed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000002,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999994, 162.8397999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'below.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.13050792300377,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00008999999994, 150.8397999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft divides time into',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.66160558891323,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96024999999995, 136.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.858694411086674,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 175.62185558891326, 136.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'terms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.11546512380177,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 180.48054999999994, 136.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.004434876198189,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 202.59601512380175, 136.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'of arbitrary length, as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.03542149554866,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 207.60044999999994, 136.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shown in Figure 5. Terms are numbered with consecutive',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82385055360453,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00044999999994, 124.5596999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'integers. Each term begins with an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.82168458940458,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00044999999994, 112.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.5783154105953088,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 209.82213458940464, 112.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.6213324558913,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 212.40044999999995, 112.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', in which one',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 56.62336380736534,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 244.08054999999996, 112.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'or more candidates attempt to become leader as described',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78191395626556,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00054999999995, 100.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in Section 5.2. If a candidate wins the election, then it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60932835400658,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00054999999995, 88.6799999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'serves as leader for the rest of the term. In some situations',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75536351070295,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00054999999995, 76.7998999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'an election will result in a split vote. In this case the term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67112659000117,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00054999999995, 64.7998999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'will end with no leader; a new term (with a new election)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79761280542365,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00054999999995, 52.799899999999795 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 611.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 4:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.62580669994156,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 611.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.134393300058491,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 359.2658066999415, 611.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Server states. Followers only respond to requests',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 179.76780441713336,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 362.4002, 611.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from other servers. If a follower receives no communication,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.36259500000008,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 600.6002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it becomes a candidate and initiates an election. A candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.42007272,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 589.6803 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that receives votes from a majority of the full cluster becomes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.4079496391658,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 578.7604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the new leader. Leaders typically operate until they fail.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 199.1621109962484,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 567.7202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 467.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 5:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.50588136744159,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 467.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.014018632558475,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 359.1458813674415, 467.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Time is divided into terms, and each term begins',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 180.00831795764066,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 362.1599, 467.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with an election. After a successful election, a single leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50583235916577,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 456.9601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'manages the cluster until the end of the term. Some elections',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.52785900051774,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64000000000004, 446.0402 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'fail, in which case the term ends without choosing a leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.48119436347937,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64000000000004, 435 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The transitions between terms may be observed at different',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.49230165499839,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64000000000004, 424.0801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'times on different servers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.20201559037716,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64000000000004, 413.16020000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 396.3602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'will begin shortly. Raft ensures that there is at most one',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70332994708866,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 396.3602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader in a given term.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 89.01086722446162,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 384.3602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Different servers may observe the transitions between',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7021278752449,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56032, 371.40000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'terms at different times, and in some situations a server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67803508308265,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 359.40000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'may not observe an election or even entire terms. Terms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75528562278342,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 347.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'act as a logical clock [14] in Raft, and they allow servers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75613999886446,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 335.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to detect obsolete information such as stale leaders. Each',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6615695191128,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 323.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server stores a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.1433565790645,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 311.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.176543420935616,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 380.7435165790644, 311.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'current term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.433005991236456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 385.92006000000003, 311.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.166994008763709,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 438.35306599123635, 311.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'number, which increases',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 103.83565563910281,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 443.52006000000006, 311.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'monotonically over time. Current terms are exchanged',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90138204971572,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 299.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'whenever servers communicate; if one server’s current',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84970857576175,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 287.6398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term is smaller than the other’s, then it updates its current',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.849767654217,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 275.75969999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term to the larger value. If a candidate or leader discovers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8753597137373,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 263.75969999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that its term is out of date, it immediately reverts to fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772257680223,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 251.87959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lower state. If a server receives a request with a stale term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6709122238761,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 239.87959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number, it rejects the request.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 117.57056315804282,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 227.87959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft servers communicate using remote procedure calls',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.6761052503494,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56022, 214.91939999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(RPCs), and the basic consensus algorithm requires only',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6608969711742,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 202.91939999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two types of RPCs. RequestVote RPCs are initiated by',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6613471430253,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 190.91939999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidates during elections (Section 5.2), and Append-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91783175316272,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 179.03969999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Entries RPCs are initiated by leaders to replicate log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777386447295,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 167.03969999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tries and to provide a form of heartbeat (Section 5.3). Sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55764485763652,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 155.15959999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion 7 adds a third RPC for transferring snapshots between',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66236227626544,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 143.15959999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers. Servers retry RPCs if they do not receive a re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67758343676073,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 131.15959999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sponse in a timely manner, and they issue RPCs in parallel',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.73011737396888,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 119.27949999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for best performance.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 85.89089956450312,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 107.27949999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 90.95959999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541337159767226,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 90.95959999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898510486319992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 331.1413971597672, 90.95959999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Leader election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 65.65929357005705,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 341.0399076460872, 90.95959999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56022, 76.79939999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft uses a heartbeat mechanism to trigger leader elec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71767175553768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56022, 76.79939999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion. When servers start up, they begin as followers. A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5931737439562,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 64.79939999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server remains in follower state as long as it receives valid',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66099777316583,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60006000000004, 52.79939999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08016000000003, 22.91929999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 6
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 5,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 9, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 8,
      streamId: 6,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'RPCs from a leader or candidate. Leaders send periodic',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82326431201653,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'heartbeats (AppendEntries RPCs that carry no log entries)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.677885304753,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to all followers in order to maintain their authority. If a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5836095796683,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'follower receives no communication over a period of time',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58248779636702,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'called the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.503483739498165,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.536716260501848,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 110.50348373949815, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'election timeout',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 64.0896576903612,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 113.0402, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', then it assumes there is no vi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 123.55742984786278,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 177.1203, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'able leader and begins an election to choose a new leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69142234073212,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To begin an election, a follower increments its current',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.89026869528166,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96045999999998, 624.0001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term and transitions to candidate state. It then votes for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6781272076148,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 612.1200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'itself and issues RequestVote RPCs in parallel to each of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6779018925485,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 600.1200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the other servers in the cluster. A candidate continues in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54129628494834,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 588.1200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'this state until one of three things happens: (a) it wins the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70349812641484,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 576.2403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election, (b) another server establishes itself as leader, or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67754611816795,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 564.2403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(c) a period of time goes by with no winner. These out-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67705922256937,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 552.2403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'comes are discussed separately in the paragraphs below.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 223.41018450562436,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 540.3602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'A candidate wins an election if it receives votes from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83086775938753,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96045999999998, 526.0801000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a majority of the servers in the full cluster for the same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5839501126663,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 514.0801000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term. Each server will vote for at most one candidate in a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5835647179004,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 502.2000000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'given term, on a first-come-first-served basis (note: Sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5576805537757,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 490.2000000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion 5.4 adds an additional restriction on votes). The ma-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6770729510873,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 478.2000000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'jority rule ensures that at most one candidate can win the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70272064198906,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 466.3199000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election for a particular term (the Election Safety Prop-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79711382659923,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 454.3199000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'erty in Figure 3). Once a candidate wins an election, it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6097500526324,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 442.3199000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'becomes leader. It then sends heartbeat messages to all of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67789893364449,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 430.4402000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the other servers to establish its authority and prevent new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.71335605906827,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 418.4402000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'elections.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.01065295986855,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 406.56010000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'While waiting for votes, a candidate may receive an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.701398779362,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96045999999998, 392.28000000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'AppendEntries RPC from another server claiming to be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70369067435786,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 380.28000000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader. If the leader’s term (included in its RPC) is at least',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60981558687817,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 368.28000000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'as large as the candidate’s current term, then the candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82327513144352,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 356.3999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'recognizes the leader as legitimate and returns to follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79781189882146,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 344.3999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state. If the term in the RPC is smaller than the candidate’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75598764021115,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 332.3999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'current term, then the candidate rejects the RPC and con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67814826863568,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 320.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tinues in candidate state.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 97.89079747688278,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 308.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The third possible outcome is that a candidate neither',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71733558617672,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96045999999998, 294.2401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'wins nor loses the election: if many followers become',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82286759969165,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 282.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidates at the same time, votes could be split so that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60961813731623,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 270.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'no candidate obtains a majority. When this happens, each',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6618470384127,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 258.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidate will time out and start a new election by incre-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6770821864547,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 246.47990000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'menting its term and initiating another round of Request-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6771344903146,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 234.47990000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Vote RPCs. However, without extra measures split votes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63539804241324,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 222.47990000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'could repeat indefinitely.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.97069744117718,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 210.59980000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft uses randomized election timeouts to ensure that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.64968614227035,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96045999999998, 196.31970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'split votes are rare and that they are resolved quickly. To',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54148328370113,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 184.31970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prevent split votes in the first place, election timeouts are',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7031454888092,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 172.43960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'chosen randomly from a fixed interval (e.g., 150–300ms).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.05078353265537,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 160.43960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This spreads out the servers so that in most cases only a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58361898440052,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 148.43960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'single server will time out; it wins the election and sends',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75540590173625,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 136.55950000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'heartbeats before any other servers time out. The same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58430958464268,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 124.55950000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mechanism is used to handle split votes. Each candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8233093032988,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 112.67940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'restarts its randomized election timeout at the start of an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66142471214047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 100.67940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election, and it waits for that timeout to elapse before',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8235365511171,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 88.67940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'starting the next election; this reduces the likelihood of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67709191995405,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 76.79930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'another split vote in the new election. Section 9.3 shows',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7557083973745,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 64.79930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that this approach elects a leader rapidly.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 162.57034165698653,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00029999999998, 52.79930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 542.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 6:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.66603641836156,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 542.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.0542635816385086,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 358.3060364183615, 542.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Logs are composed of entries, which are numbered',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 181.7234293696292,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 360.3603, 542.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sequentially. Each entry contains the term in which it was',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.52830336534421,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 530.9997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'created (the number in each box) and a command for the state',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.66193250954902,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 520.0799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'machine. An entry is considered',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 113.68324117999744,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 509.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.876758820002749,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 437.32324117999724, 509.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'committed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.363118797079345,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 439.2, 509.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9970812029206968,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 476.5631187970793, 509.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'if it is safe for that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.57237887579178,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 478.5602, 509.15999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry to be applied to state machines.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 133.04142611446775,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64020000000005, 498.11979999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56051, 481.31979999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Elections are an example of how understandability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 219.06186450925657,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56051, 481.31979999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'guided our choice between design alternatives. Initially',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6616472874806,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 469.4400999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'we planned to use a ranking system: each candidate was',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6359858979488,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 457.4400999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'assigned a unique rank, which was used to select between',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6617153323117,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 445.5599999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'competing candidates. If a candidate discovered another',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79795567964194,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 433.5599999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidate with higher rank, it would return to follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79752668836343,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 421.5599999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state so that the higher ranking candidate could more eas-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5578700930017,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 409.67989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ily win the next election. We found that this approach',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90227577822506,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 397.67989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'created subtle issues around availability (a lower-ranked',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90147107586685,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 385.67989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server might need to time out and become a candidate',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8236232559728,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 373.79979999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'again if a higher-ranked server fails, but if it does so too',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66113865485818,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 361.79979999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'soon, it can reset progress towards electing a leader). We',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.4637784775041,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 349.9196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'made adjustments to the algorithm several times, but after',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67749060488123,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 337.9196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'each adjustment new corner cases appeared. Eventually',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90131501111128,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 325.9196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'we concluded that the randomized retry approach is more',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70294231072913,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 314.0395999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'obvious and understandable.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 113.97085302716575,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 302.0395999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 284.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541337159767226,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 284.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898510486319992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 331.14168715976723, 284.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Log replication',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 65.05922870930799,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 341.0401976460872, 284.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56051, 269.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Once a leader has been elected, it begins servicing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82127416546098,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56051, 269.8793999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'client requests. Each client request contains a command to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5420017992624,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 257.9992999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be executed by the replicated state machines. The leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67814316776375,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 245.99929999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'appends the command to its log as a new entry, then is-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55702199338364,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 233.99929999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sues AppendEntries RPCs in parallel to each of the other',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67704541435006,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 222.11919999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers to replicate the entry. When the entry has been',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66180196742908,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 210.11919999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'safely replicated (as described below), the leader applies',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75600108977477,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 198.11919999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the entry to its state machine and returns the result of that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60948062299607,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 186.2394999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'execution to the client. If followers crash or run slowly,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69107916763468,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 174.2394999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'or if network packets are lost, the leader retries Append-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91720957633203,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 162.3593999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Entries RPCs indefinitely (even after it has responded to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5415136398651,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 150.3593999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the client) until all followers eventually store all log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67816603202272,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 138.3593999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tries.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.65069617211072,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 126.4792999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Logs are organized as shown in Figure 6. Each log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7184973993651,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56051, 112.6792999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try stores a state machine command along with the term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67163935711918,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 100.6792999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number when the entry was received by the leader. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70404052242412,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 88.6792999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term numbers in log entries are used to detect inconsis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777551328988,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 76.7991999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tencies between logs and to ensure some of the properties',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8754518880821,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 64.7991999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in Figure 3. Each log entry also has an integer index iden-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6782741864425,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60035000000005, 52.7991999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '6',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08045000000004, 22.9190999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 7
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 6,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 10, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 9,
      streamId: 7,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'tifying its position in the log.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 115.77046136782464,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The leader decides when it is safe to apply a log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71787734457718,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 683.7602999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try to the state machines; such an entry is called',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 193.2615708693769,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 671.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.698429130623083,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 265.26157086937695, 671.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'commit-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.71759080607436,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 267.96000000000004, 671.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ted',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.181316331486961,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 659.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. Raft guarantees that committed entries are durable',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 216.58391974698776,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.23980000000003, 659.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and will eventually be executed by all of the available',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7034797752319,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 647.8802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machines. A log entry is committed once the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67778093613626,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 636.0001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that created the entry has replicated it on a majority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774996210706,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 624.0001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the servers (e.g., entry 7 in Figure 6). This also commits',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7554125767049,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 612.12 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'all preceding entries in the leader’s log, including entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75546696000004,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00000000000003, 600.12 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'created by previous leaders. Section 5.4 discusses some',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.703809558541,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 588.12 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'subtleties when applying this rule after leader changes,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81087864837932,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 576.2403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and it also shows that this definition of commitment is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63551675723144,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 564.2403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'safe. The leader keeps track of the highest index it knows',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75517116201257,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 552.2403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to be committed, and it includes that index in future',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82329130080834,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 540.3602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'AppendEntries RPCs (including heartbeats) so that the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7035303555551,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 528.3602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'other servers eventually find out. Once a follower learns',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75586300758448,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 516.4801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that a log entry is committed, it applies the entry to its',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6349472528786,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 504.4801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'local state machine (in log order).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 134.7304949316489,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 492.4801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We designed the Raft log mechanism to maintain a high',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70142218160368,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 478.2000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'level of coherency between the logs on different servers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69073215892087,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 466.3199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Not only does this simplify the system’s behavior and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6617190981899,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 454.3199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'make it more predictable, but it is an important component',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.96913416859024,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 442.3199000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of ensuring safety. Raft maintains the following proper-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79729551526503,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 430.44020000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ties, which together constitute the Log Matching Property',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7809441331122,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 418.44020000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in Figure 3:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.56978123293233,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 406.56010000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 392.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 392.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94148, 392.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If two entries in different logs have the same index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86139050914454,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92032, 392.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and term, then they store the same command.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 180.81018872738994,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92032, 380.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96055, 368.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96055, 368.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94187, 368.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If two entries in different logs have the same index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86139050914454,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92071, 368.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and term, then the logs are identical in all preceding',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.9811929288681,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92071, 356.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.13067261529352,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92071, 344.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The first property follows from the fact that a leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71765703075604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96094, 330.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'creates at most one entry with a given log index in a given',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7818160733277,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 318.23969999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term, and log entries never change their position in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70312517498638,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 306.23969999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log. The second property is guaranteed by a simple con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67742425369906,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 294.23969999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sistency check performed by AppendEntries. When send-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67795440562404,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 282.35959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing an AppendEntries RPC, the leader includes the index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78171363746318,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 270.35959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and term of the entry in its log that immediately precedes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.875104341386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 258.35959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the new entries. If the follower does not find an entry in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5414204493305,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 246.47949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its log with the same index and term, then it refuses the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70431727460078,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 234.47949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'new entries. The consistency check acts as an induction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78165267606903,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 222.47949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'step: the initial empty state of the logs satisfies the Log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66125819657566,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 210.59939999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Matching Property, and the consistency check preserves',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87557294412102,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 198.59939999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the Log Matching Property whenever logs are extended.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9304901540327,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 186.71929999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'As a result, whenever AppendEntries returns successfully,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8106001128903,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 174.71929999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the leader knows that the follower’s log is identical to its',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63613087428647,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 162.71929999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'own log up through the new entries.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 143.2505605899103,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 150.83959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'During normal operation, the logs of the leader and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70115533229114,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96094, 136.55949999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'followers stay consistent, so the AppendEntries consis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6771505999035,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 124.55949999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tency check never fails. However, leader crashes can leave',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70309823600763,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 112.67979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the logs inconsistent (the old leader may not have fully',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66107756394973,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 100.67979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'replicated all of the entries in its log). These inconsisten-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79755912000005,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 88.67979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cies can compound over a series of leader and follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79740479546297,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 76.79969999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'crashes. Figure 7 illustrates the ways in which followers’',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79783403580743,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 64.79969999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'logs may differ from that of a new leader. A follower may',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6612451853676,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00077999999999, 52.79969999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 564 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 7:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.745974124701604,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 564 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2540258752984528,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 359.38597412470153, 564 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'When the leader at the top comes to power, it is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 179.64845840244527,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 362.64, 564 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'possible that any of scenarios (a–f) could occur in follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50630437891326,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 552.9602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'logs. Each box represents one log entry; the number in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54094466998535,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 542.0403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'box is its term. A follower may be missing entries (a–b), may',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5634656700933,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 531.1204 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have extra uncommitted entries (c–d), or both (e–f). For ex-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50517049049853,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 520.2005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ample, scenario (f) could occur if that server was the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50618019455015,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 509.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for term 2, added several entries to its log, then crashed before',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54106335195888,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 498.24080000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committing any of them; it restarted quickly, became leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50612838680655,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 487.32050000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for term 3, and added a few more entries to its log; before any',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56368221713703,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 476.2807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the entries in either term 2 or term 3 were committed, the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54195254489568,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 465.36080000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server crashed again and remained down for several terms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 210.08085007932513,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 454.44090000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 437.64090000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be missing entries that are present on the leader, it may',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66134438337411,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 437.64090000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have extra entries that are not present on the leader, or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67771710550156,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 425.64090000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'both. Missing and extraneous entries in a log may span',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133322521713,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 413.7608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'multiple terms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.45087506174285,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 401.7608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In Raft, the leader handles inconsistencies by forcing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82137744814972,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 389.0405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the followers’ logs to duplicate its own. This means that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60966872760187,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 377.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'conflicting entries in follower logs will be overwritten',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9008336561969,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 365.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with entries from the leader’s log. Section 5.4 will show',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.71316604163542,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 353.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that this is safe when coupled with one more restriction.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 223.17079637352236,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 341.28069999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To bring a follower’s log into consistency with its own,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.73077909289123,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 328.5608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the leader must find the latest log entry where the two',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54166538083481,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 316.5608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'logs agree, delete any entries in the follower’s log after',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67778700338377,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 304.68069999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that point, and send the follower all of the leader’s entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75487880834154,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 292.68069999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'after that point. All of these actions happen in response',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82410124351503,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 280.68069999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to the consistency check performed by AppendEntries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.99596108737538,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 268.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RPCs. The leader maintains a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.50310823471973,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 256.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.0568917652803407,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 435.1032682347196, 256.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'nextIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.50320050164296,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 437.16015999999996, 256.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9365994983571113,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 475.66336050164284, 256.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'for each follower,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 69.8106633018933,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 477.59995999999995, 256.8005999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which is the index of the next log entry the leader will',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6098046478994,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59995999999995, 244.92049999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'send to that follower. When a leader first comes to power,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81046661351422,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59995999999995, 232.92049999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it initializes all nextIndex values to the index just after the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7034235666366,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59995999999995, 220.92049999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'last one in its log (11 in Figure 7). If a follower’s log is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6355190984516,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 209.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'inconsistent with the leader’s, the AppendEntries consis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774053346458,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 197.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tency check will fail in the next AppendEntries RPC. Af-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67786156378168,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 185.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ter a rejection, the leader decrements nextIndex and retries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7564669600004,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 173.16069999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the AppendEntries RPC. Eventually nextIndex will reach',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66190916543562,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 161.16069999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a point where the leader and follower logs match. When',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.661782072037,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 149.16069999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'this happens, AppendEntries will succeed, which removes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87543337749722,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 137.28059999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'any conflicting entries in the follower’s log and appends',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87615722306867,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 125.28059999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries from the leader’s log (if any). Once AppendEntries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.99593278351492,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 113.40049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'succeeds, the follower’s log is consistent with the leader’s,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69062887816386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 101.40049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and it will remain that way for the rest of the term.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 201.45042302161028,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 89.40049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'If desired, the protocol can be optimized to reduce the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74370722227647,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 76.80049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number of rejected AppendEntries RPCs. For example,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81015625735273,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 64.80049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'when rejecting an AppendEntries request, the follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79759973443987,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 52.80049999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '7',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 8
