You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
RFC:
Author: John Bevan
Status: Draft
SupercededBy:
Version:
Area: Standard Functions
Comments Due:
Plan to implement:
Get-ChildItem; Add IncludeRoot Switch
Suggestion: Currently if you wish to fetch an item and its children you have to make a call to Get-Item and Get-ChildItem. Since this is a common use case, it would be good to reduce this to a single call. By adding an IncludeRoot switch to Get-ChildItem we could easily have it fulfill this requirement.
Here are some examples of people who've hit this scenario & tried to get creative in resolving it.
Motivation
As a PowerShell user,
I can retrieve an item and its children,
so that I have the full tree returned in a single result set.
User Experience
Example of user experience with example code/script.
Include example of input and output.
I understand your point; that the name of the command uses the world "Child". However I wouldn't use the phrase "defeats the point" as this doesn't impact the current functionality; and there's not an existing way (with a single command) to get a folder and its decedents. Rather I'd say it adds flexibility.
Perhaps adding a -IncludeDecendents switch to the Get-Item cmdlet would be more appropriate based on the function names? To me that feels less intuitive; but either option would be welcome.
In what use cases would you use this added parameter?
In most cases where I'd call GetChildItem -Path $Path -Recurse where I'm interested in folders rather than solely files, there's a 50:50 on whether or not I'd also want to include the parent... Most times I want $Path; GetChildItem -Path $Path -Recurse | % FullName though sometimes I want Get-Item -Path $Path; GetChildItem -Path $Path -Recurse.
A couple of examples I can think of when this would be useful are:
Looping through folders to report on or amend permissions
Comparing folder structures of 2 directories
.. but really most cases where you'd be interested in the folders of Get-ChildItem there's likely a case where the parent may be of equal interest to its content.
RFC:
Author: John Bevan
Status: Draft
SupercededBy:
Version:
Area: Standard Functions
Comments Due:
Plan to implement:
Get-ChildItem; Add IncludeRoot Switch
Suggestion: Currently if you wish to fetch an item and its children you have to make a call to
Get-Item
andGet-ChildItem
. Since this is a common use case, it would be good to reduce this to a single call. By adding anIncludeRoot
switch toGet-ChildItem
we could easily have it fulfill this requirement.Here are some examples of people who've hit this scenario & tried to get creative in resolving it.
Motivation
User Experience
Example of user experience with example code/script.
Include example of input and output.
Specification
Include
[Parameter()][Switch]$IncludeRoot
in the list of available parameters.Alternate Proposals and Considerations
The current workaround is to make separate calls to
Get-Item
andGet-ChildItem
.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: