405 Method Not Allowed on Unknown OData Route vs 404 Not Found on REST API in .NET 8 - Is This Expected Behavior?

[KavehRostami90]

Assemblies affected
ASP.NET Core OData 8.2.5

Describe the bug
Hello,

I am working with a .NET 8 API and have encountered an issue when sending a POST request to an unknown route. Here are the details:

When I send a POST request to an OData route that doesn't exist, e.g., {{apiUrlOData}}/Locationsdd, I receive a 405 Method Not Allowed response.
However, when I send the same request to a regular REST API route that doesn't exist, e.g., {{apiUrl}}/Locationsdd, I receive a 404 Not Found response.

This difference in behavior is unexpected. It seems that OData routing might be interpreting the route in a way that leads to the 405 response instead of a 404.

Is this difference in handling unknown routes between OData and REST in .NET 8 expected? Could you please clarify why OData returns a 405 error instead of a 404, and if there is a recommended way to align these behaviors?

Request/Response
POST request to an OData route that doesn't exist, e.g., {{apiUrlOData}}/Locationsjjjjjjjj

{
"title": "Method Not Allowed",
"status": 405,
}

Expected behavior
{
"title": "Not Found",
"status": 404,
}

[xuzhg]

@KavehRostami90 What do you mean about "non-existed" OData route? Basically, OData route (endpoint) in 8.x is a normal ASP.NET Core endpoint containing 'OData routing metadata'. If it's an unknown route, why do you call its unknown OData route?

Would you please share a simple repro for us to dig more? Maybe a simple github repo can help us to figure out the root cause.

[julealgon]

@xuzhg I believe he is referring to anything sitting under the root odata folder/odata prefix defined in the AddRouteComponents call.

Apparently, any invalid URL attempted under that prefix is throwing "method not allowed" instead of "not found".

Keep me honest here @KavehRostami90 .

[KavehRostami90]

Hi @xuzhg,
Just checking in on this issue. Are there any updates or progress to share on resolving this bug?