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 7,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 11, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 10,
      streamId: 8,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'can include the term of the conflicting entry and the first',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60952035400456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'index it stores for that term. With this information, the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7035755660155,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader can decrement nextIndex to bypass all of the con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67777738943659,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'flicting entries in that term; one AppendEntries RPC will',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6095060576161,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be required for each term with conflicting entries, rather',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67783691621045,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'than one RPC per entry. In practice, we doubt this opti-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67705577549614,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mization is necessary, since failures happen infrequently',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9009201717631,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 626.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and it is unlikely that there will be many inconsistent en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67800581284646,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 614.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tries.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.65065353201154,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 602.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 589.92 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'With this mechanism, a leader does not need to take any',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70202784037716,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 589.92 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'special actions to restore log consistency when it comes to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54134826004116,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 578.0399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'power. It just begins normal operation, and the logs auto-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67689993988117,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 566.0399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'matically converge in response to failures of the Append-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91756867969116,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 554.0399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Entries consistency check. A leader never overwrites or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67707660737616,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 542.1598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'deletes entries in its own log (the Leader Append-Only',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90104854037935,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 530.1598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Property in Figure 3).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.49063895576607,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 518.1598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This log replication mechanism exhibits the desirable',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74329631318992,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 505.6797 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus properties described in Section 2: Raft can ac-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67764911048377,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 493.7996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cept, replicate, and apply new log entries as long as a ma-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67742546914113,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 481.7996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'jority of the servers are up; in the normal case a new entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6618119599571,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 469.7996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can be replicated with a single round of RPCs to a ma-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67781173065657,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 457.91949999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'jority of the cluster; and a single slow follower will not',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.73015523200115,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 445.91949999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'impact performance.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 82.89050446623817,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 434.03979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 418.07959999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.4',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541318828509604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 418.07959999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898530411600007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.5413588285096, 418.07959999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Safety',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.7013284502968,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.43988924010961, 418.07959999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 404.51939999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The previous sections described how Raft elects lead-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71757418144193,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 404.51939999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ers and replicates log entries. However, the mechanisms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87556063029788,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 392.51939999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'described so far are not quite sufficient to ensure that each',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6614933646927,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 380.63929999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine executes exactly the same commands in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70307565070274,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 368.63929999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'same order. For example, a follower might be unavailable',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8234402422764,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 356.7595999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'while the leader commits several log entries, then it could',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78129029500167,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 344.7595999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be elected leader and overwrite these entries with new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.71295164562275,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 332.7595999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ones; as a result, different state machines might execute',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8229747179969,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 320.8794999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'different command sequences.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 121.41079877592934,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 308.8794999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This section completes the Raft algorithm by adding a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.62302321850208,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 296.3993999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'restriction on which servers may be elected leader. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70373698070858,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 284.3993999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'restriction ensures that the leader for any given term con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67816751645614,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 272.5192999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tains all of the entries committed in previous terms (the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70336809403736,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 260.5192999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leader Completeness Property from Figure 3). Given the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7035157303995,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 248.51929999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election restriction, we then make the rules for commit-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79768762485014,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 236.63959999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ment more precise. Finally, we present a proof sketch for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777033172081,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 224.63959999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the Leader Completeness Property and show how it leads',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63478106608076,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 212.75949999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to correct behavior of the replicated state machine.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 201.93071888729304,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 200.75949999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 184.91929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.4.1',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.10132373422961,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 184.91929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.778759553520004,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 92.10136373422961, 184.91929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Election restriction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 81.61906938057146,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 101.88012328774961, 184.91929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 172.43959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In any leader-based consensus algorithm, the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71767954632256,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.9602, 172.43959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'must eventually store all of the committed log entries. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66131161625114,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 160.43959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'some consensus algorithms, such as Viewstamped Repli-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5578327729521,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 148.43959999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cation [22], a leader can be elected even if it doesn’t',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84931213242842,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 136.55949999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'initially contain all of the committed entries. These al-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5574228501668,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 124.55949999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'gorithms contain additional mechanisms to identify the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70351595954034,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 112.67939999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'missing entries and transmit them to the new leader, ei-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55742855875943,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 100.67939999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ther during the election process or shortly afterwards. Un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6767339224481,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 88.67939999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'fortunately, this results in considerable additional mecha-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79754841557508,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00004, 76.79929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nism and complexity. Raft uses a simpler approach where',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7032510629053,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00003999999998, 64.79929999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it guarantees that all the committed entries from previous',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87581125046987,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00003999999998, 52.799299999999846 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 596.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 8:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.0258034494816,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 596.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4139965505184477,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 358.66580344948153, 596.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A time sequence showing why a leader cannot de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 181.06586813740503,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 361.0798, 596.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'termine commitment using log entries from older terms. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56287637270083,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 585.9601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(a) S1 is leader and partially replicates the log entry at index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56305209801806,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 574.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2. In (b) S1 crashes; S5 is elected leader for term 3 with votes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.527945857841,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 564 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from S3, S4, and itself, and accepts a different entry at log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5633646100244,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 553.0801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'index 2. In (c) S5 crashes; S1 restarts, is elected leader, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56318999999993,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 542.0403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'continues replication. At this point, the log entry from term 2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5632268540601,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 531.12 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'has been replicated on a majority of the servers, but it is not',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.49282955958728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 520.2001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committed. If S1 crashes as in (d), S5 could be elected leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5058973769922,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 509.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(with votes from S2, S3, and S4) and overwrite the entry with',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.68333873756438,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 498.2404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its own entry from term 3. However, if S1 replicates an en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5059054646669,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 487.32050000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try from its current term on a majority of the servers before',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54099684535066,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 476.2807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'crashing, as in (e), then this entry is committed (S5 cannot',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.37281513713555,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 465.36080000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'win an election). At this point all preceding entries in the log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56416706957273,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 454.44090000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'are committed as well.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 81.20172572229949,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 443.40070000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 426.72060000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'terms are present on each new leader from the moment of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67738537947756,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 426.72060000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its election, without the need to transfer those entries to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54114378681763,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 414.72060000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the leader. This means that log entries only flow in one di-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6783553719957,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 402.72060000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rection, from leaders to followers, and leaders never over-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7975277145154,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 390.8405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'write existing entries in their logs.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 136.0504438698815,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 378.8405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft uses the voting process to prevent a candidate from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83112980670734,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 363.9608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'winning an election unless its log contains all committed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78101523647373,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 351.9608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries. A candidate must contact a majority of the cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67743888881702,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 340.0807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in order to be elected, which means that every committed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78120490521425,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 328.0807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry must be present in at least one of those servers. If the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70320254484847,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 316.0807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'candidate’s log is at least as up-to-date as any other log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66202163367873,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 304.20059999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in that majority (where “up-to-date” is defined precisely',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66147237341013,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 292.20059999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'below), then it will hold all the committed entries. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70394360586218,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 280.3204999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RequestVote RPC implements this restriction: the RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.52488196879844,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 268.3204999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'includes information about the candidate’s log, and the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7042094190601,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 256.3204999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'voter denies its vote if its own log is more up-to-date than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66131335971295,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 244.4407999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that of the candidate.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.73053431587029,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 232.4407999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft determines which of two logs is more up-to-date',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.9835633693173,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 217.5606999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'by comparing the index and term of the last entries in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7031987092321,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 205.5606999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'logs. If the logs have last entries with different terms, then',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000056,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 193.6805999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the log with the later term is more up-to-date. If the logs',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75506190173945,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 181.6805999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'end with the same term, then whichever log is longer is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63609267752435,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 169.6805999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'more up-to-date.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.69060842898438,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 157.80049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 139.4406999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.4.2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.10132981144001,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 139.4406999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.77875955351999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.70148981143996, 139.4406999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Committing entries from previous terms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 171.63551735711914,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 348.48024936495995, 139.4406999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56032, 124.56059999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'As described in Section 5.3, a leader knows that an en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71813595478602,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56032, 124.56059999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try from its current term is committed once that entry is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63582465262036,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 112.68049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'stored on a majority of the servers. If a leader crashes be-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67817927237144,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 100.68049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'fore committing an entry, future leaders will attempt to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5413990495795,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 88.68049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'finish replicating the entry. However, a leader cannot im-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774338576839,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 76.80039999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mediately conclude that an entry from a previous term is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63564564390484,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 64.80039999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committed once it is stored on a majority of servers. Fig-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67835984522137,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60016, 52.80039999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '8',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08026, 22.920299999999912 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 9
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 8,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 12, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 11,
      streamId: 9,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Figure 9:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.146135676306,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 615.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.654264323694008,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 112.185935676306, 615.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If S1 (leader for term T) commits a new log entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 180.76347878311398,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 114.84020000000001, 615.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from its term, and S5 is elected leader for a later term U, then',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5631239882508,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 605.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'there must be at least one server (S3) that accepted the log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56367343008446,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 594.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry and also voted for S5.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.84155224062506,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 583.08 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 566.2800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ure 8 illustrates a situation where an old log entry is stored',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66196028374168,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 566.2800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on a majority of servers, yet can still be overwritten by a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58315838166533,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 554.3999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'future leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.65081389939471,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 542.3999000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To eliminate problems like the one in Figure 8, Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.6496759704148,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 530.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'never commits log entries from previous terms by count-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7973539959617,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 518.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing replicas. Only log entries from the leader’s current',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84963697426812,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 506.51980000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term are committed by counting replicas; once an entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66100011438627,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 494.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from the current term has been committed in this way,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69149611408145,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 482.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'then all prior entries are committed indirectly because',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7036855635237,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 470.64010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the Log Matching Property. There are some situations',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75570034756146,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 458.7600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'where a leader could safely conclude that an older log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6768474865817,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 446.7600000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try is committed (for example, if that entry is stored on ev-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67634803951313,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 434.8799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ery server), but Raft takes a more conservative approach',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90115694386517,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 422.8799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for simplicity.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 56.01096028671481,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 410.8799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft incurs this extra complexity in the commitment',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.88909817474547,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 398.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rules because log entries retain their original term num-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79722230978626,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 386.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'bers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.71546454019281,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.084542903040003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 88.71542454019281, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'when',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.661310946525116,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.79996744323282, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.178530448800004,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 116.46127838975792, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.42341216,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 122.63980883855793, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.136747136640011,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 127.06322099855792, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.437545548899756,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 133.19996813519793, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.162450747840012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 157.6375136840977, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'replicates',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.31545971149047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 163.79996443193772, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.08453294040001,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 202.11542414342824, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.675486139222745,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 208.19995708382825, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.084692342640011,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 234.87544322305104, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.5109513366464,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 240.96013556569105, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.049075904640006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 260.47108690233745, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'previous',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.35547272244781,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 266.52016280697745, 374.99980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'terms. In other consensus algorithms, if a new leader re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67726000961588,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 363.1197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'replicates entries from prior “terms,” it must do so with',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54084727872603,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 351.1197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its new “term number.” Raft’s approach makes it easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5575264416975,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 339.1197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to reason about log entries, since they maintain the same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5835208025834,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 327.2396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term number over time and across logs. In addition, new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7129736829825,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 315.2396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leaders in Raft send fewer log entries from previous terms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7558249403372,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 303.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'than in other algorithms (other algorithms must send re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67780752642247,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 291.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dundant log entries to renumber them before they can be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70325972043946,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 279.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committed).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.69066135120047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 267.47979999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 252.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.4.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.10132373422961,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 252.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.778759553520004,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 92.10128373422963, 252.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Safety argument',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 70.51753453766399,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 101.88004328774963, 252.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 240.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Given the complete Raft algorithm, we can now ar-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71799724494946,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 240.11959999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'gue more precisely that the Leader Completeness Prop-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79746350530058,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 228.23989999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'erty holds (this argument is based on the safety proof; see',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58430603794284,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 216.23989999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Section 9.2). We assume that the Leader Completeness',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7551313014898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 204.35979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Property does not hold, then we prove a contradiction.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.93016416648928,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 192.35979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Suppose the leader for term T (leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.27806274602383,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 180.35979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.50449974,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 229.19996, 178.91956999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') commits a log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.5415223931153,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 234.11988, 180.35979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry from its term, but that log entry is not stored by the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70390346638575,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99987999999999, 168.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader of some future term. Consider the smallest term U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.59271354968934,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99987999999999, 156.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99987999999999, 144.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f10',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '>',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.74097128,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99987999999999, 144.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f10',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4590287200000063,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 79.74085127999999, 144.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f10',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T whose leader (leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 91.1577082391078,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 82.19988, 144.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 173.27998, 143.03985999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') does not store the entry.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 100.89068737963602,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 179.03975, 144.47969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1. The committed entry must have been absent from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 221.350787933441,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 79.43975, 125.75979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.43754554889974,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91985, 113.75979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 116.28004999999999, 112.31956999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s log at the time of its election (leaders never',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.75755816261125,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 122.03981999999999, 113.75979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'delete or overwrite entries).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 109.89065642537732,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91991999999999, 101.75979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2. leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.91762054240534,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 79.43982, 88.67969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.50449974,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 116.28002000000001, 87.23985999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.695500260000003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 120.78451974000001, 87.23985999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'replicated the entry on a majority of the clus-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 177.19758806613126,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 123.48002000000001, 88.67969999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ter, and leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 59.357856322984304,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91982000000002, 76.79959999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 151.08002000000002, 75.35975999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.517010520000014,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 156.40284948000001, 75.35975999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'received votes from a majority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.75759657004534,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 160.91986000000003, 76.79959999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the cluster. Thus, at least one server (“the voter”)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.87707247162774,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91986000000003, 64.79959999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'both accepted the entry from leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 145.75786484379114,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.91986000000003, 52.799599999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.50449974,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 237.59986000000004, 51.35975999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.8955002600000057,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 242.10435974000004, 51.35975999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'and voted for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 54.677325171782215,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 245.99986000000004, 52.799599999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.43755760369411,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51976, 698.0396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 362.87996000000004, 696.59976 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', as shown in Figure 9. The voter is key to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.50128922370436,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 368.63973000000004, 698.0396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'reaching a contradiction.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.09033657323118,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51983000000007, 686.1599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '3. The voter must have accepted the committed entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 221.22148932452222,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.0397300000001, 672.2396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.757495213620516,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51983000000007, 660.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.50449974,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 385.19993000000005, 658.91967 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.415420260000019,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 389.70442974, 658.91967 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'before',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.183573436831765,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 393.11985000000004, 660.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.8965265631683224,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 418.30342343683174, 660.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'voting for leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 67.27753115287844,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 421.19995000000006, 660.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 488.39995000000005, 658.91967 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '; otherwise it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 53.0497821643962,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 494.16011000000003, 660.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'would have rejected the AppendEntries request from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.8709224841424,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000005, 648.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.43755760369411,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000005, 636.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.50449974,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 362.88031000000007, 634.91967 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4552702600000202,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 367.38480974000004, 634.91967 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(its current term would have been higher than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 177.4216698970159,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 369.84008000000006, 636.3599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'T).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.970660702211177,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52018000000004, 624.4798000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '4. The voter still stored the entry when it voted for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 221.23775740904205,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.04008000000005, 610.5599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.43755760369411,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52018000000004, 598.6798000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 362.88038000000006, 597.2395700000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', since every intervening leader contained the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.66355985720003,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 368.64015000000006, 598.6798000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry (by assumption), leaders never remove entries,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.77027969560953,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52025000000003, 586.6798000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and followers only remove entries if they conflict',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.80904690817326,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52025000000003, 574.7997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with the leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 61.29109445060087,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52025000000003, 562.7997000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5. The voter granted its vote to leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 159.67750438579026,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.04015000000004, 548.9997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 485.52015000000006, 547.5598600000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', so leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 43.397793329409154,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 491.4002300000001, 548.9997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 534.72013, 547.5598600000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.635604416831956,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 540.6002100000001, 548.9997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log must have been as up-to-date as the voter’s. This',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71475142717378,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52021, 536.9997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leads to one of two contradictions.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.49064081687442,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52021, 524.9997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '6. First, if the voter and leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 128.59794585225228,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.04011, 511.1997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 454.56011, 509.7598600000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.03694052000003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 459.88293948, 509.7598600000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'shared the same last',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.28940407868757,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 463.91988000000003, 511.1997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log term, then leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.8372736423246,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51988000000006, 499.1997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 422.28008000000005, 497.7598600000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s log must have been at least',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 119.0495184907002,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 428.1601600000001, 499.1997000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'as long as the voter’s, so its log contained every entry',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.74122270959901,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5199600000001, 487.31960000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in the voter’s log. This is a contradiction, since the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7842354713109,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5199600000001, 475.31960000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'voter contained the committed entry and leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.47768662342986,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5199600000001, 463.31960000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 523.9199600000001, 461.87976000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.5970905200000516,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 529.24278948, 461.87976000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'was',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.395567268211135,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 531.8398800000001, 463.31960000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'assumed not to.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.37036280344456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5198800000001, 451.43990000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '7. Otherwise, leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 84.19777319538201,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.0397800000001, 437.51960000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 410.1600800000001, 436.07976000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s last log term must have been',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 131.34168453465267,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 415.9198500000001, 437.51960000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'larger than the voter’s. Moreover, it was larger than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7405798602904,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51985000000013, 425.6399000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'T, since the voter’s last log term was at least T (it con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75753696099255,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51985000000013, 413.6399000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tains the committed entry from term T). The earlier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.757462221267,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51985000000013, 401.7598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader that created leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.55800374663656,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.51985000000013, 389.7598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 437.9999500000001, 388.3195700000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s last log entry must have',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 103.42306304547041,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 443.88003000000015, 389.7598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'contained the committed entry in its log (by assump-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75745185015884,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52003000000013, 377.7598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion). Then, by the Log Matching Property, leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.27771402227876,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52003000000013, 365.87970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'U',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.32282948,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 534.7200300000002, 364.4394700000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.635604416831956,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 540.6001100000002, 365.87970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log must also contain the committed entry, which is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71573059528356,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 353.87970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a contradiction.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.37083858924306,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 341.87970000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '8. This completes the contradiction. Thus, the leaders',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 221.3158740209633,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.04001000000017, 328.07970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of all terms greater than T must contain all entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.83622674351818,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 316.07970000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from term T that are committed in term T.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 167.2505556674694,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 304.19960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9. The Log Matching Property guarantees that future',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 221.3835961323656,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 326.04001000000017, 290.27970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leaders will also contain entries that are committed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86161581424795,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 278.3996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'indirectly, such as index 2 in Figure 8(d).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 164.01074737110042,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52011000000016, 266.3996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Given the Leader Completeness Property, we can prove',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.86390384373942,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56034000000017, 244.19960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the State Machine Safety Property from Figure 3, which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66077970093875,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 232.19960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'states that if a server has applied a log entry at a given',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78141002600913,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 220.31950000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'index to its state machine, no other server will ever apply a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58380193832153,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 208.31950000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'different log entry for the same index. At the time a server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67812855257094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 196.43980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'applies a log entry to its state machine, its log must be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.702924099023,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 184.43980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'identical to the leader’s log up through that entry and the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70416686862436,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 172.43980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry must be committed. Now consider the lowest term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67134071702253,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 160.55970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in which any server applies a given log index; the Log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66231465484626,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 148.55970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Completeness Property guarantees that the leaders for all',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.61003688700026,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 136.55970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'higher terms will store that same log entry, so servers that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60976789572038,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 124.67960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'apply the index in later terms will apply the same value.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69086165331547,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 112.67960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Thus, the State Machine Safety Property holds.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.25072522085523,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 100.67960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Finally, Raft requires servers to apply entries in log in-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71767759364496,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56034000000017, 88.67960000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dex order. Combined with the State Machine Safety Prop-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7981295277097,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 76.79950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'erty, this means that all servers will apply exactly the same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5837103716973,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 64.79950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'set of log entries to their state machines, in the same order.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81114249893713,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6001800000002, 52.79950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 307.08, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 10
