-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 215
Description
When enabling VNC using raspi-config on Raspberry Pi OS (Bookworm), it installs several dependencies, such as realvnc-vnc-server, cups, and related packages. These packages are not required for VNC functionality and significantly increase the system footprint, especially for minimal setups.
I expect that enabling VNC through raspi-config should install only the essential packages required for the VNC server to run, without pulling in a large number of unrelated dependencies.
Steps to reproduce:
Run sudo raspi-config
Select "Interfacing Options" > "VNC" > Enable
Notice the installation of several packages, including:
-
Full cups printing stack (server, drivers, filters)
-
Fonts (Droid, Noto, URW)
-
Ghostscript, Poppler, QPDF
-
lynx, mailcap, and other unrelated CLI tools
-
Certificate packages (ssl-cert) and other auxiliary libraries
These packages may be justified in a full desktop environment, but in a headless or minimal X11 system, in my honest opinion ,they are completely unnecessary and clutter the system, adding attack surface, maintenance overhead, and wasted disk space.
I believe the packaging of realvnc-vnc-server should:
-
Avoid pulling in unrelated dependencies (like printing software or full font suites);
-
Be more transparent in what it will install and why;
3.Possibly offer a "minimal" variant for advanced users who know what they need;
4.Document clearly the dependencies and their necessity in the official documentation.
I’ve now removed the package and replaced it with x11vnc, which works fine and integrates cleanly with my use case — no bloat, no surprises.
I hope this feedback helps improve the experience for advanced users and those working with minimal, secure setups.
PS: It’s also worth mentioning that the VNC server doesn't even work with open-source VNC clients like TigerVNC, which is another significant issue.
This makes the experience even more frustrating, especially for users who prefer open-source tools or need compatibility across different platforms.