External display audio appears but doesn't do anything

[yeremia1234]

macOS Version

Ventura

What is your CPU's model?

AMD Ryzen 5 3500u

Please describe the behaviour in detail.

I've already install nootedred kext on my mac. The graphic is working, but i have a problem. HDMI Audio appear on setting but no sound when connected to TV. Any solution?

What should've happened instead?

Fix that i trust in you

If applicable, attach the .gpuRestart, .panic, etc file related to this issue.

No response

Bug report submission terms

• I am using the latest version of NootedRed.
• I am on the latest minor and patch version of macOS (ex. 7 is the minor and 10 is the patch of macOS 11.7.10).
• The bug only happens with NootedRed enabled.
• I have ruled out any external factors that could interfere, including, but not limited to, using OCLP or WhateverGreen.

[dipol0]

Hi. Very strange. I have more simple CPU - AMD Athlon 3000G with int Radeon Vega 3 and mobo ASUS PRIME A320M-K.
When i boot MacOS 13 Ventura all audio out works - and line out on backside panel and if i connect old TV Samsung over hdmi cable. Check settings sound - may be on your system Line Out as default?
When i think this kexst project orient on graphics, no sound.

[yeremia1234]

Hi. Very strange. I have more simple CPU - AMD Athlon 3000G with int Radeon Vega 3 and mobo ASUS PRIME A320M-K. When i boot MacOS 13 Ventura all audio out works - and line out on backside panel and if i connect old TV Samsung over hdmi cable. Check settings sound - may be on your system Line Out as default? When i think this kexst project orient on graphics, no sound.

I set audio default on samsung but the sound is not appear. Only graphic show on tv but sound not show

[dipol0]

Hi. Very strange. I have more simple CPU - AMD Athlon 3000G with int Radeon Vega 3 and mobo ASUS PRIME A320M-K. When i boot MacOS 13 Ventura all audio out works - and line out on backside panel and if i connect old TV Samsung over hdmi cable. Check settings sound - may be on your system Line Out as default? When i think this kexst project orient on graphics, no sound.

I set audio default on samsung but the sound is not appear. Only graphic show on tv but sound not show

You TV correct shown in Displays? You see HDMI as out on you TV in Sound?

And! )) may be you just set low level volume on TV or mute it ? )) Check. ;)

• in my config.plist module for audio set as 4 + in boot-args alcid=11:
  
  

[VisualEhrmanntraut]

It is actually a known issue and it has no known cause or solution. The problem only appears on a very small amount of devices.

[yeremia1234]

![Screenshot 2024-02-04 at 19 34 19](https://github.com/ChefKissInc/NootedRed/assets/31928254/736c6

f36-2f12-40df-a533-d00978bc3b66)

this is the screenshot but i dont hear any sound on tv. Only picture

[yeremia1234]

[VisualEhrmanntraut]

It is actually a known issue and it has no known cause or solution. The problem only appears on a very small amount of devices.

.

[dipol0]

@yeremia1234 check cable on another devices - its work audio ? If you TV have few hdmi in - try another and in boot-arg try aclid=1

Just i have a little another issue )) Black screen on boot. It randomly )) ~ 1 normal boot after shutdown/restart per 20 cycles ))

[VisualEhrmanntraut]

Ahem. Let's see if you can ignore the developer (me) now.

It is actually a known issue and it has no known cause or solution. The problem only appears on a very small amount of devices.

We have already tried numerous things, including different AppleALC layouts, cables, changing volume, removing AppleALC. Nothing we tried works and, as mentioned previously, the cause is not known.

[VisualEhrmanntraut]

The machines affected by this issue also have the same issue on Linux 5.15. It seems to be fixed in Linux 6.x. Hopefully that gives us a clue on what's wrong.