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 9,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 13, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 12,
      streamId: 10,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: '5.5',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541318828509604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898530411600007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.5413188285096, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Follower and candidate crashes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 133.95556779618528,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.43984924010961, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 684.9603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Until this point we have focused on leader failures. Fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71757316525273,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 684.9603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lower and candidate crashes are much simpler to han-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67740664971413,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 673.0802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dle than leader crashes, and they are both handled in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70347090848225,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 661.0802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'same way. If a follower or candidate crashes, then fu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67772792492894,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 649.2001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ture RequestVote and AppendEntries RPCs sent to it will',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60916161926346,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 637.2001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'fail. Raft handles these failures by retrying indefinitely;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84969293441733,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 625.2001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'if the crashed server restarts, then the RPC will complete',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82378123355542,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 613.32 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'successfully. If a server crashes after completing an RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.52488467863648,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 601.32 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'but before responding, then it will receive the same RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.52521992147257,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 589.32 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'again after it restarts. Raft RPCs are idempotent, so this',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63570102622103,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 577.4399000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'causes no harm. For example, if a follower receives an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66155653779285,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 565.4399000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'AppendEntries request that includes log entries already',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78165688030302,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 553.4399000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'present in its log, it ignores those entries in the new re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6781117754855,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 541.5598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quest.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.610660376595767,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 529.5598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 514.3196000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.6',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541318828509604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 514.3196000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898530411600007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.5413188285096, 514.3196000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Timing and availability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.3014257367491,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.43984924010961, 514.3196000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 501.23990000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'One of our requirements for Raft is that safety must',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.76959121703638,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 501.23990000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'not depend on timing: the system must not produce incor-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67734151397386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 489.23990000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rect results just because some event happens more quickly',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78125439960976,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 477.23990000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'or slowly than expected. However, availability (the ability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000013,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 465.3598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the system to respond to clients in a timely manner)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79737912173977,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 453.3598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'must inevitably depend on timing. For example, if mes-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67802033837543,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 441.3598000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sage exchanges take longer than the typical time between',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6619085676774,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 429.4797000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server crashes, candidates will not stay up long enough to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5417112687549,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 417.4797000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'win an election; without a steady leader, Raft cannot make',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70385793712086,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 405.59960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'progress.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.4506702207984,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 393.59960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leader election is the aspect of Raft where timing is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.67576605234578,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 381.59960000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'most critical. Raft will be able to elect and maintain a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5835887776761,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 369.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'steady leader as long as the system satisfies the follow-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7973007356883,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 357.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.781320111290166,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 345.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.458479888709846,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.78132011129016, 345.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'timing requirement',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 76.08998231257462,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 87.2398, 345.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ':',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.76961392,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 163.4402, 345.71950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 97.4402, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'broadcastTime',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 58.90330633998313,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 97.4402, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.056493660016855,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 156.34350633998315, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '≪',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.96264,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 158.4, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.277160000000009,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 168.36264, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'electionTimeout',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.8496184100717,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 170.6398, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.1503815899282017,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 234.4894184100718, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '≪',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.96264,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 236.6398, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.157260000000008,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 246.60244, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'MTBF',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.007155206927198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 248.7597, 330.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In this inequality',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 71.34121955059777,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.138880449402194,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 143.34191955059782, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'broadcastTime',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 58.90330633998313,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 147.48080000000002, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.21659366001677,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 206.38410633998325, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is the average time it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 90.00935207624521,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 210.60070000000002, 315.83940000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'takes a server to send RPCs in parallel to every server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67748746664972,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 303.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in the cluster and receive their responses;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 170.88907534216779,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 291.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.469924657832138,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 242.8897753421679, 291.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'electionTime-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 54.31758996242808,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 246.35970000000003, 291.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.8496185016408,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 279.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.350381498359212,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.85031850164081, 279.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is the election timeout described in Section 5.2; and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 212.4613138803683,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 88.20070000000003, 279.95970000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 268.0796 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'MTBF',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.0071734385584,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 268.0796 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.8729265614416164,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 98.0078734385584, 268.0796 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is the average time between failures for a single',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 198.82281919234467,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 101.88080000000002, 268.0796 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server. The broadcast time should be an order of mag-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67723942680178,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 256.0796 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nitude less than the election timeout so that leaders can',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133722023596,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 244.07960000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'reliably send the heartbeat messages required to keep fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67757937200386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 232.19950000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lowers from starting elections; given the randomized ap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67728612169546,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 220.19950000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'proach used for election timeouts, this inequality also',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54090343812788,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 208.31940000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'makes split votes unlikely. The election timeout should be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70244521484366,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 196.31940000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a few orders of magnitude less than MTBF so that the sys-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55708452887495,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 184.31940000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tem makes steady progress. When the leader crashes, the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70352294335083,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 172.43970000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'system will be unavailable for roughly the election time-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67760072194142,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 160.43970000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out; we would like this to represent only a small fraction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78158961255778,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 148.43970000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of overall time.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.93034735582728,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 136.55960000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The broadcast time and MTBF are properties of the un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71750431344776,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96086000000003, 124.55960000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'derlying system, while the election timeout is something',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7815816723338,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 112.67950000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'we must choose. Raft’s RPCs typically require the recip-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67775223377046,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 100.67950000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ient to persist information to stable storage, so the broad-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7973251740443,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 88.67950000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cast time may range from 0.5ms to 20ms, depending on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66138857764528,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 76.79940000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'storage technology. As a result, the election timeout is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63512835374854,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 64.79940000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'likely to be somewhere between 10ms and 500ms. Typical',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72980519464474,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00070000000002, 52.79940000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 579.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 10:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.70606560516537,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 579.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.6541343948347276,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 363.3460656051653, 579.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Switching directly from one configuration to an-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.1455135293182,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 366.0002, 579.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'other is unsafe because different servers will switch at dif-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.62580454000002,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 568.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ferent times. In this example, the cluster grows from three',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54138075884327,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 557.2803 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers to five. Unfortunately, there is a point in time where',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5411214511336,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 546.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two different leaders can be elected for the same term, one',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54165354302194,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 535.3202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with a majority of the old configuration (',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 154.30571692628862,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 524.4003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 477.48, 524.4003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.886945557163699,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 483.24016, 522.72022 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') and another',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.30594931357269,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 492.72024, 524.4003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with a majority of the new configuration (',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 149.86553712686413,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64023999999995, 513.4804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 473.0402399999999, 513.4804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.515211161342165,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 478.80078999999995, 512.16048 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ').',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.241608562386012,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 490.80078999999995, 513.4804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60078999999996, 496.6804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server MTBFs are several months or more, which easily',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54134711433724,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60078999999996, 496.6804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'satisfies the timing requirement.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 128.13049905244353,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60078999999996, 484.6804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.60078999999996, 464.8804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '6',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.60078999999996, 464.8804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.57838999999996, 464.8804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Cluster membership changes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 148.05077455692802,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.48091538879993, 464.8804 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56094999999993, 451.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Up until now we have assumed that the cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.11765147872393,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56094999999993, 451.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.8023485212764854,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 516.6786014787234, 451.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'config-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.917667267523047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 519.4809499999999, 451.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'uration',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.341488702849187,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 439.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0585112971509147,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 347.94243870284896, 439.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(the set of servers participating in the consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.35601001153333,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 351.0009499999999, 439.5605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'algorithm) is fixed. In practice, it will occasionally be nec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6765591200007,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 427.68039999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'essary to change the configuration, for example to replace',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70365759839285,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 415.68039999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers when they fail or to change the degree of replica-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67780179790424,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 403.68039999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion. Although this can be done by taking the entire cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67795863974587,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 391.80029999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'off-line, updating configuration files, and then restarting',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66167798237444,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 379.80029999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the cluster, this would leave the cluster unavailable dur-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6784294641496,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 367.80029999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing the changeover. In addition, if there are any manual',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8502830614348,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 355.9201999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'steps, they risk operator error. In order to avoid these is-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55750398590683,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 343.9201999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sues, we decided to automate configuration changes and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66168800479034,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 332.0400999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'incorporate them into the Raft consensus algorithm.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 206.9709109165923,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 320.0400999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'For the configuration change mechanism to be safe,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.73112732701003,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56110999999987, 306.72019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'there must be no point during the transition where it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60945447106602,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 294.72019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'is possible for two leaders to be elected for the same',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58370930569467,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 282.72019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term. Unfortunately, any approach where servers switch',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5418289175706,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 270.84049999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'directly from the old configuration to the new configura-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9176618702256,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 258.84049999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion is unsafe. It isn’t possible to atomically switch all of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6780389286613,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 246.96039999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the servers at once, so the cluster can potentially split into',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6613200000007,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 234.96039999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two independent majorities during the transition (see Fig-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6770836908134,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 222.96039999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ure 10).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.170491942342387,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 211.08029999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In order to ensure safety, configuration changes must',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.77020010370524,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5611099999998, 197.64049999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'use a two-phase approach. There are a variety of ways',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6354062018151,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 185.76039999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to implement the two phases. For example, some systems',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6351639502613,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 173.76039999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(e.g., [22]) use the first phase to disable the old configura-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9180070059631,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 161.88029999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion so it cannot process client requests; then the second',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.661316487982,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 149.88029999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'phase enables the new configuration. In Raft the cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67820824372825,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 137.88029999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'first switches to a transitional configuration we call',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 207.25005412675225,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60094999999984, 126.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.109945873248307,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 525.8510041267516, 126.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'joint',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.369626297000963,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 528.9609499999999, 126.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.59545334248874,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 114.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '; once the joint consensus has been committed,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.25160144500572,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 359.1611499999999, 114.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the system then transitions to the new configuration. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70369364322448,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 102.00019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'joint consensus combines both the old and new configu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79793498723865,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 90.12009999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rations:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.009624088446678,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6009499999999, 78.12009999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56110999999987, 64.80019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56110999999987, 64.80019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54242999999985, 64.80019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Log entries are replicated to all servers in both con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75810013906874,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52126999999984, 64.80019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'figurations.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 45.33065815690508,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52126999999984, 52.80019999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5614699999999, 22.920099999999863 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 11
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 10,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 14, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 13,
      streamId: 11,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Figure 11:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.98613388397239,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 600.84 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.054066116027613,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.02593388397239, 600.84 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Timeline for a configuration change. Dashed lines',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 177.48818040826967,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 118.08, 600.84 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'show configuration entries that have been created but not',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.49272323625317,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 589.8002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'committed, and solid lines show the latest committed configu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.38580454000018,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 578.8803 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ration entry. The leader first creates the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.74159713835706,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03979999999999, 567.9604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.6584028616430828,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 215.7813971383569, 567.9604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 217.4398, 567.9604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.19532620611219,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 223.19957, 566.2803200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.404673793887781,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 245.3948962061122, 566.2803200000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'configuration',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.68325609282275,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 247.79957, 567.9604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry in its log and commits it to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 118.60325277025093,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03957, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9967472297491327,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 195.64282277025086, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 197.63957, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.19532620611219,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 203.39973, 555.24051 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0046737938877754,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 225.59505620611222, 555.24051 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(a majority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.78602687287763,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 228.59973, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.0541731271224535,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 278.38575687287755, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 280.43993, 556.9202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.886945494399072,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 286.1997, 555.24051 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03970000000001, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and a majority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.82606913038901,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03970000000001, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.654430869610991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 140.86576913038903, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 143.52020000000002, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.515198957104701,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 149.27997000000002, 544.68036 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '). Then it creates the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 76.70135979650233,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 161.16007000000002, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.6189402034978,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 237.86142979650222, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 240.48037000000002, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.515211168316057,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 246.23975000000002, 544.68036 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.484788831683943,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 257.7549611683161, 544.68036 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'entry and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.36330354411988,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 261.23975, 546.00028 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'commits it to a majority of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 96.22584816190536,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03975000000003, 535.08038 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.934351838094699,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 173.26559816190533, 535.08038 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 175.19995000000003, 535.08038 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.515198957104701,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 180.96011000000004, 533.76046 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. There is no point in time in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 102.76345773781043,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 192.83981000000006, 535.08038 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.883199190326575,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03981000000006, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.7566008096734294,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 98.92300919032662, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 100.67961000000005, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.886921078950195,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 106.43977000000005, 522.3605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.7532789210498123,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 115.32669107895025, 522.3605 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.883194799074797,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 118.07997000000006, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.877005200925197,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 130.96316479907486, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 132.84017000000006, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.515198957104701,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 138.59994000000006, 522.72027 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.645001042895302,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 150.11513895710476, 522.72027 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'can both make decisions independently.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 142.2815609217754,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 152.76014000000006, 524.04058 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96014000000007, 507.24057999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96014000000007, 507.24057999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94146000000006, 507.24057999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Any server from either configuration may serve as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71547850064084,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92030000000007, 507.24057999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.37073506879574,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92030000000007, 495.36047999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96053000000006, 483.36047999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96053000000006, 483.36047999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978840000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 86.94185000000006, 483.36047999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Agreement (for elections and entry commitment) re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.757845344551,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92069000000006, 483.36047999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quires separate majorities from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 123.55081320035727,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.92069000000006, 471.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2091867996426515,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 215.47150320035743, 471.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'both',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.821313186668576,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 217.68069000000008, 471.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.338886813331385,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 235.5020031866687, 471.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'the old and new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.87270908982833,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 237.8408900000001, 471.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'configurations.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 59.85064615616351,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 91.9208900000001, 459.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The joint consensus allows individual servers to transition',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000005,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.0009900000001, 447.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'between configurations at different times without com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67769077424427,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 435.4803799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'promising safety. Furthermore, joint consensus allows the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70354206165717,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 423.6002799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cluster to continue servicing client requests throughout',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.0895176493292,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 411.6002799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the configuration change.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 101.25055786171606,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 399.6002799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Cluster configurations are stored and communicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.94148053038603,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96115000000012, 387.6002799999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'using special entries in the replicated log; Figure 11 illus-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5575591200001,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 375.72017999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'trates the configuration change process. When the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67734780039964,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 363.72017999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'receives a request to change the configuration from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 209.59108040471187,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00099000000012, 351.72017999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.6889195952879845,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 281.5920704047121, 351.72017999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 284.2809900000001, 351.72017999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.446166930192172,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 290.6407600000001, 350.16040999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00076000000013, 339.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.741314781864565,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00076000000013, 339.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.018885218135438,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 79.74207478186469, 339.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 83.76096000000013, 339.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042749164785409,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 90.12073000000012, 338.40026999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', it stores the configuration for joint consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 198.03568063981757,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 102.72073000000012, 339.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.31755912,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00083000000012, 327.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 74.88091000000013, 327.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.32282769231561,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 81.24068000000013, 326.28033999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.037372307684393,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 104.56350769231574, 326.28033999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'in the figure) as a log entry and replicates that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 192.0092354597334,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 108.60088000000013, 327.84010999999987 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry using the mechanisms described previously. Once a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5832036319763,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 315.96040999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'given server adds the new configuration entry to its log,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69046219130234,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 303.96040999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it uses that configuration for all future decisions (a server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6778787792237,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 291.96040999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'always uses the latest configuration in its log, regardless',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87582316578738,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 280.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of whether the entry is committed). This means that the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70362509029894,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 268.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader will use the rules of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 105.31730455081198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00088000000014, 256.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.8426954491879428,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 177.3181845508122, 256.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 179.16088000000013, 256.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.32282761859221,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 185.52104000000014, 254.52014999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.077172381407763,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 208.84386761859238, 254.52014999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'to determine when the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 88.78320984193135,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 211.92104000000015, 256.0803099999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entry for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.95740041695153,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00104000000016, 244.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.442599583048505,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 122.95844041695166, 244.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 125.40104000000017, 244.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.32282761859221,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 131.76120000000017, 242.64043999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.6771723814077575,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 155.08402761859242, 242.64043999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is committed. If the leader crashes,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 141.9307776491853,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 158.76120000000017, 244.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a new leader may be chosen under either',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 163.99700744595768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00100000000018, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.202992554042197,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 235.99800744595797, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 238.20100000000016, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.4461669301922,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 244.56155000000015, 230.64043999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.273733069807804,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 254.00771693019237, 230.64043999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.357546118168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 257.2814500000002, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2026538818320205,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 265.63899611816817, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 267.8416500000002, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.322790978062383,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 274.2014200000002, 230.64043999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.49066,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 298.0815200000002, 232.20020999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'depending on whether the winning candidate has received',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78107998367125,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00152000000017, 220.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.52144200000016, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.52144200000016, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.32282769231561,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 77.88160200000016, 206.76033999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. In any case,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 56.010414284229554,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 101.76170200000016, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2692857157704225,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 157.77211628422972, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 161.04140200000015, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042755652444601,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 167.40156200000015, 206.88026999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.277144347555378,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 179.44431765244477, 206.88026999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'cannot make unilateral deci-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.95778160501739,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 183.72146200000014, 208.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sions during this period.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 96.570649843758,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00146200000015, 196.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Once',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.103415360572306,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96162200000015, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.3363846394277061,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 103.06503736057245, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 104.40142200000015, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.322827618592225,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 110.76158200000015, 182.76033999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.477172381407769,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 134.0844096185924, 182.76033999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'has been committed, neither',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 110.8374239476656,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 136.56158200000016, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.2425760523342433,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 247.3990059476659, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 248.64158200000014, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.446166930192172,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 255.00174200000015, 182.76033999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4339330698078356,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 264.44790893019234, 182.76033999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'nor',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.397557524804009,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 266.8818420000002, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.3626424751960258,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 280.27939952480415, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 281.6420420000002, 184.32010999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042743414360206,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 288.0018120000002, 182.88026999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.0018120000002, 172.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can make decisions without approval of the other, and the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70388202678444,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.0018120000002, 172.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leader Completeness Property ensures that only servers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75597021555362,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.0018120000002, 160.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.34333054576968,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.0018120000002, 148.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.7765694542303407,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 105.34514254576986, 148.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 108.1217120000002, 148.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old,new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.322827618592225,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 114.4818720000002, 146.88030999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.91697238140776,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 137.80469961859242, 146.88030999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'log entry can be elected as leader. It is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 158.91601050548493,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 141.72167200000018, 148.44046999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'now safe for the leader to create a log entry describing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78144943821312,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00177200000019, 136.56036999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.52169400000018, 124.56036999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.52169400000018, 124.56036999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042749164785409,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 77.88185400000017, 123.12013999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.4373508352145876,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 89.92460316478558, 123.12013999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'and replicate it to the cluster. Again, this configura-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 207.55788748855562,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 93.36195400000017, 124.56036999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion will take effect on each server as soon as it is seen.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6908681788449,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00175400000018, 112.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'When the new configuration has been committed under',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79709822510515,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00175400000018, 100.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the rules of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.75755687239952,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00175400000018, 88.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9225431276005054,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 118.75931087239968, 88.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 121.68185400000019, 88.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042755652444601,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 128.04162400000018, 87.24042999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', the old configuration is irrelevant and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 160.02158886553758,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 140.64162400000018, 88.68026999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servers not in the new configuration can be shut down. As',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63519709596443,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00182400000018, 76.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shown in Figure 11, there is no time when',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 171.18124638781393,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00182400000018, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4587536121859728,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 243.18307038781418, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 245.64182400000016, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.446166930192172,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 252.00198400000016, 63.24039999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.3936330698078336,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 261.44815093019236, 63.24039999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.461320702211177,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 264.8417840000002, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3386792977888717,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 279.30310470221133, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 281.6417840000002, 64.80016999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042743414360206,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 288.0019440000002, 63.36032999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00194400000021, 52.80012999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can both make unilateral decisions; this guarantees safety.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69066,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72.00194400000021, 52.80012999999984 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There are three more issues to address for reconfigura-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.95805018401833,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5617440000002, 698.0401299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion. The first issue is that new servers may not initially',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66089641326658,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 686.1604299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'store any log entries. If they are added to the cluster in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54115467598314,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 674.1604299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'this state, it could take quite a while for them to catch',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66155195497834,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 662.1604299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'up, during which time it might not be possible to com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67817367336778,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 650.2803299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mit new log entries. In order to avoid availability gaps,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69000126976263,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 638.2803299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft introduces an additional phase before the configu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79803221264234,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 626.40023 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ration change, in which the new servers join the cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67822596726492,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 614.40023 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'as non-voting members (the leader replicates log entries',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75554202128617,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 602.40023 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to them, but they are not considered for majorities). Once',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70272849254923,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 590.52013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the new servers have caught up with the rest of the cluster,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6907960592936,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 578.52013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the reconfiguration can proceed as described above.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 206.13095559747018,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 566.52013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The second issue is that the cluster leader may not be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74403141654454,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5617440000002, 553.8002299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'part of the new configuration. In this case, the leader steps',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6352408618417,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 541.8002299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'down (returns to follower state) once it has committed the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70367383749618,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60158400000023, 529.8002299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.12150600000024, 517.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.12150600000024, 517.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042743414360206,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 324.48166600000025, 516.48029 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.677156585639807,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 336.52440941436043, 516.48029 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'log entry. This means that there will be a period of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 207.0780033389332,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 340.20156600000024, 517.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'time (while it is committing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 109.62148633591455,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6015660000002, 505.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.3785136640856308,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 428.2230523359146, 505.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 429.6015660000002, 505.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.0427191593616,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 435.9617260000002, 504.48028999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') when the leader is man-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.71761124694572,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 448.56172600000025, 505.92013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'aging a cluster that does not include itself; it replicates log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133140663655,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017260000002, 494.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries but does not count itself in majorities. The leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6780064604175,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017260000002, 482.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'transition occurs when',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 91.02152473860173,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017260000002, 470.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.338675261398521,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 409.6232507386017, 470.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 411.96192600000023, 470.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.0427191593616,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 418.32169600000026, 468.6002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.4373808406384114,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 430.36441515936184, 468.6002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is committed because this is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 113.43557438743741,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 433.80179600000025, 470.04042999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the first point when the new configuration can operate in-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777236609189,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60179600000026, 458.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dependently (it will always be possible to choose a leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67816919017966,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60179600000026, 446.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.51095133664637,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60179600000026, 434.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.7288486633536309,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.11274733664663, 434.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 339.84159600000027, 434.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042743414360206,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 346.2017560000003, 432.72009999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '). Before this point, it may be the case that only',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.46176241924263,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 358.8017560000003, 434.16032999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a server from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 53.11135010400469,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017560000003, 422.2802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.8491498959953674,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 371.71310610400496, 422.2802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 373.56225600000033, 422.2802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'old',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.446166930192172,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 379.9216360000003, 420.7200699999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0339330698078015,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 389.3678029301925, 420.7200699999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'can be elected leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 85.29083458420259,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 392.4017360000003, 422.2802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The third issue is that removed servers (those not in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.58213104456487,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5619360000003, 409.4400299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.1217360000003, 397.4400299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.64508088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.1217360000003, 397.4400299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.042743414360206,
  height: 7.37234,
  transform: [ 7.37234, 0, 0, 7.37234, 324.4818960000003, 396.0001899999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ') can disrupt the cluster. These servers will not re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 210.1969141122274,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 337.0818960000003, 397.4400299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ceive heartbeats, so they will time out and start new elec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67781511795386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 385.5603299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tions. They will then send RequestVote RPCs with new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.71320800427503,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 373.5603299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term numbers, and this will cause the current leader to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54147769465976,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 361.6802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'revert to follower state. A new leader will eventually be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70276493588622,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 349.6802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'elected, but the removed servers will time out again and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66212595248192,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 337.6802299999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the process will repeat, resulting in poor availability.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 209.13065151765986,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 325.80012999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To prevent this problem, servers disregard RequestVote',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7434655485555,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5619560000003, 312.96032999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RPCs when they believe a current leader exists. Specif-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67736771571703,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 300.96032999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ically, if a server receives a RequestVote RPC within',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.661368094457,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 289.0802299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the minimum election timeout of hearing from a cur-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67794930475225,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 277.0802299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rent leader, it does not update its term or grant its vote.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69132394969927,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 265.0802299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This does not affect normal elections, where each server',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67785521757997,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 253.2001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'waits at least a minimum election timeout before starting',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66183848050494,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 241.2001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'an election. However, it helps avoid disruptions from re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67755619890295,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 229.3200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'moved servers: if a leader is able to get heartbeats to its',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6357380872416,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 217.3200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cluster, then it will not be deposed by larger term num-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7974937319504,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 205.3200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'bers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.170669198081605,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 193.4403299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6017960000003, 174.1200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '7',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6017960000003, 174.1200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.5793960000003, 174.1200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Log compaction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 82.00724406423049,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.4819213888003, 174.1200299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5619560000003, 161.2802299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s log grows during normal operation to incorpo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.95775046795663,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5619560000003, 161.2802299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rate more client requests, but in a practical system, it can-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6775620569354,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 149.4001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'not grow without bound. As the log grows longer, it oc-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67830682405108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 137.4001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cupies more space and takes more time to replay. This',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63585607478694,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 125.40012999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'will eventually cause availability problems without some',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7039596257871,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 113.52002999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mechanism to discard obsolete information that has accu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6778165027606,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 101.52002999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mulated in the log.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 74.85059885298853,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 89.52002999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Snapshotting is the simplest approach to compaction.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.97099766085043,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5619560000003, 76.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In snapshotting, the entire current system state is written',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66142930491736,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 64.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.223421307292575,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6017960000003, 52.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.1367786927074803,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.82521730729286, 52.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'snapshot',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.649608709506396,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 336.96199600000034, 52.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9901912904937262,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 372.6116047095066, 52.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'on stable storage, then the entire log up to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 171.54155127088563,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 375.6017960000003, 52.8001299999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.56, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '11',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.56, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 12
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 11,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 15, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 14,
      streamId: 12,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Figure 12:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.465826247592396,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 573.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4142737524076097,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.50562624759239, 573.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A server replaces the committed entries in its log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.68401741945837,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 118.9199, 573.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(indexes 1 through 5) with a new snapshot, which stores just',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.61369860358218,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 563.0401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the current state (variables',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.48783256384182,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.0320674361582576,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 170.52763256384176, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'x',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.98107272,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 172.55970000000002, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.8990072800000064,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 176.54077272, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.883194799074797,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 178.43978, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9969052009251982,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 191.3229747990748, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'y',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.98107272,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 193.31988, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.8990072800000064,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 197.30095272, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'in this example). The snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 96.34573465204726,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 199.19996, 552.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot’s last included index and term serve to position the snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5058059981265,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03996000000001, 541.08 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot in the log preceding entry 6.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 118.16172334631278,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03995999999998, 530.1601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 513.36 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that point is discarded. Snapshotting is used in Chubby',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78113670098085,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 513.36 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and ZooKeeper, and the remainder of this section de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6784421864411,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 501.36 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'scribes snapshotting in Raft.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.89048515752101,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 489.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Incremental approaches to compaction, such as log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70125026628767,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 475.4401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cleaning [36] and log-structured merge trees [30, 5], are',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70328898071293,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 463.4401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'also possible. These operate on a fraction of the data at',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60960102150057,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 451.55999999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'once, so they spread the load of compaction more evenly',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78108876075697,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 439.55999999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'over time. They first select a region of data that has ac-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67766492119353,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 427.55999999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cumulated many deleted and overwritten objects, then',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66158374576284,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 415.6798999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'they rewrite the live objects from that region more com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67771881907586,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 403.6798999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pactly and free the region. This requires significant addi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67766815905154,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 391.7997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tional mechanism and complexity compared to snapshot-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79738534838984,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 379.7997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ting, which simplifies the problem by always operating',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78165743821083,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 367.7997999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on the entire data set. While log cleaning would require',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82341158972358,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 355.91969999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'modifications to Raft, state machines can implement LSM',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.57647636927882,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 343.91969999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'trees using the same interface as snapshotting.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 184.17012017075217,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 331.91969999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 12 shows the basic idea of snapshotting in Raft.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.6108467902303,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 317.87989999999985 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Each server takes snapshots independently, covering just',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60994434403767,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 305.9997999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the committed entries in its log. Most of the work con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6773899324042,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 293.9997999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sists of the state machine writing its current state to the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70315006166106,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 282.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'snapshot. Raft also includes a small amount of metadata',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70337856477195,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 270.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in the snapshot: the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 77.26363983508465,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 258.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.416460164915293,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 149.2636398350847, 258.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'last included index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 75.22299636856708,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 151.68009999999998, 258.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.416503631432761,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 226.90309636856722, 258.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is the index of the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 71.38359894743427,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 229.31959999999998, 258.1196999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'last entry in the log that the snapshot replaces (the last en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67803756378012,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 246.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'try the state machine had applied), and the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 173.62371848294094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 234.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.137281517058966,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 245.62331848294102, 234.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'last included',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.02126201527928,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 248.76059999999998, 234.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.233021874954968,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 222.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.6470781250450415,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 90.23262187495494, 222.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'is the term of this entry. These are preserved to sup-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 207.79734808890078,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 92.87969999999999, 222.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'port the AppendEntries consistency check for the first log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6613909686789,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 210.35989999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entry following the snapshot, since that entry needs a pre-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67745261733518,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 198.35989999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'vious log index and term. To enable cluster membership',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90171628632532,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 186.47979999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'changes (Section 6), the snapshot also includes the latest',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60961197044205,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 174.47979999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'configuration in the log as of last included index. Once a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58396226708703,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 162.47979999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'server completes writing a snapshot, it may delete all log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6614663958264,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 150.59969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'entries up through the last included index, as well as any',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66139598984935,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 138.59969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prior snapshot.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 59.37048277366751,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 126.59969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Although servers normally take snapshots indepen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.95778827617562,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.95975999999999, 112.67979999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dently, the leader must occasionally send snapshots to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54171857136998,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 100.67979999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'followers that lag behind. This happens when the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67768352144248,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 88.67979999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'has already discarded the next log entry that it needs to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54135504459904,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 76.79969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'send to a follower. Fortunately, this situation is unlikely',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78143765241,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 64.79969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in normal operation: a follower that has kept up with the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70325750873346,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99959999999999, 52.79969999999979 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 683.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Invoked by',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.216,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 683.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9984999999999786,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 365.046, 683.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f5',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader to send chunks of a snapshot to a follower.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.75059359999997,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 367.04449999999997, 683.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Leaders always send chunks in order.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 119.5262032,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 674.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 658.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Arguments:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 44.888000000000005,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 658.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 649.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.432000000000002,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 649.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.317999999999984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 345.262, 649.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f7',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'leader’s term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.83907839999998,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 649.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 639.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leaderId',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.887999999999998,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 639.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.861999999999966,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 357.718, 639.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'so follower can redirect clients',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.64000000000004,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 639.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 630.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lastIncludedIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 61.792,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 630.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.958000000000027,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 390.62199999999996, 630.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'the snapshot replaces all entries up through',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.20000000000005,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 630.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and including this index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 77.11200000000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 395.83, 620.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 610.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lastIncludedTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.60162480000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 610.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.148375199999975,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 389.4316248, 610.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'term of lastIncludedIndex',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 82.64917599999998,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 610.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 601.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'offset',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.656,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 601.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.093999999999994,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 347.486, 601.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'byte offset where chunk is positioned in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 139.61507840000002,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 601.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'snapshot file',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.66400000000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 395.83, 591.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 582.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'data[]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.44,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 582.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.31000000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 349.2699999999999, 582.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'raw bytes of the snapshot chunk, starting at',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.648,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 582.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'offset',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.071078400000026,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 395.83, 572.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 562.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'done',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.448,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 562.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.30200000000002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 345.27799999999996, 562.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'true if this is the last chunk',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.66400000000002,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 562.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 547.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Results:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.560000000000006,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 547.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 537.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.432000000000002,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 537.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.317999999999984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 345.262, 537.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f12',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'currentTerm, for leader to update itself',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 123.85135952800007,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 396.58, 537.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 521.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Receiver implementation:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 97.35865600000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 521.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f6',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 512.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 512.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 512.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reply immediately if term < currentTerm',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.60609440000005,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 512.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 502.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 502.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Create new snapshot file if first chunk (offset is 0)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 160.93507839999998,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 502.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '3.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 493.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 493.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Write data into snapshot file at given offset',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.95876560000002,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 493.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '4.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 483.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 483.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reply and wait for more data chunks if done is false',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 167.07999999999996,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 483.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 473.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 473.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Save snapshot file, discard any existing or partial snapshot',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 187.31199999999993,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 473.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with a smaller index',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 65.10400000000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 341.83, 464.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '6.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 454.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 454.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'If existing log entry has same index and term as snapshot’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.42220319999993,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 454.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'last included entry, retain log entries following it and reply',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 187.90485919999998,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 341.83, 445.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '7.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 435.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 435.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Discard the entire log',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 69.096,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 435.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '8.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 328.83, 425.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.375,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 334.83, 425.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Reset state machine using snapshot contents (and load',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 173.53599999999994,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 342.205, 425.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'snapshot’s cluster configuration)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 104.43020320000001,
  height: 8,
  transform: [ 8, 0, 0, 8, 341.83, 416.15 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f11',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 10, 0, 0, 10, 383.658, 696.801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f13',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'InstallSnapshot RPC',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.34832406200003,
  height: 10,
  transform: [ 10, 0, 0, 10, 383.658, 696.801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f13',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 395.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 13:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.545910554245346,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 395.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.4942894457547595,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 364.18591055424525, 395.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A summary of the InstallSnapshot RPC. Snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 174.46569049834793,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 367.6802, 395.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shots are split into chunks for transmission; this gives the fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.62579259474302,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 384.4801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lower a sign of life with each chunk, so it can reset its election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.5631670695728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.63999999999993, 373.43989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'timer.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.72169816273728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 362.52 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 345.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader would already have this entry. However, an excep-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79704046171796,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 345.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tionally slow follower or a new server joining the cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67787624871306,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 333.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(Section 6) would not. The way to bring such a follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79768670828707,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 321.8399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'up-to-date is for the leader to send it a snapshot over the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70348565318938,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 309.8399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'network.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.25058484301096,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 297.9598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The leader uses a new RPC called InstallSnapshot to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.58174349786847,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 282.9598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'send snapshots to followers that are too far behind; see',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58323380881288,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 270.9598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 13. When a follower receives a snapshot with this',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63522565885316,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 259.07969999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RPC, it must decide what to do with its existing log en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67811807187363,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 247.07969999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tries. Usually the snapshot will contain new information',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90102324523613,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 235.19959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'not already in the recipient’s log. In this case, the follower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7975591200006,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 223.19959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'discards its entire log; it is all superseded by the snapshot',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72989878368477,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 211.19959999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and may possibly have uncommitted entries that conflict',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7294294437143,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 199.31949999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with the snapshot. If instead the follower receives a snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6778463109798,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 187.31949999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot that describes a prefix of its log (due to retransmis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67782787013337,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 175.31949999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sion or by mistake), then log entries covered by the snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67831932716447,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 163.43979999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot are deleted but entries following the snapshot are still',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.4896139200007,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 151.43979999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'valid and must be retained.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 107.61098080184784,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 139.55969999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This snapshotting approach departs from Raft’s strong',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7014895390124,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 124.55969999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader principle, since followers can take snapshots with-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777590183282,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 112.67959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out the knowledge of the leader. However, we think this',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63608654053814,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 100.67959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'departure is justified. While having a leader helps avoid',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6613277158775,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 88.67959999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'conflicting decisions in reaching consensus, consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75592151816952,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 76.79949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'has already been reached when snapshotting, so no de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67746836826885,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 64.79949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cisions conflict. Data still only flows from leaders to fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6775436160886,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 52.79949999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.56, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '12',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.56, 22.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 13
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 12,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 16, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 15,
      streamId: 13,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'lowers, just followers can now reorganize their data.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 207.93043792069565,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We considered an alternative leader-based approach in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.580762088165,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 685.4399999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which only the leader would create a snapshot, then it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6085258434291,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 673.4399999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'would send this snapshot to each of its followers. How-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777735040069,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 661.4399999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ever, this has two disadvantages. First, sending the snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67733979043714,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 649.5603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot to each follower would waste network bandwidth and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66093267727624,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 637.5603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'slow the snapshotting process. Each follower already has',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63518733257717,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 625.5603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the information needed to produce its own snapshots, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66131769346157,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 613.6802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'it is typically much cheaper for a server to produce a snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67795669703114,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 601.6802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot from its local state than it is to send and receive one',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70378840785628,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 589.8001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'over the network. Second, the leader’s implementation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90142885419877,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 577.8001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'would be more complex. For example, the leader would',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66159396743137,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 565.8001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'need to send snapshots to followers in parallel with repli-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67763969578908,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 553.9200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cating new log entries to them, so as not to block new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7125294488649,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 541.9200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'client requests.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 59.85064395442006,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 529.9200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There are two more issues that impact snapshotting per-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71759405690887,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 517.32 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'formance. First, servers must decide when to snapshot. If',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67800624123984,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 505.32000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a server snapshots too often, it wastes disk bandwidth and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133770840548,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 493.32000000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'energy; if it snapshots too infrequently, it risks exhaust-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79791412547047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 481.44030000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing its storage capacity, and it increases the time required',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78187407581754,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 469.44030000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to replay the log during restarts. One simple strategy is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63515637865476,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 457.5602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to take a snapshot when the log reaches a fixed size in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5413254256702,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 445.5602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'bytes. If this size is set to be significantly larger than the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7040660267827,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 433.5602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'expected size of a snapshot, then the disk bandwidth over-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79725720891423,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 421.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'head for snapshotting will be small.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 142.29067955343194,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 409.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The second performance issue is that writing a snap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.717498933622,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 396.9602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'shot can take a significant amount of time, and we do',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66155348922513,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 385.08009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'not want this to delay normal operations. The solution is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63548394029536,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 373.08009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to use copy-on-write techniques so that new updates can',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132670965084,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 361.08009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be accepted without impacting the snapshot being writ-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772619822187,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 349.19999999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ten. For example, state machines built with functional data',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7036873667616,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 337.19999999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'structures naturally support this. Alternatively, the operat-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79758281514685,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 325.3198999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing system’s copy-on-write support (e.g., fork on Linux)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79791940566972,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 313.3198999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can be used to create an in-memory snapshot of the entire',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70374863699743,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 301.3198999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine (our implementation uses this approach).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 220.29065271116582,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 289.4401999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 270.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '8',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 270.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.9025253888,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 77.9776, 270.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Client interaction',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 89.92732992163842,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 89.8801253888, 270.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 257.5201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This section describes how clients interact with Raft,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.61087685747782,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 257.5201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'including how clients find the cluster leader and how Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6094116317141,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 245.6404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'supports linearizable semantics [10]. These issues apply',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78087363747153,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 233.6404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to all consensus-based systems, and Raft’s solutions are',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70311814136235,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 221.6404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'similar to other systems.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 97.41040574071538,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 209.7603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Clients of Raft send all of their requests to the leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7309751676094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96016, 197.0404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'When a client first starts up, it connects to a randomly-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91801815415744,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 185.0404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'chosen server. If the client’s first choice is not the leader,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81179220254216,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 173.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that server will reject the client’s request and supply in-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67731860986456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 161.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'formation about the most recent leader it has heard from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79076896987564,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 149.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(AppendEntries requests include the network address of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67778810923716,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 137.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the leader). If the leader crashes, client requests will time',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58341216000005,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 125.28020000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out; clients then try again with randomly-chosen servers.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 226.29078015303247,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 113.40010000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Our goal for Raft is to implement linearizable seman-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71758067708322,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96015999999997, 100.68020000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tics (each operation appears to execute instantaneously,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.93011603697533,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 88.68020000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'exactly once, at some point between its invocation and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6609223559812,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 76.80010000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its response). However, as described so far Raft can exe-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7973419610924,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 64.80010000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cute a command multiple times: for example, if the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.677066096791,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 52.800100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'crashes after committing the log entry but before respond-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91788714544117,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing to the client, the client will retry the command with a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58415250369765,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'new leader, causing it to be executed a second time. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70378224098212,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'solution is for clients to assign unique serial numbers to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54104844435287,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'every command. Then, the state machine tracks the latest',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6101323191289,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'serial number processed for each client, along with the as-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55831923870073,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sociated response. If it receives a command whose serial',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6095258533817,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 626.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number has already been executed, it responds immedi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7978918490073,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 614.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ately without re-executing the request.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.8506715773462,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 602.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Read-only operations can be handled without writing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70132804461807,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 590.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'anything into the log. However, with no additional mea-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67794631596033,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 578.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sures, this would run the risk of returning stale data, since',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58401962200526,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 566.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the leader responding to the request might have been su-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67749742928964,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 554.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'perseded by a newer leader of which it is unaware. Lin-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67761331471831,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 542.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'earizable reads must not return stale data, and Raft needs',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.756030031244,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 530.6403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two extra precautions to guarantee this without using the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70330031819725,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 518.6403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log. First, a leader must have the latest information on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6613343011822,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 506.64030000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which entries are committed. The Leader Completeness',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75579161530607,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 494.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Property guarantees that a leader has all committed en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67785686141568,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 482.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tries, but at the start of its term, it may not know which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6612919798876,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 470.8801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'those are. To find out, it needs to commit an entry from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7915574032425,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 458.8801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its term. Raft handles this by having each leader com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67678767089066,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 446.8801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mit a blank',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.42111302014753,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 435.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.018686979852532,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 367.0211130201475, 435.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'no-op',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.4613206122112,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 371.0398, 435.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.018779387788868,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 394.50112061221114, 435.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'entry into the log at the start of its',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 148.71544499852394,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 398.5199, 435.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'term. Second, a leader must check whether it has been de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67753900338636,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 423.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'posed before processing a read-only request (its informa-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91767425378706,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 411.00000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion may be stale if a more recent leader has been elected).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69134219129336,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 399.11990000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft handles this by having the leader exchange heart-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6770887518342,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 387.11990000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'beat messages with a majority of the cluster before re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67784043302206,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 375.2398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sponding to read-only requests. Alternatively, the leader',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67773421135442,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 363.2398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'could rely on the heartbeat mechanism to provide a form',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79127714421662,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 351.2398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of lease [9], but this would rely on timing for safety (it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60965747978133,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 339.3601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'assumes bounded clock skew).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 122.61043991959923,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 327.3601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6, 308.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.9776,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6, 308.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 324.5776, 308.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Implementation and evaluation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 160.0075432465407,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 336.4801253888, 308.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 296.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We have implemented Raft as part of a replicated',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.82147899733917,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 296.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine that stores configuration information for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6779503807173,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 284.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'RAMCloud [33] and assists in failover of the RAMCloud',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66143554152978,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 272.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'coordinator. The Raft implementation contains roughly',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90175449304976,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 260.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2000 lines of C++ code, not including tests, comments, or',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67717910301636,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 248.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'blank lines. The source code is freely available [23]. There',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70354782006282,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 236.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'are also about 25 independent third-party open source im-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67780666963532,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 224.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'plementations [34] of Raft in various stages of develop-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91689108069406,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 213.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ment, based on drafts of this paper. Also, various compa-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79726909434353,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 201.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nies are deploying Raft-based systems [34].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 174.2104448232754,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 189.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The remainder of this section evaluates Raft using three',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74310765067597,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 177.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'criteria: understandability, correctness, and performance.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 226.8907362250228,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 165.1198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 149.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9.1',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541337159767226,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 149.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898510486319992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 331.1413371597672, 149.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Understandability',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 77.58128587923065,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 341.0398476460872, 149.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 136.56 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To measure Raft’s understandability relative to Paxos,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.73117510783132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 136.56 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'we conducted an experimental study using upper-level un-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67745917275198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 124.56 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'dergraduate and graduate students in an Advanced Oper-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67797158121502,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 112.6799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ating Systems course at Stanford University and a Dis-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55794704443292,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 100.6799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tributed Computing course at U.C. Berkeley. We recorded',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90112114809935,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 88.6799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a video lecture of Raft and another of Paxos, and created',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66165513804094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 76.7998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'corresponding quizzes. The Raft lecture covered the con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67811890873548,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 64.7998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tent of this paper except for log compaction; the Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75554324669108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 52.799800000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '13',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5602, 22.919700000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 14
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 13,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 17, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 16,
      streamId: 14,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: '0',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.892,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 125.809, 575.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 595.565 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 595.565 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 616.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '20',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 616.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 636.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '30',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 636.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 657.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '40',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 657.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 677.465 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '50',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 677.465 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 697.965 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '60',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 121.917, 697.965 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 132.927, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '0',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.892,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 132.927, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.662000000000006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 136.819, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 151.481, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.666000000000025,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 159.265, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '20',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 171.931, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.716000000000008,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 179.715, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '30',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 192.431, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.665999999999997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 200.215, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '40',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 212.881, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.716000000000008,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 220.665, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '50',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 233.381, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.665999999999997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 241.165, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '60',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 253.831, 568.065 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 111.735, 622.509 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft grade',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.68300000000003,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 111.735, 622.509 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos grade',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.298,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 175.652, 557.565 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft then Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.805,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 191.1985, 588.715 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 191.199, 581.715 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos then Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.805,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 191.199, 581.715 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 545.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 14:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.5861371344324,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 545.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.7740628655676147,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.62593713443239, 545.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A scatter plot comparing 43 participants’ perfor-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.2657101934436,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 119.4, 545.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mance on the Raft and Paxos quizzes. Points above the diag-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50574411465894,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 534.4801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'onal (33) represent participants who scored higher for Raft.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 212.84159500000013,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 523.4403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 506.64029999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lecture covered enough material to create an equivalent',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84961748734443,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 506.64029999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'replicated state machine, including single-decree Paxos,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6901019023891,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 494.76019999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'multi-decree Paxos, reconfiguration, and a few optimiza-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7977957095315,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 482.76019999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tions needed in practice (such as leader election). The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.703356397898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 470.76019999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quizzes tested basic understanding of the algorithms and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6614590832485,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 458.8800999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'also required students to reason about corner cases. Each',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66137963119448,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 446.8800999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'student watched one video, took the corresponding quiz,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69029672181452,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 434.9999999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'watched the second video, and took the second quiz.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6905553619115,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 422.9999999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'About half of the participants did the Paxos portion first',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6096548795325,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 410.9999999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and the other half did the Raft portion first in order to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54136499727642,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 399.11989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'account for both individual differences in performance',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.94381155863155,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 387.11989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and experience gained from the first portion of the study.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81060820255414,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 375.11989999999986 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We compared participants’ scores on each quiz to deter-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67765024622489,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 363.23979999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mine whether participants showed a better understanding',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.02132122659893,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 351.23979999999983 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of Raft.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.450658714173386,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 339.3600999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We tried to make the comparison between Paxos and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70077430116163,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.95996000000005, 323.9998999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft as fair as possible. The experiment favored Paxos in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5405560707589,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 312.11979999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two ways: 15 of the 43 participants reported having some',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.704189912211,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 300.11979999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'prior experience with Paxos, and the Paxos video is 14%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.73899540127778,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 288.11979999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'longer than the Raft video. As summarized in Table 1, we',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58319361952297,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 276.24009999999976 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have taken steps to mitigate potential sources of bias. All',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6089665706975,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 264.24009999999976 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of our materials are available for review [28, 31].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 195.57101804927103,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 252.35999999999976 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'On average, participants scored 4.9 points higher on the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.7433405771994,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.95996000000005, 236.99979999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft quiz than on the Paxos quiz (out of a possible 60',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6611450508731,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 225.11969999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'points, the mean Raft score was 25.7 and the mean Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75482497023512,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 213.11969999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'score was 20.8); Figure 14 shows their individual scores.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6913208015052,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 201.11969999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'A paired',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.34123400773338,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99980000000005, 189.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.938865992266642,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 107.34103400773341, 189.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 't',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.76961392,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 110.27990000000005, 189.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '-test states that, with 95% confidence, the true',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 187.66322548077756,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 113.04006000000005, 189.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'distribution of Raft scores has a mean at least 2.5 points',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75573453934177,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99986000000006, 177.23999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'larger than the true distribution of Paxos scores.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 190.40997828020906,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99986000000006, 165.36029999999977 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We also created a linear regression model that predicts',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.79518174230967,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96002000000006, 150.00009999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a new student’s quiz scores based on three factors: which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66160015423088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99986000000006, 138.11999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quiz they took, their degree of prior Paxos experience, and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66170733231198,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99986000000006, 126.11999999999978 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 333.209, 629.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '0',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.892,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 333.209, 629.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 333.209, 648.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '5',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.892,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 333.209, 648.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 667.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 667.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 685.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '15',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 685.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 704.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '20',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.784,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 329.317, 704.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 352.259, 622.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'implement',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.284,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 352.259, 622.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.919899999999984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 384.543, 622.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'explain',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.176,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 411.4629, 622.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 323.335, 636.577 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number of participants',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 69.25100000000008,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 323.335, 636.577 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 682.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos much easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 59.52100000000007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 682.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 675.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos somewhat easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 74.30500000000008,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 675.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 668.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Roughly equal',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 44.744000000000035,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 668.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 661.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft somewhat easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 67.69000000000007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 661.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 654.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft much easier',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.90600000000007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 473.75, 654.865 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 608.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 15:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.90606313970536,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 608.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.854136860294716,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 364.54606313970527, 608.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Using a 5-point scale, participants were asked',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 173.6829958118008,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 368.4002, 608.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(left) which algorithm they felt would be easier to implement',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.4926536399999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 597.4801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in a functioning, correct, and efficient system, and (right)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.62535812547904,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 586.4399 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which would be easier to explain to a CS graduate student.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 210.08099970130795,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.64, 575.52 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 558.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the order in which they learned the algorithms. The model',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.73015135653395,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 558.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'predicts that the choice of quiz produces a 12.5-point dif-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6782092399922,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 546.72 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ference in favor of Raft. This is significantly higher than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66111592011325,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 534.8403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the observed difference of 4.9 points, because many of the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70333992965385,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 522.8403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'actual students had prior Paxos experience, which helped',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7817923223936,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 510.96020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos considerably, whereas it helped Raft slightly less.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.57072620246217,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 498.96020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Curiously, the model also predicts scores 6.3 points lower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6779848813396,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 486.96020000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on Raft for people that have already taken the Paxos quiz;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7293023602786,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 475.0801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'although we don’t know why, this does appear to be sta-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55827742550068,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 463.0801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tistically significant.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 80.97056756887459,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 451.0801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We also surveyed participants after their quizzes to see',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.6237932807607,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 436.8 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'which algorithm they felt would be easier to implement',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8494145882181,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 424.8 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'or explain; these results are shown in Figure 15. An over-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79713040443215,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 412.8 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'whelming majority of participants reported Raft would be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70308254484948,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 400.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'easier to implement and explain (33 of 41 for each ques-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67792283401755,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 388.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion). However, these self-reported feelings may be less',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.51562027026088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 376.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'reliable than participants’ quiz scores, and participants',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87541028409746,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 365.03979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'may have been biased by knowledge of our hypothesis',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8757562865847,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 353.03979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'that Raft is easier to understand.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 128.73077415478434,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 341.16009999999994 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'A detailed discussion of the Raft user study is available',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74349817620123,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 326.76009999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'at [31].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.77060384678959,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 314.76009999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 296.99989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9.2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541337159767226,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 296.99989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898510486319992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 331.14149715976714, 296.99989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Correctness',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.9154605219786,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 341.04000764608713, 296.99989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 281.5198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We have developed a formal specification and a proof',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.83727995359465,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56031999999993, 281.5198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of safety for the consensus mechanism described in Sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55805484019768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 269.64009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion 5. The formal specification [31] makes the informa-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9179001964995,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 257.64009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion summarized in Figure 2 completely precise using the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7033490056191,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 245.64009999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'TLA+ specification language [17]. It is about 400 lines',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63545947205122,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 233.75999999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'long and serves as the subject of the proof. It is also use-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67784920014546,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 221.75999999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ful on its own for anyone implementing Raft. We have',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7037703057393,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 209.75999999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mechanically proven the Log Completeness Property us-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67748576303805,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 197.87989999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing the TLA proof system [7]. However, this proof relies',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63557315573615,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 185.87989999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on invariants that have not been mechanically checked',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78152112937036,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 173.99979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(for example, we have not proven the type safety of the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70365505791975,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 161.99979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'specification). Furthermore, we have written an informal',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84975136530062,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 149.99979999999996 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'proof [31] of the State Machine Safety property which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66181653280898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 138.11969999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'is complete (it relies on the specification alone) and rela-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67807489379206,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.60015999999996, 126.11969999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.2398, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Concern',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.70524030346117,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.2398, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.97489732460001,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 110.94504030346117, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Steps taken to mitigate bias',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 105.00836124236653,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.91993762806118, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 162.11150112957233,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 268.9282988704277, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Materials for review [28, 31]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 107.62590346485162,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.0398, 110.28 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.2398, 98.8801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Equal lecture quality',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.72347499096496,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.2398, 98.8801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.956847057599987,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 151.96327499096492, 98.8801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Same lecturer for both. Paxos lecture based on and improved from exist-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 255.10530841611353,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.9201220485649, 98.8801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing materials used in several universities. Paxos lecture is 14% longer.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 251.12162401772488,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.91980000000004, 87.9602 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'videos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.287878270668337,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.0400000000001, 98.8801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Equal quiz difficulty',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.48314014144493,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.24000000000007, 76.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.196966713999984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 151.72314014144496, 76.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Questions grouped in difficulty and paired across exams.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 203.2413181793964,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.92010685544494, 76.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.87855338740002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 367.1614250348412, 76.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'quizzes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.767907972656147,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.03997842224123, 76.9199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Fair grading',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 43.842970512677184,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 78.24000000000004, 66 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.836770424799994,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 122.0829705126772, 66 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Used rubric. Graded in random order, alternating between quizzes.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 238.7618025858013,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.9197409374772, 66 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.358597672600013,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 402.68154352327844, 66 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'rubric',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.381051406701804,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.04014119587845, 66 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 85.8, 52.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Table 1:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.70590180961001,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 85.8, 52.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2940981903900024,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.50590180961, 52.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Concerns of possible bias against Paxos in the study, steps taken to counter each, and additional materials available.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 414.5609525851967,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 118.8, 52.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5602, 22.919900000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '14',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5602, 22.919900000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 15
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 14,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 18, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 17,
      streamId: 15,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: '0%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.115,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 91.3055, 624.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 640.265 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '20%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 640.265 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 655.915 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '40%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 655.915 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 671.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '60%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 671.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 687.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '80%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 687.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 83.5219, 702.765 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '100%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.899,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 83.5219, 702.765 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 108.005, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '100',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 108.005, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.12900000000002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 119.68099999999998, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '1000',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.568,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 152.81, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.23600000000002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 168.378, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '10000',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.46,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 197.614, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.394000000000005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 217.07399999999998, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '100000',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.352,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 242.468, 614.515 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 79.2551, 636.68 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cumulative percent',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 58.744000000000035,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 79.2551, 636.68 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-150ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 663.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 656.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-151ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 656.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 649.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-155ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 649.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 642.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-175ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 642.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 635.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-200ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 635.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 628.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-300ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 628.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 91.3055, 534.365 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '0%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.115,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 91.3055, 534.365 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 548.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '20%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 548.015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 561.615 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '40%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 561.615 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 575.215 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '60%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 575.215 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 588.815 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '80%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.007,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 87.4137, 588.815 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 83.5219, 602.465 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '100%',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.899,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 83.5219, 602.465 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 104.64699999999999, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '0',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.892,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 104.64699999999999, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.01600000000002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 108.53899999999999, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '100',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 129.555, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.074000000000012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 141.231, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '200',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 158.305, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.123999999999995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 169.981, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '300',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 187.105, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.074000000000012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 198.78099999999998, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '400',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 215.855, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.124000000000024,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 227.53099999999998, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '500',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 244.655, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.074000000000012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 256.331, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '600',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.676,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 273.40500000000003, 524.665 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 79.2551, 541.38 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cumulative percent',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 58.744000000000035,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 0, 7, -7, 0, 79.2551, 541.38 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'time without leader (ms)',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 74.68300000000002,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 161.781, 514.165 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '12-24ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.23,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 232.8915, 566.3149999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 232.891, 559.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '25-50ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.23,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 232.891, 559.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 229, 552.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '50-100ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.122,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 229, 552.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 545.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '100-200ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 545.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 538.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '150-300ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.013999999999996,
  height: 7,
  transform: [ 7, 0, 0, 7, 225.108, 538.315 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f14',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 503.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Figure 16:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.9459041655524,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 503.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0142958344476085,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.98570416555239, 503.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The time to detect and replace a crashed leader.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 175.52169473073857,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 120, 503.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The top graph varies the amount of randomness in election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56336963119733,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 492.4801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'timeouts, and the bottom graph scales the minimum election',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.56296072840368,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 481.4403 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'timeout. Each line represents 1000 trials (except for 100 tri-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.62580196278435,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.0398, 470.52 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'als for “150–150ms”) and corresponds to a particular choice',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.42113689569362,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 459.6001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of election timeouts; for example, “150–155ms” means that',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.4924280450909,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 448.5603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election timeouts were chosen randomly and uniformly be-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.50637000384864,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 437.6404 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tween 150ms and 155ms. The measurements were taken on a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.54096885231235,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 426.7205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cluster of five servers with a broadcast time of roughly 15ms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.48138029033504,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 415.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Results for a cluster of nine servers are similar.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 168.4417151230322,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 77.03980000000001, 404.7608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 387.9608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tively precise (it is about 3500 words long).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 173.49039785662788,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 387.9608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 370.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '9.3',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.541318828509604,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 370.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.898530411600007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 84.54127882850962, 370.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Performance',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 55.06348288647599,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 94.43980924010962, 370.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 355.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s performance is similar to other consensus algo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71728909053584,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 355.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rithms such as Paxos. The most important case for per-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.677369847722,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 343.6807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'formance is when an established leader is replicating new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7129652844769,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 331.8006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entries. Raft achieves this using the minimal number',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79707945549134,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 319.8006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of messages (a single round-trip from the leader to half the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70353196950276,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 307.8006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cluster). It is also possible to further improve Raft’s per-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67755875930166,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 295.92049999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'formance. For example, it easily supports batching and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6609545054205,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 283.92049999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pipelining requests for higher throughput and lower la-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55782634704946,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 271.92049999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tency. Various optimizations have been proposed in the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70306746141284,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 260.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'literature for other algorithms; many of these could be ap-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6780184753619,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 248.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'plied to Raft, but we leave this to future work.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 183.4501714755855,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 236.04079999999993 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We used our Raft implementation to measure the per-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71795878915918,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 222.24079999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'formance of Raft’s leader election algorithm and answer',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6778891005188,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 210.24079999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'two questions. First, does the election process converge',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.06340484261628,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 198.24079999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quickly? Second, what is the minimum downtime that can',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66174365609749,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 186.36069999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'be achieved after leader crashes?',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 130.7835814269088,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 174.36069999999992 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'To measure leader election, we repeatedly crashed the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.74365193958718,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96012000000002, 160.4407999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'leader of a cluster of five servers and timed how long it',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.60935111863895,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 148.4407999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'took to detect the crash and elect a new leader (see Fig-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67724217649027,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 136.5606999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ure 16). To generate a worst-case scenario, the servers in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54179273326204,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 124.56069999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'each trial had different log lengths, so some candidates',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87506597525928,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 112.68059999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'were not eligible to become leader. Furthermore, to en-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776605774824,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 100.68059999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'courage split votes, our test script triggered a synchro-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91756058006482,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 88.68059999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nized broadcast of heartbeat RPCs from the leader before',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82317739794505,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 76.80049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'terminating its process (this approximates the behavior',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79777383157415,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 64.80049999999991 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of the leader replicating a new log entry prior to crash-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67741818645126,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99996000000002, 52.800499999999914 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing). The leader was crashed uniformly randomly within',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66197950167398,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 698.0405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its heartbeat interval, which was half of the minimum',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79098122392068,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 686.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'election timeout for all tests. Thus, the smallest possible',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70375588979917,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 674.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'downtime was about half of the minimum election time-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67827278171023,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 662.1608 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.330653186668545,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 650.2807 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The top graph in Figure 16 shows that a small amount',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.89033420960214,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 637.4405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of randomization in the election timeout is enough to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54197059627413,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 625.4405 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'avoid split votes in elections. In the absence of random-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91793027370997,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 613.5604000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ness, leader election consistently took longer than 10 sec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55774973434765,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 601.5604000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'onds in our tests due to many split votes. Adding just 5ms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75585407109673,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 589.6803000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'of randomness helps significantly, resulting in a median',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.78176906959183,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 577.6803000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'downtime of 287ms. Using more randomness improves',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8758292230723,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 565.6803000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'worst-case behavior: with 50ms of randomness the worst-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67786834833947,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 553.8002000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'case completion time (over 1000 trials) was 513ms.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 205.65121348520654,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 541.8002000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The bottom graph in Figure 16 shows that downtime',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.86329757724482,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 528.9604000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'can be reduced by reducing the election timeout. With',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54132980923148,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 517.0803000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'an election timeout of 12–24ms, it takes only 35ms on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6609566374251,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 505.0803000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'average to elect a leader (the longest trial took 152ms).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8104239236018,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 493.0803000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'However, lowering the timeouts beyond this point violates',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7555302753337,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 481.20020000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s timing requirement: leaders have difficulty broad-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79722330605009,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 469.20020000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'casting heartbeats before other servers start new elections.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69067769509985,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 457.32010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'This can cause unnecessary leader changes and lower',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67774912542677,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 445.32010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'overall system availability. We recommend using a con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6776815986526,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 433.32010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'servative election timeout such as 150–300ms; such time-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6774673221916,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 421.4404000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'outs are unlikely to cause unnecessary leader changes and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66165962122878,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 409.4404000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'will still provide good availability.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.0102847369955,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 397.4404000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.59996, 378.24040000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.977612174336011,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.59996, 378.24040000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 330.577572174336, 378.24040000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Related work',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 68.68696385715205,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 342.480097563136, 378.24040000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 365.4006000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There have been numerous publications related to con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71742546911463,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 365.4006000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus algorithms, many of which fall into one of the fol-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777833371323,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 353.4006000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lowing categories:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.08988994905124,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59996, 341.5205000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 328.68070000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56012, 328.68070000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54143999999997, 328.68070000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Lamport’s original description of Paxos [15], and at-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.638077724329,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52027999999996, 328.68070000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tempts to explain it more clearly [16, 20, 21].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 180.56996414199654,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52027999999996, 316.68070000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56050999999997, 304.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56050999999997, 304.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54182999999995, 304.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Elaborations of Paxos, which fill in missing details',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71540681944606,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52066999999994, 304.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and modify the algorithm to provide a better founda-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.99774785771837,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52066999999994, 292.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion for implementation [26, 39, 13].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 146.13089640170477,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.52066999999994, 280.80060000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56089999999995, 268.9205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56089999999995, 268.9205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.54221999999993, 268.9205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Systems that implement consensus algorithms, such',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7417448914119,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 268.9205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'as Chubby [2, 4], ZooKeeper [11, 12], and Span-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75858361602542,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 256.9205 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ner [6]. The algorithms for Chubby and Spanner',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.87809900212784,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 245.0408 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have not been published in detail, though both claim',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75030694363002,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 233.0408 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to be based on Paxos. ZooKeeper’s algorithm has',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.71660947945898,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 221.0408 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'been published in more detail, but it is quite different',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.92997030422433,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 209.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'from Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.090517277500716,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5210599999999, 197.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56128999999993, 185.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56128999999993, 185.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.5426099999999, 185.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Performance optimizations that can be applied to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6220170420489,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5214499999999, 185.1607 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos [18, 19, 3, 25, 1, 27].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 110.01088049391363,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5214499999999, 173.2806 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5616799999999, 161.2806 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '•',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98132,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5616799999999, 161.2806 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.978839999999991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 333.5429999999999, 161.2806 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f4',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Oki and Liskov’s Viewstamped Replication (VR), an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.74180011432526,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 161.2806 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'alternative approach to consensus developed around',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.86187890764504,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 149.4005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the same time as Paxos. The original description [29]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.63773350515444,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 137.4005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'was intertwined with a protocol for distributed trans-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75725679163014,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 125.4005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'actions, but the core consensus protocol has been',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.7414797158229,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 113.5204 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'separated in a recent update [22]. VR uses a leader-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.75764042300867,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 101.5204 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'based approach with many similarities to Raft.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.49087465816703,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 338.5218399999999, 89.5204 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The greatest difference between Raft and Paxos is',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.67566801996804,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.5620699999999, 76.8005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s strong leadership: Raft uses leader election as an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66096142945503,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6019099999999, 64.8005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'essential part of the consensus protocol, and it concen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79808421762297,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6019099999999, 52.8005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '15',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5621099999999, 22.9204 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 16
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 15,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 19, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 18,
      streamId: 16,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'trates as much functionality as possible in the leader. This',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63610300878224,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'approach results in a simpler algorithm that is easier to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54180825505523,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'understand. For example, in Paxos, leader election is or-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67759653763264,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'thogonal to the basic consensus protocol: it serves only as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6354069490133,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a performance optimization and is not required for achiev-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79737671078104,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ing consensus. However, this results in additional mecha-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79752917902354,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'nism: Paxos includes both a two-phase protocol for basic',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58347251366735,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 626.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus and a separate mechanism for leader election.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6906506047499,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 614.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In contrast, Raft incorporates leader election directly into',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66133919033263,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 602.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the consensus algorithm and uses it as the first of the two',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54154981421104,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 590.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'phases of consensus. This results in less mechanism than',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66120496618993,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 578.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'in Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.45066503026297,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 566.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Like Raft, VR and ZooKeeper are leader-based and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.70155698608525,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96015999999997, 546.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'therefore share many of Raft’s advantages over Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69089272678968,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 534.8403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'However, Raft has less mechanism that VR or ZooKeeper',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91782469961385,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 522.8403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'because it minimizes the functionality in non-leaders. For',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67751266216644,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 510.8403000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'example, log entries in Raft flow in only one direction:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.84945147987415,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 498.96020000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'outward from the leader in AppendEntries RPCs. In VR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.64477021666562,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 486.96020000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entries flow in both directions (leaders can receive',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82300484502025,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 475.08010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'log entries during the election process); this results in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54176221769578,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 463.08010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'additional mechanism and complexity. The published de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67765423128094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 451.08010000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'scription of ZooKeeper also transfers log entries both to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5418914530619,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 439.2000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and from the leader, but the implementation is apparently',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90097453788945,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 427.2000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'more like Raft [35].',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 79.0506695955456,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 415.2000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft has fewer message types than any other algo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71789172066687,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96015999999997, 395.4000000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rithm for consensus-based log replication that we are',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70313380263232,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 383.51990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'aware of. For example, we counted the message types VR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.64507349935263,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 371.51990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and ZooKeeper use for basic consensus and membership',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90132730500918,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 359.51990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'changes (excluding log compaction and client interaction,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8111320481279,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 347.63980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'as these are nearly independent of the algorithms). VR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6451172054542,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 335.63980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and ZooKeeper each define 10 different message types,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69077448021565,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 323.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'while Raft has only 4 message types (two RPC requests',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7556025343618,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 311.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and their responses). Raft’s messages are a bit more dense',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7034035510731,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 299.7601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'than the other algorithms’, but they are simpler collec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772987244351,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 287.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tively. In addition, VR and ZooKeeper are described in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5413120159568,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 275.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'terms of transmitting entire logs during leader changes;',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8496103540942,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 263.88 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'additional message types will be required to optimize',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.703529030524,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 251.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'these mechanisms so that they are practical.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 174.57011395043835,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 239.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Raft’s strong leadership approach simplifies the algo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71751323997313,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 81.96015999999997, 220.19989999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rithm, but it precludes some performance optimizations.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81053886257956,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 208.3198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'For example, Egalitarian Paxos (EPaxos) can achieve',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8233783742819,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 196.3198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'higher performance under some conditions with a lead-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777071428619,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 184.3198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'erless approach [27]. EPaxos exploits commutativity in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54100375195014,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 172.44009999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'state machine commands. Any server can commit a com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772897979094,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 160.44009999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mand with just one round of communication as long as',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63613816693882,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 148.44009999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'other commands that are proposed concurrently commute',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.82374580640771,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 136.55999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'with it. However, if commands that are proposed con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67738517026237,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 124.55999999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'currently do not commute with each other, EPaxos re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67730774062412,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 112.67989999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'quires an additional round of communication. Because',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.58395764442196,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 100.67989999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'any server may commit commands, EPaxos balances load',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66196953903423,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 88.67989999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'well between servers and is able to achieve lower latency',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6618385303181,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 76.79979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'than Raft in WAN settings. However, it adds significant',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.72930185218397,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 64.79979999999998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'complexity to Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.61079117385474,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 71.99999999999997, 52.799799999999976 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Several',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.649442194165506,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.070485608000013,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 358.2094421941655, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'different',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.32954335782531,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 365.2799278021655, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.070485608000013,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 399.60947115999073, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'approaches',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 45.15560692079768,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 406.67995676799075, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.9246126331199775,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 451.83556368878834, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.71756132740719,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 458.7601763219083, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.122261448079996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 470.4777376493155, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'cluster',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.59755637661472,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 477.5999990973955, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.242281372159994,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 504.19755547401013, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'member-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.9574648459047,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 511.4398368461701, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ship changes have been proposed or implemented in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.54157136340098,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'other work, including Lamport’s original proposal [15],',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6902417280416,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'VR [22], and SMART [24]. We chose the joint consensus',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.75542554806225,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'approach for Raft because it leverages the rest of the con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6775985700108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus protocol, so that very little additional mechanism',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79135079801432,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'is required for membership changes. Lamport’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 192.51548665267808,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59984000000003, 626.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.9626359046, 0, 1.6637607314, 9.9626359046, 514.08, 626.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f15',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'α',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.2864232558026,
  height: 10.100604632346212,
  transform: [ 9.9626359046, 0, 1.6637607314, 9.9626359046, 514.08, 626.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f15',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '-based',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.10136731059271,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 521.16, 626.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'approach was not an option for Raft because it assumes',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63553432136564,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 614.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'consensus can be reached without a leader. In comparison',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90127966366472,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 602.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'to VR and SMART, Raft’s reconfiguration algorithm has',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.63543237367054,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 590.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the advantage that membership changes can occur with-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67784862231233,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 578.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out limiting the processing of normal requests; in con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6779749087371,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 566.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'trast, VR stops all normal processing during configura-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.91757723759895,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 554.6402 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion changes, and SMART imposes an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.5815452537611,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 542.6402 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.9626359046, 0, 1.6637607314, 9.9626359046, 473.64, 542.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f15',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'α',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.2864232558026,
  height: 10.100604632346212,
  transform: [ 9.9626359046, 0, 1.6637607314, 9.9626359046, 473.64, 542.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f15',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '-like limit on the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.5831741486139,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 480.72, 542.64 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'number of outstanding requests. Raft’s approach also adds',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.755827988905,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 530.7599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'less mechanism than either VR or SMART.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 172.7708347056663,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 518.7599 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6, 498.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '11',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.977612174336011,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.6, 498.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 330.577612174336, 498.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Conclusion',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 57.167201531392045,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 342.480137563136, 498.24 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 484.07980000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Algorithms are often designed with correctness, effi-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71829323498395,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56016, 484.07980000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ciency, and/or conciseness as the primary goals. Although',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7813732738299,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 472.1997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'these are all worthy goals, we believe that understandabil-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 229.03823621522156,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 460.1997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ity is just as important. None of the other goals can be',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70315009154882,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 448.1997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'achieved until developers render the algorithm into a prac-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67816837324312,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 436.3196 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tical implementation, which will inevitably deviate from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7911623048653,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 424.3196 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and expand upon the published form. Unless developers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.99534959049467,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 412.43989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'have a deep understanding of the algorithm and can cre-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67742868707356,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 400.43989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ate intuitions about it, it will be difficult for them to retain',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66132000000061,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.6, 388.43989999999997 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'its desirable properties in their implementation.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 189.0907286296406,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 376.56019999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In this paper we addressed the issue of distributed con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71779599962144,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56015999999994, 362.4 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sensus, where a widely accepted but impenetrable algo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67760830351048,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 350.51989999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rithm, Paxos, has challenged students and developers for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67767405693414,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 338.51989999999995 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'many years. We developed a new algorithm, Raft, which',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66152244563864,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 326.6397999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'we have shown to be more understandable than Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6908137330171,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 314.6397999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'We also believe that Raft provides a better foundation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90154700114633,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 302.6397999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'for system building. Using understandability as the pri-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6777518253021,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 290.7596999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mary design goal changed the way we approached the de-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67768058246344,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 278.7596999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sign of Raft; as the design progressed we found ourselves',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.87549823428347,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 266.7596999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'reusing a few techniques repeatedly, such as decomposing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.90141532493354,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 254.8795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'the problem and simplifying the state space. These tech-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67800199715512,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 242.8795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'niques not only improved the understandability of Raft',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6101081099138,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 230.8795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'but also made it easier to convince ourselves of its cor-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67870277921546,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 218.9994999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'rectness.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.65066026619573,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 206.9994999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.59999999999997, 186.4795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '12',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.977612174336011,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 318.59999999999997, 186.4795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.902525388799972,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 330.57761217433597, 186.4795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Acknowledgments',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 93.330749444224,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 342.48013756313594, 186.4795999999999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56015999999994, 172.43979999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The user study would not have been possible with-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 218.71764199713235,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 328.56015999999994, 172.43979999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'out the support of Ali Ghodsi, David Mazi`',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 180.4376363425726,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 160.43979999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'eres, and the',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 52.183629655000445,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 495.1200573032921, 160.43979999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'students of CS 294-91 at Berkeley and CS 240 at Stan-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67825469951882,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 148.43979999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ford. Scott Klemmer helped us design the user study,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.8112421851129,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 136.55969999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and Nelson Ray advised us on statistical analysis. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.70417475903568,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 124.55969999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos slides for the user study borrowed heavily from',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79081987896595,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 112.67959999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a slide deck originally created by Lorenzo Alvisi. Spe-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6779979224354,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 100.67959999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cial thanks go to David Mazi`',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 131.11725504748244,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 88.67959999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'eres and Ezra Hoch for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 101.47790594412494,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 445.7996760082022, 88.67959999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'finding subtle bugs in Raft. Many people provided help-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6773631129771,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 76.79949999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ful feedback on the paper and user study materials,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69042595718042,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 64.79949999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'including Ed Bugnion, Michael Chan, Hugues Evrard,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.81101724862694,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 318.59999999999997, 52.79949999999988 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '16',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.56019999999995, 22.919399999999882 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 17
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 16,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 20, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 19,
      streamId: 17,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: 'Daniel Giffin, Arjun Gopalan, Jon Howell, Vimalkumar',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.79760226495065,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Jeyakumar, Ankita Kejriwal, Aleksandar Kracun, Amit',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6097303166425,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 686.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Levy, Joel Martin, Satoshi Matsushita, Oleg Pesok, David',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6618227594591,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 674.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Ramos, Robbert van Renesse, Mendel Rosenblum, Nico-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.677480044483,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 662.1603 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'las Schiper, Deian Stefan, Andrew Stone, Ryan Stutsman,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.69064596215964,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 650.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'David Terei, Stephen Yang, Matei Zaharia, 24 anony-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.9172964206652,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 638.2802 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'mous conference reviewers (with duplicates), and espe-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6772235563162,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 626.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cially our shepherd Eddie Kohler. Werner Vogels tweeted',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66039527254924,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 614.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a link to an earlier draft, which gave Raft significant ex-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6773084778595,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 602.4001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'posure. This work was supported by the Gigascale Sys-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.5574187455591,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 590.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tems Research Center and the Multiscale Systems Cen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67727698595445,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 578.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ter, two of six research centers funded under the Fo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67664015408056,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 566.5200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'cus Center Research Program, a Semiconductor Research',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.6612304107724,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 554.6403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Corporation program, by STARnet, a Semiconductor Re-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.55795293235323,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 542.6403000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'search Corporation program sponsored by MARCO and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.66106116544418,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 530.7602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'DARPA, by the National Science Foundation under Grant',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7294726118337,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 518.7602000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'No. 0963859, and by grants from Facebook, Google, Mel-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.67766008931304,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 506.76020000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'lanox, NEC, NetApp, SAP, and Samsung. Diego Ongaro',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7816069674766,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 494.88010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'is supported by The Junglee Corporation Stanford Gradu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 228.7971867033108,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 482.88010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ate Fellowship.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.81087389251393,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 72, 470.88010000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 452.2801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'References',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 55.29072221015036,
  height: 11.9552,
  transform: [ 11.9552, 0, 0, 11.9552, 72, 452.2801000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f1',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.43984, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[1] B',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.43984, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OLOSKY',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.458272042450012,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.63984, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', W. J., B',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.301320888423966,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 129.47934, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'RADSHAW',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.45069599965001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 170.28014000000002, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.03425296103399,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 208.43954000000002, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AAGENS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.22769274295002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 237.96024000000003, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R. B.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.922068678478034,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 269.63954, 440.7602000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16054, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'USTERS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.18785032086,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 99.1207, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', N. P.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.56193671569197,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 128.7602, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.71856328430809,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 159.32213671569193, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 164.04070000000002, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.90113639620003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 180.4993636038, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.47845818,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 185.40050000000002, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'I',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3886423,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 191.40050000000002, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', P.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.761917433851998,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 194.28058000000001, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.478290995599991,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 208.042497433852, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Paxos replicated state',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 82.10098007611793,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 218.52078842945198, 429.7200000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'machines as the basis of a high-performance data store.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6417945884745,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92058000000002, 418.8001000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483191368109205,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92058000000002, 407.8802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.636708631890798,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 99.40377136810922, 407.8802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. NSDI’11, USENIX Conference on Networked',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.48319464687285,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 104.04048000000002, 407.8802000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Systems Design and Implementation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 137.8029302722071,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92058000000002, 396.8400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.877069727792929,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 229.7235102722071, 396.8400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2011), USENIX,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.08150334339824,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 234.60058000000004, 396.8400000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pp. 141–154.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.761433504006185,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92058000000003, 385.9201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[2] B',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.44048000000004, 369.7201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'URROWS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.54800939445001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.52058000000004, 369.7201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.121684577787978,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 131.52058000000005, 369.7201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.278320360199984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 148.642264577788, 369.7201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The Chubby lock service for loosely-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 142.54569934033145,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 157.920584937988, 369.7201000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'coupled distributed systems.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 103.76165263390611,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92098000000004, 358.80020000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7583371939599886,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 195.68263263390608, 358.80020000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 202.44096982786607, 358.80020000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.3168066097479425,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 209.9241733902521, 358.80020000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. OSDI’06, Sympo-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 87.2255518970519,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 213.24098000000004, 358.80020000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'sium on Operating Systems Design and Implementation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.603369696001,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92098000000004, 347.7604000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92098000000004, 336.84050000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(2006), USENIX, pp. 335–350.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.52124951209434,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92098000000004, 336.84050000000013 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[3] C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.44088000000005, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMARGOS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.667540247270004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.64088000000005, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L. J., S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.78567311537199,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 137.75998000000004, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'CHMIDT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.662461070670012,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 172.08028000000004, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R. M.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.44197103448201,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 202.67988000000005, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2783289655180283,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 233.12185103448203, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 236.40018000000006, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.101136396200019,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 252.85884360380004, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'P',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98530728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 255.95998000000006, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EDONE',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.222214616510026,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 261.47990000000004, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', F.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.201751174367978,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 288.23930000000007, 320.64050000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Multicoordinated Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 88.76164217094266,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92130000000006, 309.72060000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.798575878760005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 180.68294217094268, 309.72060000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483191368109191,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 186.4815180497027, 309.72060000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0765905821881745,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 193.9647094178119, 309.72060000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. PODC’07, ACM Sym-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 103.5457499683912,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 197.04130000000006, 309.72060000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'posium on Principles of Distributed Computing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.6032087690165,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92130000000006, 298.68080000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.9167912309836197,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 270.52450876901645, 298.68080000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2007),',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.001652435495032,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 274.44130000000007, 298.68080000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ACM, pp. 316–317.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 71.36144680270176,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92130000000006, 287.76090000000016 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[4] C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.44120000000007, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HANDRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.018424879000015,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.64120000000007, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', T. D., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.59406975732997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 132.12050000000008, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'RIESEMER',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 38.98407982524006,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 169.20100000000008, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.16190622646601,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 208.6807000000001, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.798293773534027,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 224.84260622646607, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 227.6409000000001, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.8608363962000283,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 244.09956360380008, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 246.9604000000001, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EDSTONE',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.46207050980001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 253.4404800000001, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.001757226379961,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 289.43968000000007, 271.5609000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Paxos made live: an engineering perspective.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 169.28141784739267,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92168000000007, 260.6410000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.678469538199977,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 261.2030978473927, 260.6410000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 269.8815673855927, 260.6410000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.916909052021367,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 277.3647709479787, 260.6410000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.281441813579647,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 281.28168000000005, 260.6410000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'PODC’07, ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.72316749967803,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92168000000004, 249.6008000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Computing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.76318827814695,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92168000000004, 238.68090000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.356711721853088,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 131.68486827814695, 238.68090000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2007), ACM, pp. 398–407.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.68148052324067,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 134.04158000000004, 238.68090000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[5] C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.44158000000004, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HANG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.098506305700013,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.64158000000005, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', F., D',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.19367355261598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 121.20098000000004, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.738743312710017,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 146.88108000000005, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.233906857588018,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.08068000000006, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HEMAWAT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.982370756440005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 187.80098000000007, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.67371560505598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 225.72048000000007, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'SIEH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.418829663949982,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 251.88068000000007, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', W. C.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.80174703198203,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 269.76038000000005, 222.4809000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'W',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.464262719999999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16238000000004, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ALLACH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.338740221360005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 100.20222000000004, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 132.00182000000004, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.038417577379988,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 134.24341500000003, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'D.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.201760027931991,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 140.28183257738002, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.398256339540012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 149.483592605312, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.961922028679984,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 155.881848944852, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.278339973420003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 167.84377097353197, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'B',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 174.12211094695198, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'URROWS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.54799720018001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 180.48232000000004, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 213.48232000000004, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.278322040659987,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 215.72391500000003, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'M.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.401738845889998,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 222.00223704066002, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.39824737315999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 235.40397588655, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 241.80222325971, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HANDRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.01843707327004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 248.28232000000003, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 281.76162000000005, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.158405674540006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 284.00321500000007, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'T.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.281815193849981,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 290.1616206745401, 211.56100000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'F',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98530728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16262000000006, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'IKES',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.42808798412,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 97.68254000000006, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', A.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.241936286520005,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 115.56224000000006, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2783637134799903,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 132.80417628652006, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 136.08254000000005, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.22103639620002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 152.54120360380003, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 155.76224000000005, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'RUBER',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.664139546100028,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 162.72240000000005, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R. E.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.521615314564006,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 188.88220000000004, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.438477091580012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 214.403815314564, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Bigtable: a distributed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 80.80326726409385,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 219.84229240614403, 200.52080000000018 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'storage system for structured data.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 130.28144024928827,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92240000000004, 189.60090000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.03838003140001,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 222.20384024928825, 189.60090000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 231.24222028068826, 189.60090000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.0369761569257605,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 238.72542384307428, 189.60090000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. OSDI’06,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 57.801337691978944,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 242.76240000000004, 189.60090000000017 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'USENIX Symposium on Operating Systems Design and',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6032110717723,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92240000000004, 178.68100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Implementation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 56.203219525532745,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92240000000004, 167.64120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.356980474467292,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 148.12561952553276, 167.64120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2006), USENIX, pp. 205–218.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.52134167751437,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 150.48260000000005, 167.64120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[6] C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.7005101661956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 76.44240000000005, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ORBETT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.422603366319997,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.64240000000005, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. C., D',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.91440059465999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 129.00220000000004, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.738743312710017,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 167.40300000000005, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J., E',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.438645178508,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 183.60260000000005, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'PSTEIN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.778607594970065,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 208.56280000000004, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M., F',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.26536077017002,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 235.80230000000003, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'IKES',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.428082245640002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 264.6023, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', A.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.96189445853395,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 282.482, 151.44120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'F',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98530728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16300000000004, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ROST',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.50229098983,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 97.68292000000004, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', C., F',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.30564148413999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 117.12242000000003, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'URMAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.57858944347,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 141.96262000000004, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. J., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.63423928818798,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 171.00212000000005, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HEMAWAT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.982370756440005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 204.12282000000005, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.833870655976003,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 242.04232000000005, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UBAREV',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.698527136540058,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 267.36262000000005, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 298.44232000000005, 140.52090000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'A., H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.43388813982799,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16332000000006, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EISER',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.94423157476001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 115.08362000000005, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', C., H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.073753712760002,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 137.52342000000004, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OCHSCHILD',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 44.89850951245005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 166.08362000000005, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', P., H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.033863707325967,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 211.44302000000005, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'SIEH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.41882966395004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 237.96332000000004, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', W., K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.873714149049967,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 255.84302000000002, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.818820901900004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 286.20322000000004, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9858045399999997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 297.48292000000004, 129.60100000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 92.16292000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'THAK',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.378592470400008,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 92.16292000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.233509759770005,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 114.00242000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OGAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.098506305700013,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 141.48212000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', E., L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.71831860109202,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 164.04152000000005, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'I',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3886423,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 191.28132000000005, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', H., L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.678446641234004,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 194.16140000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'LOYD',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.018819901420017,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 222.36140000000003, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', A., M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.171476869193953,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 243.84110000000004, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ELNIK',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.538739256450015,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 274.4415, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 298.4415, 118.56120000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'S., M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.531208592984,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16350000000003, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'WAURA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.739136613980005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 114.12370000000003, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., N',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.754081904359968,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 142.32370000000003, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AGLE',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.34252783915001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 169.32370000000003, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., Q',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.634210370139986,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 190.20340000000004, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UINLAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.89850224944004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 217.20340000000004, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.70080061039598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 247.56280000000004, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.459054788709999,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 272.76320000000004, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.881825843046038,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 283.6831, 107.64130000000014 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16310000000001, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OLIG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.61882903991,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.28302000000001, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L., S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.90525380043198,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 117.36272000000001, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AITO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.498907002180008,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 142.80252000000002, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', Y., S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.54549752896799,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 161.76232000000002, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ZYMANIAK',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.37819491961004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 186.84242, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M., T',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.798750354970007,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 229.68152, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AYLOR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.903985773490046,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 257.28192, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', C.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.881825843046038,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 283.68152000000003, 96.72100000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'W',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.464262719999999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.16352000000003, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ANG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 100.20336000000003, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.081852966639993,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 117.12286000000003, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.358347033360019,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 135.20471296664002, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 139.56306000000004, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.541336396200023,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 156.0217236038, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'W',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.464262719999999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 160.56306000000004, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OODFORD',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.458268204940026,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 169.44314000000003, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.681822032039996,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 207.36224000000004, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.278320360199984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 223.04406203204002, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Spanner: Google’s',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 68.1680851091702,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 232.32238239224, 85.68120000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'globally-distributed database. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.92349971291019,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92324000000005, 74.76130000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.356500287089915,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 208.84673971291014, 74.76130000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. OSDI’12, USENIX',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 89.47866788837774,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 211.20324000000005, 74.76130000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Conference on Operating Systems Design and Implemen-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6659617442195,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92324000000005, 63.84140000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.923197378882183,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92324000000005, 52.80160000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2370026211178384,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 112.84643737888221, 52.80160000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2012), USENIX, pp. 251–264.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.5213106628059,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 115.08344000000005, 52.80160000000015 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[7] C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.70054029323245,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.04344000000003, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OUSINEAU',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.61843435835999,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.24344, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., D',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.713935573274004,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 385.32274, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OLIGEZ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.382441023970014,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 413.52314, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.478834661033986,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 442.44264, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.74216440346601,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 469.44264, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L., M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.25156330462597,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 501.12194, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ERZ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.58275018794004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 529.80244, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 544.9223400000001, 698.0416000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'S., R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.900487682556026,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.7633400000001, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ICKETTS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.548015132930054,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 359.16334000000006, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.241894144533948,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 392.16334000000006, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.398305855465992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 409.40523414453406, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.458712380880005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 412.80354000000005, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.4607876191199693,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 429.2622523808801, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'V',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 432.7230400000001, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ANZETTO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.018479986390034,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 438.6031200000001, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', H.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.481725867319959,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 475.0824200000001, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.038381711859984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 489.5641458673201, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'TLA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.5136993739056,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 495.6025275791801, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '+',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.41868145,
  height: 6.97385,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 513.1234200000001, 690.3619300000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f16',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.4613985500000126,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 6.97385, 0, 0, 6.97385, 518.5421014500001, 690.3619300000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f16',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'proofs.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.041565030987197,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 522.0035000000001, 687.1217000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5235000000001, 676.2018000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0769964376140138,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 346.0067035623861, 676.2018000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. FM’12, Symposium on Formal Methods',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 168.72773841290086,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 349.08370000000014, 676.2018000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2322615870992877,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 517.8114384129009, 676.2018000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2012),',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.001579269834224,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 521.0437000000002, 676.2018000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'D. Giannakopoulou and D. M´',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.4257296348208,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5237000000002, 665.1620000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ery, Eds., vol. 7436 of',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 80.98540131413468,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 447.4835561432408, 665.1620000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.774742542624722,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 528.4689574573755, 665.1620000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Lec-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.945855023899975,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 531.2437000000002, 665.1620000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ture Notes in Computer Science',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 113.66113521568687,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5237000000002, 654.2417000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', Springer, pp. 147–154.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.36166202191879,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 452.1637000000002, 654.2417000000002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[8] G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.19369119323245,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.0437000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HEMAWAT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.982370756440005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.72380000000015, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.953795988476006,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 383.6433000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OBIOFF',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.388160274067996,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 409.0835000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', H.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.122049509453976,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 436.9233000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0384504905459835,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 454.04534950945424, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.458712380880005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 457.0838000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9810876191199327,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 473.5425123808803, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.47845818,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 476.5236000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EUNG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.37863479169002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 482.5236000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S.-T. The',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.86136709579719,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 504.3631000000002, 638.5218000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Google file system. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.44334373003056,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5241000000002, 627.6019000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.8367562699695554,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 421.96744373003065, 627.6019000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. SOSP’03, ACM Symposium',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 122.27318407934082,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 424.8042000000002, 627.6019000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'on Operating Systems Principles',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.64751843688563,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5241000000002, 616.6820000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.9124815631145111,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 455.1716184368857, 616.6820000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2003), ACM, pp. 29–43.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 89.96140455320068,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 457.0841000000002, 616.6820000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[9] G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.19369119323245,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 323.0441000000002, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'RAY',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.378986524550047,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.72420000000017, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', C.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.041980893966006,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 360.48440000000016, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.198219106033946,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.52638089396623, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 378.7246000000002, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.381136396199963,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 395.18326360380024, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 397.5644000000002, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HERITON',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.33877237483002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 404.0444800000002, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D. Leases: An efficient fault-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 108.34606252860965,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 438.8440800000002, 600.9621000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tolerant mechanism for distributed file cache consistency.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.52153491759685,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5240800000002, 590.0418000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5240800000002, 579.1219000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.75663643761402,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 346.0072835623862, 579.1219000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proceedings of the 12th ACM Ssymposium on Operating',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 199.36316986450552,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 347.7639200000002, 579.1219000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Systems Principles',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 67.44793598016145,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5240800000002, 568.0821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.271964019838606,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 405.9720159801616, 568.0821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(1989), pp. 202–210.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 75.20111495792023,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 408.2439800000002, 568.0821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[10] H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633932322696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6041800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ERLIHY',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.81882732212004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.7244800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M. P.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.841967784022057,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 373.9244800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.638532215977932,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 403.76644778402226, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.458712380880005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 407.4049800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.820987619119933,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 423.86369238088025, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'W',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.464262719999999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 427.6846800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ING',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.698943211909985,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 436.6846800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. M.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.601736831694016,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 450.8444800000002, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.118561510459983,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 477.44621683169424, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Linearizability: a',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 62.661030973486056,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 484.5647783421542, 552.4821000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'correctness condition for concurrent objects.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 160.2819466867596,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5244800000002, 541.4423 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.998053313240632,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 498.8064266867596, 541.4423 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ACM Trans-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 44.38599751114099,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 502.80448000000024, 541.4423 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'actions on Programming Languages and Systems 12',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 188.44259554277042,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52448000000027, 530.522 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3574044572299044,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 526.9670755427703, 530.522 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(July',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.923140885468765,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 529.3244800000002, 530.522 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '1990), 463–492.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 58.76157867264352,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5244800000002, 519.6021000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[11] H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633932322696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6045800000002, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UNT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.662449503800008,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.7248800000002, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', P., K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.47402741062601,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 361.3244800000002, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ONAR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.46414173024003,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 386.04478000000023, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M., J',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.568002881493985,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 408.00458000000026, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UNQUEIRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.69860853344001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 434.0447800000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', F. P.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.041882602233997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 475.2041800000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.1585173977659906,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 500.2460626022343, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45871238087995,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 503.4045800000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.2209876191200237,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 519.8632923808802, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 523.0842800000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EED',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.018823021620028,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 529.5643600000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 545.0440600000003, 503.88220000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'B.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.72168210997202,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.7650600000003, 492.9623000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.118561510459983,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 347.48674210997234, 492.9623000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ZooKeeper: wait-free coordination for internet-scale',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 192.50084931959282,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 354.6053036204323, 492.9623000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'systems. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.72308338966937,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248260000003, 481.92210000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.8769166103306816,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 379.24790938966964, 481.92210000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc ATC’10, USENIX Annual Technical Con-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 166.0656424364896,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 381.1248260000003, 481.92210000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ference',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.941083283301857,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248260000003, 471.0022000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.378816716698225,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 364.4659092833021, 471.0022000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2010), USENIX, pp. 145–158.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.52114888241148,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 366.8447260000003, 471.0022000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[12] J',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.648127782696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6049260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UNQUEIRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.698510979280016,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 342.7252260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', F. P., R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.421189619913974,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 383.8846260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EED',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.018823021620028,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 421.8053260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', B. C.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.922068678478034,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 437.2850260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.358431321521891,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 468.2070946784784, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.458712380880005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 472.5655260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.301087619119926,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 489.0242383808804, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98530728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 493.3253260000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ERAFINI',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.708236782168026,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 498.8452460000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.881451945000027,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 530.0448460000003, 455.40220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Zab: High-performance broadcast for primary-backup sys-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6663574843673,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52484600000037, 444.36240000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tems. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.683211193740426,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52484600000037, 433.44250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.116788806259592,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 368.2080571937408, 433.44250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. DSN’11, IEEE/IFIP Int’l Conf. on Depend-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 176.74549973469,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 370.3248460000004, 433.44250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'able Systems & Networks',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 90.60811519239903,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52484600000037, 422.52220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.032084807601052,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 429.1329611923993, 422.52220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2011), IEEE Computer Society,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 116.00167303542442,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.16504600000036, 422.52220000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pp. 245–256.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.76154065224731,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52484600000037, 411.48240000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[13] K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633932322696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6049460000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'IRSCH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.059083384480015,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.72524600000037, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.722063406753996,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 369.2451460000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.518536593245983,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 383.9672094067544, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 387.4857460000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.7011363961999564,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 403.94440960380047, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 407.6455460000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'MIR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.504381201200008,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 414.6057060000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', Y.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.761901294368009,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 429.6057060000004, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.51855826000002,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 443.36760729436844, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Paxos for system builders.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 97.28157486690215,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 449.88616555436846, 395.8824 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Tech.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.521516010433015,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248060000004, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.558545886160005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 358.0463220104334, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Rep.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.641608901423016,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 363.6048678965934, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.678327756580018,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 380.24647679801643, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'CNDS-2008-2,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 54.44153743520147,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 385.92480455459645, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.678327756580018,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 440.36634198979783, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Johns',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.287864726215115,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 446.04466974637785, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.751905870860014,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 466.3325344725929, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Hopkins',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.247852754058968,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 472.0844403434529, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.752049332939976,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 502.3322930975118, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'University,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.08134223333946,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 508.0843424304518, 384.8422 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '2008.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 20.001649788940433,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248060000004, 373.9223 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[14] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6049060000004, 358.2024 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7651060000004, 358.2024 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L. Time, clocks, and the ordering of events in',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 170.8030548905718,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4444060000004, 358.2024 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'a distributed system.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.4015806129745,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52490600000044, 347.2825 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9183193870255764,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 411.9264866129749, 347.2825 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Commununications of the ACM 21',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 123.52334311222005,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 414.84480600000046, 347.2825 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 7',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.923027552699981,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 538.3248060000004, 347.2825 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(July 1978), 558–565.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 78.92170580292677,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248060000004, 336.36260000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[15] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6049060000004, 320.64230000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7651060000004, 320.64230000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L. The part-time parliament.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 112.16185316905629,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4444060000004, 320.64230000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.318146830943704,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 488.6062591690567, 320.64230000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ACM Transac-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 53.146154985339564,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 493.92440600000043, 320.64230000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tions on Computer Systems 16',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 108.52362256818753,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52440600000045, 309.72240000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 2 (May 1998), 133–169.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 91.76130285247733,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 447.0044060000005, 309.72240000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[16] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6044060000005, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.76460600000047, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.521582584331956,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4439060000005, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.438477091580012,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 389.9654885843325, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Paxos made simple.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 72.68140833277235,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 395.4039656759125, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.318331991315802,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 468.0853740086847, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ACM SIGACT News',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.80788596277117,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 473.4037060000005, 294.00250000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '32',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.923191458126423,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5247060000005, 283.08260000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 4 (Dec. 2001), 18–25.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.00173161813589,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 347.4047860000005, 283.08260000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[17] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6047860000005, 267.3627000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7649860000005, 267.3627000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.76150498037197,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4442860000005, 267.3627000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.038495019627987,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 390.2057909803725, 267.3627000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Specifying Systems, The TLA+ Language',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 150.74070097852018,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 396.2442860000005, 267.3627000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and Tools for Hardware and Software Engineers',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 170.76756237197984,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5247860000005, 256.4428000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '. Addison-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.785846708459296,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 509.2847860000005, 256.4428000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Wesley, 2002.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 49.88134330298908,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5247860000005, 245.5225000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[18] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.60488600000053, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7650860000005, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.76150498037197,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4443860000005, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.158405674540006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 390.20589098037254, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Generalized consensus and Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 125.36152845484388,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 396.36429665491255, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.918456379360009,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 521.7258251097561, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Tech.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.521540488650384,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 527.6442814891161, 229.8026000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Rep. MSR-TR-2005-33, Microsoft Research, 2005.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 184.64186851935384,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5248860000005, 218.88270000000009 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[19] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6049860000005, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPORT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.742164475197004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7651860000005, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', L.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.641579647871996,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 376.4444860000005, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.678327756580018,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 390.08606564787254, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Fast paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.76131468006585,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 395.76439340445256, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.558577915482147,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 436.5257080845183, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Distributed Computing 19',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 95.44269106120865,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 442.0842860000005, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 2',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.763168392320043,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 537.4842860000005, 203.1628000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(2006), 79–103.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 57.32155975322831,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52528600000045, 192.24290000000008 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[20] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.60538600000046, 176.52260000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPSON',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.17822461249,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.76558600000044, 176.52260000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', B. W. How to build a highly available system',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 169.69537171659013,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 377.4046860000004, 176.52260000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'using consensus. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 72.52352678944787,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5253860000004, 165.60270000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4764732105522853,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 411.04891278944814, 165.60270000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Distributed Algorithms',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.16757079681135,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 413.5253860000004, 165.60270000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', O. Baboaglu',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.44317294377492,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 496.68518600000044, 165.60270000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and K. Marzullo, Eds. Springer-Verlag, 1996, pp. 1–17.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 198.92100982609534,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5251860000004, 154.68280000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[21] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.60528600000043, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMPSON',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.17822461249,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7654860000004, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', B. W.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.561526055488027,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 377.4045860000004, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.878350509799986,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 407.9661120554885, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The ABCD’s of Paxos.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 88.6416754585988,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 417.8444625652885, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.758290681600045,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 506.48613802388724, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 516.2444287054873, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.156953732127022,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 523.7276322678733, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.281416976706964,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 527.8845860000004, 138.96290000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'PODC’01, ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.72270985564285,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5255860000003, 128.04300000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Computing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.76324951852241,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5255860000003, 117.12310000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3566504814776863,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 378.28883551852266, 117.12310000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2001), ACM, pp. 13–13.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 90.80134956708152,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 380.64548600000035, 117.12310000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[22] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638664142696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.60568600000033, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ISKOV',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.178982468289984,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.7658860000003, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', B.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.721670792126012,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 367.3260860000003, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.8783292078739464,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 385.0477567921264, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 388.92608600000034, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.060836396199932,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 405.3847496038004, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 409.44558600000033, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OWLING',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.218908564689993,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 415.9256660000003, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.201730551693995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 447.60536600000034, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.838481127039984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 459.80709655169437, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Viewstamped replica-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 79.54579318941907,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 467.64557767873436, 101.40320000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tion revisited. Tech. Rep. MIT-CSAIL-TR-2012-021, MIT,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.64127045873173,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52536600000036, 90.48330000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'July 2012.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.161836612162325,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.52536600000036, 79.44350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[23] LogCabin',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 55.72318505865027,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.6054660000004, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.276907781259979,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 374.32865105865056, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'source',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.30110429088229,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 381.60555883991054, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.298929210539995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 404.90666313079277, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'code.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.04160477747711,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 412.20559234133276, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.118268881190545,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 431.2471971188098, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'http://github.com/',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 97.17972627653214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 450.36546600000037, 63.84350000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'logcabin/logcabin',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 91.77975673848323,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5254660000004, 52.80330000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 430.3254660000004, 52.80330000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5654660000004, 22.923200000000044 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '17',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5654660000004, 22.923200000000044 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}

# Page 18
Size: NaNxNaN
pagex: PDFPageProxy {
  _pageIndex: 17,
  _pageInfo: {
    rotate: 0,
    ref: { num: 21, gen: 0 },
    userUnit: 1,
    view: [ 0, 0, 612, 792 ]
  },
  _transport: <ref *1> WorkerTransport {
    messageHandler: MessageHandler {
      sourceName: 'd0',
      targetName: 'd0_worker',
      comObj: LoopbackPort {},
      callbackId: 20,
      streamId: 18,
      streamSinks: [Object: null prototype],
      streamControllers: [Object: null prototype] {},
      callbackCapabilities: [Object: null prototype] {},
      actionHandler: [Object: null prototype],
      _onComObjOnMessage: [Function (anonymous)]
    },
    loadingTask: PDFDocumentLoadingTask {
      _capability: [PromiseCapability],
      _transport: [Circular *1],
      _worker: [PDFWorker],
      docId: 'd0',
      destroyed: false,
      onPassword: null,
      onProgress: null
    },
    commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
    fontLoader: FontLoader {
      _document: undefined,
      nativeFontFaces: Set(0) {},
      styleElement: null,
      loadingRequests: [],
      loadTestFontId: 0
    },
    _params: {
      ignoreErrors: true,
      isEvalSupported: true,
      disableFontFace: true,
      fontExtraProperties: false,
      enableXfa: false,
      ownerDocument: undefined,
      disableAutoFetch: false,
      pdfBug: false,
      styleElement: null
    },
    canvasFactory: NodeCanvasFactory {},
    filterFactory: NodeFilterFactory {},
    cMapReaderFactory: NodeCMapReaderFactory { baseUrl: null, isCompressed: true },
    standardFontDataFactory: NodeStandardFontDataFactory { baseUrl: null },
    destroyed: false,
    destroyCapability: null,
    _networkStream: PDFNodeStream {
      source: [Object],
      url: [Url],
      isHttp: false,
      isFsUrl: true,
      httpHeaders: {},
      _fullRequestReader: [PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader],
      _rangeRequestReaders: [Array]
    },
    _fullReader: PDFNodeStreamFsFullReader {
      _url: [Url],
      _done: false,
      _storedError: null,
      onProgress: [Function (anonymous)],
      _contentLength: 567533,
      _loaded: 524288,
      _filename: null,
      _disableRange: false,
      _rangeChunkSize: 65536,
      _isStreamingSupported: true,
      _isRangeSupported: true,
      _readableStream: [ReadStream],
      _readCapability: [PromiseCapability],
      _headersCapability: [PromiseCapability]
    },
    _lastProgress: { loaded: 524288, total: 567533 },
    downloadInfoCapability: PromiseCapability {
      resolve: [Function (anonymous)],
      reject: [Function (anonymous)],
      promise: [Promise]
    },
    _numPages: 18,
    _htmlForXfa: null
  },
  _stats: null,
  _pdfBug: false,
  commonObjs: PDFObjects {},
  objs: PDFObjects {},
  _maybeCleanupAfterRender: false,
  _intentStates: Map(0) {},
  destroyed: false
}
{
  str: '[24] L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.638633657004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 72, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ORCH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.3789726447,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 98.1602, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. R., A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.114005288940014,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 120, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'DYA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.25905300986,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 156.6004, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', A., B',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.62084149756,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 172.3203, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OLOSKY',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.45828423672004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 199.44060000000002, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', W. J., C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.30088052634996,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 230.2801, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HAIKEN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.89850224944001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 268.08050000000003, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 298.4399, 698.04 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'R., D',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.833894752385994,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 92.15990000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OUCEUR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 31.903984087910025,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 114.48020000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. R.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.56194377597999,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 146.87980000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.878256224020049,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 174.44174377597997, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 178.32000000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.9409363962000157,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 194.7786636038, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'H',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 198.7196, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OWELL',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.822603086510025,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 205.67976000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.081829428420004,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 233.03956000000002, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.598244907700007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 245.12138942842, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The SMART',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 47.958534799175965,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 252.71963433612, 687.1201 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'way to migrate replicated stateful services.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 157.16188206529316,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91956000000002, 676.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.798244122699998,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 249.081442065293, 676.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 254.879686187993, 676.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.956670249621027,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 262.362889750379, 676.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. Eu-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.26566012195621,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 265.31956, 676.2002 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'roSys’06, ACM SIGOPS/EuroSys European Conference on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.60341684122693,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91956000000002, 665.1604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Computer Systems',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 66.48812468635919,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91956000000002, 654.2401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.272075313640869,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 158.40768468635915, 654.2401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2006), ACM, pp. 103–115.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 99.68147487442126,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 160.67976000000002, 654.2401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[25] M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.131287297004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99966000000002, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.459054788709999,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 100.55986000000001, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 111.47976000000001, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.6783367229599975,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 113.72135500000002, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Y.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.761920907588012,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 119.39969172296001, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.558411390460009,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 130.16161263054803, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'J',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.48792182,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 135.72002402100804, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UNQUEIRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.698510979280044,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 139.68016, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 180.83956, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.43849502434,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 183.081155, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'F.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.041599484368001,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 188.51965002434, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.558411390460009,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 195.561249508708, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'P.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.561906336925992,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 201.119660899168, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.558392763906028,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 210.68156723609397, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 216.23996, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.621036396200026,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 232.69862360379997, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.97111182,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 238.31966, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ARZULLO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.49851890190007,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 246.71966, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', K.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.761903200459948,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 283.67906, 639.3604 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Mencius: building efficient replicated state machines for',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.66576764002522,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92006, 628.3202 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'WANs.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.121465266825144,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92006, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.358292251600005,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 118.04152526682515, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483191368109191,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 131.39981751842515, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.356551113465656,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 138.88300888653436, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.281454007856382,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 144.23956, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.43849502434,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 163.52101400785637, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OSDI’08,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.52160369186106,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 168.95950903219637, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.438575721760003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 203.48111272405745, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'USENIX',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.91846959147875,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 208.91968844581746, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.441704988379996,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 239.8381580372962, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Conference',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.821193125108614,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 245.2798630256762, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.498758064319986,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 286.10105615078476, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'on',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.923191458126423,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 291.59981421510474, 617.3999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Operating Systems Design and Implementation',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 178.00332327402506,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92006, 606.48 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.516676725975003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 269.923383274025, 606.48 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2008),',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.001652435495032,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 274.44006, 606.48 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'USENIX, pp. 369–384.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 84.0813791275872,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92006, 595.4398 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[26] M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.131287297004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 72.00016000000001, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AZI',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.948407412710004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 100.56036, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.2113925872899927,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 113.50876741271001, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '`',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9858045399999997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 114.72016, 581.280022 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ERES',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.10816429302001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 114.00023800000001, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 133.56003800000002, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.758417891379992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 135.801633, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'D.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.201760027931991,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 142.56005089138, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.43853313439999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 151.76181091931198, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Paxos',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.2478544868448,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 169.20034405371197, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.7119272110799955,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 190.44819854055677, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'made',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.341100878202806,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 197.16012575163677, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.698755598860004,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 216.50122662983955, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'practical.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.081591264104965,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 223.19998222869955, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.43846450719559,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 256.28157349280445, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'http:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.979804065066457,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 273.72003800000005, 580.5601 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '//www.scs.stanford.edu/˜dm/home/',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 172.2997061138661,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.92003800000003, 569.5199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'papers/paxos.pdf',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.37990286673589,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91995800000001, 558.6 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', Jan. 2007.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.64149591299222,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 178.319958, 558.6 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[27] M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.131287297004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99995800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ORARU',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.778580337190004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 100.56015800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', I., A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.753823559800026,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 127.79965800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'NDERSEN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.01842762276004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 152.03985800000004, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D. G.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.84193012522597,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 188.51915800000003, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.3982698747740585,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 218.36108812522596, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 221.75935800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.3409363962000214,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 238.2180216038, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 241.55895800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AMINSKY',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.25828532711,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 248.51911800000002, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.161507222555986,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 284.15861800000005, 543.7199 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'There is more consensus in egalitarian parliaments.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 193.04158172278468,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91961800000004, 532.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.19841851937997,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 284.9611997227847, 532.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 293.1596182421647, 532.6801 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91961800000004, 521.7598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Proc. SOSP’13, ACM Symposium on Operating System',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.6737230427475,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91961800000004, 521.7598 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Principles',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 36.84794012856869,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91961800000004, 510.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2719598714313065,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 128.76755812856874, 510.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2013), ACM.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 50.60146470795097,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 131.03951800000004, 510.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[28] Raft user study.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 81.56156396440926,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99971800000004, 495.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.518536035590728,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 153.56128196440932, 495.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'http://ramcloud.stanford.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 134.9797575560593,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 166.07981800000005, 495.83950000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'edu/˜ongaro/userstudy/',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 118.65998298014088,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91961800000004, 484.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 210.59969800000005, 484.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[29] O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633901837004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99969800000005, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'KI',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.028485001900005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 99.11999800000005, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 107.63991800000005, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.51856722638,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 109.88151300000006, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'B.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.721682109972006,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 116.40008022638006, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.51856722638,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 125.12176233635206, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'M.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.401763055115982,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 131.64032956273206, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.518525382152006,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 145.04209261784803, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 151.56061800000003, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.460836396200023,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 168.0192816038, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.47845818,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 174.48011800000003, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ISKOV',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 23.178982468290013,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 180.48011800000003, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 203.04031800000004, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.518558259999992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 205.28191300000003, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'B.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.721682109971992,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 211.80047126000002, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.518558259999992,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 220.52215336997202, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'H.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.201747475,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 227.040711629972, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.758412850000013,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 236.242459104972, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Viewstamped',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 48.52304186379468,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 252.000871954972, 469.91920000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'replication:',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 40.772665193608816,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000005, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.787511365840004,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 132.69198319360885, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 138.47949455944885, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.76612654953999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 144.95322091944885, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'new',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.633886949868387,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 150.71934746898884, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.76612654953999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 165.35323441885723, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'primary',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.36319383898798,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 171.11936096839722, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.836817489460003,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 199.48255480738518, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'copy',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 17.2031276419488,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 205.3193722968452, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.836745758419994,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 222.522499938794, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'method',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.803217128777174,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 228.359245697214, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.836674027380013,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 255.16246282599116, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'to',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.0031874227842135,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 260.99913685337117, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.716748694879982,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 268.0023242761554, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'support',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.732709174740318,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 273.71907297103536, 458.99930000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'highly-available distributed systems. In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 145.12304354179886,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000005, 447.95950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.8369564582012856,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 237.04236154179878, 447.95950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. PODC’88,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 60.681296268010136,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 239.87931800000007, 447.95950000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed Computing',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 208.60361156410127,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000006, 437.03960000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000006, 426.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '(1988), ACM, pp. 8–17.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 86.36140271420933,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000006, 426.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[30] O’N',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.0741404125222,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99941800000006, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EIL',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.182772238009996,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 109.55991800000007, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', P., C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.420827710719998,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 122.27981800000006, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HENG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.378586014610022,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 145.20011800000006, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', E., G',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.59405764977201,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 167.03961800000008, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AWLICK',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.498912238740015,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 192.12011800000008, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.522046258994013,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 223.07991800000008, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.4384537410060148,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 239.60196425899406, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 242.04041800000007, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.6210363961999974,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 258.49908160380005, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ON',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 13.433878834999971,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 261.12011800000005, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EIL',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.182760043739997,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 275.04041800000005, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', E.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.681423811951962,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 287.76031800000004, 411.11930000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'The log-structured merge-tree (LSM-tree).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.60191377826024,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000003, 400.1994000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.0380862217398317,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 244.5212317782602, 400.1994000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Acta Informat-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 53.02577567605393,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 247.55931800000002, 400.1994000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'ica 33',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 22.123198141318984,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91931800000003, 389.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 4 (1996), 351–385.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 73.04151839965834,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 113.99941800000003, 389.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[31] O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633901837004206,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 71.99941800000003, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'NGARO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.13834716769001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 99.11971800000003, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.241609797471988,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 126.71891800000003, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.598190202528031,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 140.960527797472, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Consensus: Bridging Theory and Practice',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 152.78122818871518,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 145.55871800000003, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 298.318718, 374.2795000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'PhD thesis, Stanford University, 2014 (work in progress).',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 206.00176841496344,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 91.91871799999998, 363.3596000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.518718, 698.0396000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'http://ramcloud.stanford.edu/˜ongaro/',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 199.17979209760028,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.518718, 698.0396000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'thesis.pdf',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 53.979774146399535,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5187179999999, 687.1197000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 392.5187179999999, 687.1197000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[32] O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633932322696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.59881799999994, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'NGARO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.138359361960024,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.7191179999999, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.201736157153963,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 373.3183179999999, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.9982638428459722,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 391.52005415715394, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 395.5183179999999, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.181136396199918,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 411.97698160379997, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 416.1581179999999, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'USTERHOUT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.50199648072005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 423.11827799999986, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.08180521919402,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 469.55737799999986, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.078322825659995,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 481.6391832191939, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In search of an',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 57.403418875353694,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 489.7175060448539, 669.9599000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'understandable consensus algorithm.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 136.04153121462718,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.51837799999987, 658.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.518529680399979,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 474.5599092146268, 658.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 484.0784388950268, 658.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.156735542587057,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 491.5616424574128, 658.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc ATC’14,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 51.44166499467039,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 495.71837799999986, 658.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'USENIX Annual Technical Conference',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.7410755281667,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.51837799999987, 647.9998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.378924471833443,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 477.25945352816643, 647.9998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2014), USENIX.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.68140817365194,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 479.6383779999999, 647.9998 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[33] O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.633932322696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.5983779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'USTERHOUT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.50192331510006,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.7186779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 392.1577779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.238477876580021,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 394.3993729999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'J.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.961908466293972,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 401.63785087657993, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.718555794540009,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 410.59975934287394, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'A',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 418.31831513741395, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'GRAWAL',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 32.34260408939999,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 424.9182779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 457.7979779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.4783285415800265,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 460.0395729999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'P.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.56190633692602,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 467.51790154157993, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.598244907700007,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 477.07980787850596, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'E',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.47845818,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 484.67805278620597, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'RICKSON',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.33879317681996,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 490.6780779999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 525.477678, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.358403209080052,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 527.7192729999999, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'D.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.961897819453915,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 535.07767620908, 630.8396 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.758678, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OZYRAKIS',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.62769841701004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.478598, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', C., L',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.918686447126024,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 385.55789799999997, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EVERICH',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 34.098915387790065,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 413.99809799999997, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J., M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.89139188976802,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 448.55789799999997, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AZI',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 12.948431801250017,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 476.87819799999994, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 1.211768198749951,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 489.82662980124996, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '`',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9858045399999997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 491.0383979999999, 620.639622 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ERES',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.108152098750054,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 490.3184759999999, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., M',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 30.891405452153975,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 509.8782759999999, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'I',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3886423,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 541.1985759999999, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.9858045399999997,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 544.0786559999999, 619.9197 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 338.7586559999999, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'TRA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.378988676480038,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 338.7586559999999, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S., N',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.75379677347596,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 354.59845599999994, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ARAYANAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.49856025492008,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 381.59845599999994, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', A., O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.194013491233992,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 424.55785599999996, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'NGARO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.13840813904002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 453.23835599999995, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', D., P',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.70560337761393,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 480.83755599999995, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ARULKAR',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.30367714028975,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 507.35785599999997, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 545.157056, 608.8799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'G., R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.820791284653986,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.759056, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OSENBLUM',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.856202413200045,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 360.719256, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M., R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 29.260654056033975,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 404.03835599999996, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UMBLE',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 27.062442858110067,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 433.43835599999994, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', S. M., S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.905225672095995,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 461.03795599999995, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'TRATMANN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 43.21846906904986,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 501.47775599999994, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 545.1570559999999, 597.96 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'E.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.00173660370598,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.7590559999999, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.678363396293946,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 349.7607926037059, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45866360380001,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 352.43915599999985, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.7409363961999134,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 368.8978196037999, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.98530728,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 371.63875599999983, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'TUTSMAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.57821391390004,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 377.15867599999984, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R. The case for RAMCloud.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 108.44176308740667,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 415.19777599999986, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.6382369125933565,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 523.6395390874065, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.905815900072643,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 527.2777759999999, 587.0397 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'munications of the ACM 54',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 98.32324845692835,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5187759999999, 575.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.2367515430717617,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 436.84202445692813, 575.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(July 2011), 121–130.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 78.92139497439743,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 439.0787759999999, 575.9999 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[34] Raft consensus algorithm website.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 142.88136650838837,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.5987759999999, 558.8401 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.51867599999986, 547.9198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'http://raftconsensus.github.io',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 161.97963017284204,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.51867599999986, 547.9198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f17',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 500.51867599999986, 547.9198 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[35] R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.140781422696215,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.59867599999984, 530.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'EED',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.018823021620028,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.23887599999983, 530.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', B. Personal communications, May 17, 2013.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 165.80112069622243,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 360.7185759999998, 530.76 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[36] R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 26.140781422696215,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.59867599999984, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'OSENBLUM',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 42.856202413200045,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.87877599999985, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', M.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.081812617930012,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 388.19787599999984, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.678387382069957,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 406.2796886179299, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.458712380880005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 408.95807599999983, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.620987619119944,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 425.4167883808799, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'O',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 428.03777599999984, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'USTERHOUT',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 46.50199648072005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 434.9979359999998, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', J. K. The design',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 65.68363911409458,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 481.4370359999998, 513.4799 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'and implementation of a log-structured file system.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 185.48158978618818,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5190359999998, 502.56000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.598410213812031,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 524.0006257861878, 502.56000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ACM',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 18.749073491744227,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 528.5990359999998, 502.56000000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Trans. Comput. Syst. 10',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 85.48340033080483,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5190359999998, 491.6401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.3567996691952544,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 424.0024363308045, 491.6401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(February 1992), 26–52.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 87.44153525998661,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 426.3592359999998, 491.6401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[37] S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.145513242696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.5992359999998, 474.4799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'CHNEIDER',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 39.70399222592005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.2793359999998, 474.4799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', F. B.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 24.561837859879994,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 384.47893599999975, 474.4799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.038408611000023,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 409.0407738598798, 474.4799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Implementing fault-tolerant services',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 132.00786643482922,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 415.0791824708798, 474.4799000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'using the state machine approach: a tutorial.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 161.96142282642032,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5191359999998, 463.4401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.318577173579797,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 500.48055882641995, 463.4401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ACM Com-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 41.38589631135686,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 505.79913599999975, 463.4401000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'puting Surveys 22',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 63.883029924346154,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5191359999998, 452.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', 4 (Dec. 1990), 299–319.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 92.00114992195881,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 402.35893599999974, 452.5198000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[38] S',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 25.145513242696214,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.59913599999976, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HVACHKO',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 37.21882510577005,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 344.27923599999974, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 381.95893599999977, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.558400743619984,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 384.2005309999998, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'K.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.961897819453972,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 392.75893174361977, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.678326076120015,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 404.7208295630738, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'K',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 6.47372636,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 413.3991556391938, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'UANG',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 21.858735395860023,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 420.35933599999976, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 442.67883599999976, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.678326076120015,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 444.9204309999998, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'H.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.961897819453972,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 453.5987570761198, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.678326076120015,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 465.5606548955738, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 474.2389809716938, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ADIA',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 19.338810302349987,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 480.71903599999973, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ',',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 2.241595,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 500.51863599999973, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.678326076120015,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 502.76023099999975, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'S.,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.521672135315887,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 511.43855707611976, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 8.558406788564184,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 521.9602292114356, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'AND',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 16.45871238087989,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 530.5186359999998, 435.36000000000007 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.7596359999998, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'C',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.7596359999998, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'HANSLER',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 35.98368614753002,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 345.23971599999976, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.801759917472008,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 381.7190159999998, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 11.43850062979999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 397.52077591747184, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'The Hadoop distributed file system.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 138.2013036036008,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 408.9592765472718, 424.31980000000004 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'In',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 7.483203562386011,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5194159999998, 413.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.996896437613998,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 346.0026195623858, 413.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Proc. MSST’10, Symposium on Mass Storage Sys-',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 196.18514973681744,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 350.9995159999998, 413.39990000000006 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'tems and Technologies',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 83.76815796483615,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5194159999998, 402.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 3.9521420351640586,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 422.28757396483576, 402.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f3',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '(2010), IEEE Computer Society,',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 120.92199199318448,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 426.2397159999998, 402.4800000000001 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'pp. 1–10.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 33.44151179965067,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5194159999998, 391.43980000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '[39]',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 14.865845496856227,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 318.5995159999998, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.294354503143779,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 333.465361496856, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'VAN',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.498897085319985,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 338.7597159999998, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 4.781202914679966,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 354.25861308531984, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'R',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 5.98057546,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 359.0398159999998, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'ENESSE',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 28.74216266394,
  height: 7.1731,
  transform: [ 7.1731, 0, 0, 7.1731, 365.5198959999998, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ', R.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 15.32168199951202,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 394.79919599999977, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: ' ',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 9.99823101039999,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 410.12087799951183, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: 'Paxos made moderately complex.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 126.92182284389813,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 420.1191090099118, 374.28000000000003 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: 'Tech. rep., Cornell University, 2012.',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 130.5214060515739,
  height: 8.96638,
  transform: [ 8.96638, 0, 0, 8.96638, 338.5194959999998, 363.36010000000005 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}
{
  str: '',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 0,
  height: 0,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5596959999998, 22.920100000000048 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: true
}
{
  str: '18',
  dir: 'ltr',
  width: 10.021306998168008,
  height: 9.96264,
  transform: [ 9.96264, 0, 0, 9.96264, 304.5596959999998, 22.920100000000048 ],
  fontName: 'g_d0_f2',
  hasEOL: false
}